Would The Titanic Have Sunk If It Didn't Try To Avoid The Iceberg?

Mystery Hour

Mystery Hour Question

If the Titanic had gone straight into the iceberg instead of trying to go around it, would it still have sunk?
Nigel, Covent Garden

Answer

Name: Gary, Meapham
Qualification: Genius of Titanic proportions
Answer: There is no definitive answer, but it would probably have sunk anyway. When you hit an iceberg, the ship below the water will hit the iceberg before the ship above the water line, so it would divert it off its course – it’s not like hitting a brick wall head-on. Secondly, the Titanic wasn’t build correctly, creating a structural flaw.

Name: Blair, Basildon
Qualification: Former Merchant Navy Sailor
Answer: That’s wrong – it would probably have survived. When a ship hits an iceberg head on, all the force would be transferred back to the ship, so it wouldn’t have ripped open, but crumpled round, so only 2-3 compartments would have been breached. It was built to survive with 4 compartments breached. The reason it sunk was because it tried to go around and scraped five compartments. Ships that hit harbour walls are at an angle under the water, so that the boat hits the wall, long before the bow hits, forcing it upwards and stopping it sinking. So I don’t believe it would have sunk.

(James O’Brien: I’ve no idea who is right… you both sound convincing.

Is this answer wrong? Add your answer in the comments box below.

Sadiq Khan

Mayor Sadiq Khan Says Londoners Should Be Angry With Uber, Not TfL

Nick Ferrari received this call from an angry RyanAir pilot

Furious Ryanair Pilot Calls LBC To Reveal All About Working Conditions

Archbishop Justin Welby live on LBC

Boy In A Dress Is "Not A Problem", Says Archbishop Of Canterbury

Hillsborough mum Margaret Aspinall met survivors from the Grenfell Tower

Hillsborough Hero Meets Grenfell Survivors To Give Advice On How To Get Justice

Comments

Loading...