Tim Davie had 'blind spot' on editorial failings, says man behind leaked memo which plunged BBC into chaos

Michael Prescott, a former editorial adviser whose leaked dossier sparked the resignations of top bosses at the BBC, has said the corporation is "not institutionally biased" as he faced MPs on Monday

It comes after he raised concerns about "despair at inaction by the BBC executive" over widespread evidence of alleged bias in a leaked 8,000-word memo sent to members of the BBC Board. 

The letter also accused the corporation of "effective censorship" of its reporting on transgender issues, and expressed concerns that BBC Arabic was downplaying the suffering of Israelis in the Middle East conflict.

He also raised concerns about the corporation's “doctored” Donald Trump speech which aired on an episode of Panorama and triggered the resignations of director general Tim Davie and BBC News chief executive Deborah Turness.

Mr Prescott said all the above are representative of “serious and systemic problems” at the heart of the corporation.

Pressure has also grown for BBC chairman Samir Shah to resign over his handling of the situation - and he will be questioned by MPs on Monday along with fellow board members Sir Robbie Gibb and Caroline Thomson.

Read more: BBC board member quits over 'governance issues' at top of corporation

Read more: BBC loses £1.1bn as more households opt out of paying licence fee

Caroline Daniel, also a former editorial adviser, is also facing the Culture, Media and Sport Committee.

Speaking today, Mr Prescott told the Committee there was “no party politics” behind his decision to write the memo.

He said: “I wrote that memo because I am a strong supporter of the BBC.

“The BBC employs talented professionals across all of its factual and non-factual programmes, and most people in this country, certainly myself included, might go as far as to say that they love the BBC.

“What troubled me was that during my three years on the BBC standards committee, we kept seeing incipient problems which I thought were not being tackled properly. And, indeed, I thought the problems were getting worse.”

He added: “There was no ideology at play here, no party politics. I just want (the BBC) to be impartial, accurate and fair.”

He told MPs he is a “centrist dad” when asked if he was biased and denied the BBC was institutionally bias.

He said: “I do not think it’s institutionally biased.”Referring to the “incipient problems”, he said: “We were finding the odd problem here, the odd problem there.

“And the crucial thing was, when I say odd problem here and there, every single thing we spotted, as per my memo, seemed to me to have systemic causes.

“The root of my disagreement and slight concern even today is that the BBC was not – and I hope they will change – treating these as having systemic causes.

“There’s real work that needs to be done at the BBC.”

Mr Prescott was asked if he agrees that Trump’s reputation might have been “tarnished” by the spliced edit of his speech in the programme.

In response, Mr Prescott said: “Probably not.”

He also told the Culture, Media and Sport Committee: “I can’t think of anything I agree with Donald Trump on.”

On Friday, BBC board member Shumeet Banerji stepped down over what he described as "governance issues" at the top of the corporation.

He said in a letter that he was "not consulted" about the events that sparked the departures of Mr Davie and Ms Turness.

The top executives at the BBC left in the wake of criticism that a BBC Panorama documentary misled viewers by editing a speech by US President Donald Trump.

A leaked internal memo said an edition of Panorama broadcast last October spliced together two sections of President Trump's speech to give a misleading impression of what he actually said.

The damning 19-page dossier said the Panorama episode “completely misled” viewers by showing the President telling his supporters he was going to the Capitol building with them to "fight like hell".

Earlier this year, the broadcaster also made headlines at Glastonbury 2025 where it showed rap group Bob Vylan leading chants of "death, death to the IDF."

Mr Davie later told Jewish staff at the broadcaster he was “appalled” by the stunt.

In February 2025 the BBC broadcast the documentary 'Gaza: How to Survive a War Zone,' but it later emerged that its narrator, 14-year-old Abdullah Al-Yazouri, was the son of a Hamas minister, leading to accusations of "catastrophic failures."

In 2023, Match of the Day’s Gary Lineker made a controversial tweet in which he compared the wording in the British government's Illegal Migration Bill to Germany in the 1930s.