Ministers urged to consider 'total' sunbed ban amid rising use by young people
Long-standing advice from the NHS and Cancer Research UK says there is no safe or healthy way to get a tan using UV radiation
Ministers should consider a “total ban” on commercial sunbeds, Government advisers have said amid reports of increased popularity of the products among young people.
Listen to this article
The new report from the Committee on Medical Aspects of Radiation in the Environment (Comare), which is advising Government on the health effects of radiation, says that sunbed use has “not been much reduced, despite the introduction of laws to control use”.
It says that there are also suggestions that young people are “increasingly” using them.
Meanwhile, some sunbed operators are using social media to make “false and unsubstantiated claims of health benefits” of sunbeds, the new report states.
The experts recommend that the Government should “consider whether it is appropriate to introduce a complete ban on the commercial use of sunbeds”.
Read more: Breast cancer study shows changes to lymph nodes could identify who is most at risk of spread
Sunbeds use high intensity ultraviolet (UV) radiation for tanning.
Cancer Research UK says there is “no such thing as safe UV tanning” and too much UV radiation from the sun or sunbeds causes skin cancer.
Leading skin doctors from the British Association of Dermatologists and the British Photodermatology Group have called for a complete ban on commercial sunbeds.
Since 2010 it has been illegal for children to use sunbeds.
But the new report states: “The numbers of commercial sunbed outlets in the UK do not appear to have declined appreciably since 2009, suggesting that use has also not been much reduced, despite the introduction of laws to control use.
“There are also indications of increasing use by young people.”
The authors add: “Some sunbed operators are making false and unsubstantiated claims of health benefits and this is reinforced by the prevalence of such misinformation on social media platforms.”
It comes after adverts for five tanning companies were banned earlier this year for making misleading and irresponsible claims about the safety of sunbeds.
Ads for tanning studios The Sun Company, SunShine Co and Tanbox Towcester, as well as for Tan & Deliver Home Hire Sunbeds and Byrokko, which sells products to accelerate tanning, made “a number of problematic claims” about safety, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) said.
Their misleading and irresponsible claims included that sunbed use is safe or that tanning can be achieved safely, and that sunbeds could boost vitamin D, improve mood and energy levels, and treat health conditions such as seasonal affective disorder (SAD), psoriasis and eczema.
The committee added: “Government will also wish to consider whether it is appropriate to introduce a complete ban on the commercial use of sunbeds.
“While a ban should save lives and reduce costs of cancer treatment, there are wider policy considerations, for example in relation to the constraint on freedom of individual choice, which applies to a range of self-imposed risks.
"If Government opts for a ban, this will require careful planning, with supporting public awareness campaigns and strong enforcement.”
The report highlights a study which found that banning commercial sunbeds would be cost-effective and would lead to fewer cases of skin cancer, fewer skin cancer deaths and ease the burden on the NHS.
There are currently three countries that have banned commercial sunbeds: Iran, Brazil and Australia.
These bans apply to commercial sunbeds but home or private use remains possible.
Commenting on the report, Dr Tamara Griffiths, president of the British Association of Dermatologists, said: “There is now a consensus that sunbed regulation and enforcement in the UK are not strong enough.
“Comare’s recommendations are sensible, practical steps that would strengthen protections for the public, and we welcome them.
“It is also encouraging that Comare has explicitly recommended that Government needs to consider a total ban on the commercial use of sunbeds.
“The British Association of Dermatologists believes that the case for a ban is already strong.
“Sunbed operators have demonstrated that they are not able to consistently meet existing requirements, including limits on the amount of UV radiation emitted by their machines and age restrictions.
“Some operators have also made health claims about sunbed use that are not supported by the evidence. This is not true of every operator, but it is a persistent issue.
“Stronger regulation will only protect the public if it is implemented, monitored, and enforced effectively.
“If the industry has struggled to meet existing standards consistently, the Government should be cautious about relying on tighter rules alone.
“A ban on commercial sunbeds remains the clearest and most effective way to reduce avoidable harm.
In 2023, there were almost a quarter of a million new skin cancer diagnoses in the UK, costing the NHS an estimated £750 million annually.
The Department of Health and Social Care has been approached for comment.