First small boat pilots jailed for endangering migrants in English Channel in legal landmark
Those who endanger or risk another life at sea could face up to five years in prison, or up to six years if they are in breach of a deportation order
Two small boat pilots are the first to be facing sentence under a new offence of endangering others during a Channel crossing.
Listen to this article
Afghan national Mohammad Tajik, 32, was sentenced to two years in prison at Canterbury Crown Court on Wednesday over a dangerous journey on January 17.
At the same time, Sudanese national Alnour Ali, 26, was sentenced to 27 months for a crossing on April 9.
Sentencing them, Judge Simon James said: “The inherent dangers of seeking to navigate one of the busiest shipping lanes in the world in a vessel which was never designed to undertake such a journey are obvious.
“However the risk of death and serious injury are significantly increased when boats have no navigational aids, are overcrowded, and those on board are not adequately equipped with safety equipment.”
Endangering others during a journey by sea to the UK is an offence that came into force in January as part of new border security legislation.
Tajik was the first to be convicted under the new law, having pleaded guilty at the same court on April 21.
Prosecutor Daniel Bunting said: “He was piloting and let go of the tiller with consequences no-one was in control.
“He had no experience or knowledge of piloting a boat, he was asking others to look on YouTube for assistance.”
He added the Crown’s case against him was in relation to the conditions, the time of year being very cold in January.
Of Tajik’s crossing, footage was shown to court of the boat overcrowded with people sitting around the edge “which did not appear to be a safe way of travelling”, Mr Bunting said.
He added in a police interview Tajik accepted piloting the boat but he did so to stop it going round in circles shortly before the interception around 12.15pm.
Mr Bunting told the court that in both cases, there was a lack of safety equipment expected for such a crossing.
For Ali, drone footage was played in court of the boat with 74 people on board, where Ali is seen driving while wearing a pink hat.
Passengers are seen straddling the side of the boat, with some legs dangling in the water.
A French boat comes up alongside the dinghy and hands out life-jackets, at which point Mr Bunting said Ali had the opportunity to stop.
Mr Bunting said: “The Crown say clear and obvious risk being heavily overcrowded that a wave or gust of wind could have capsized the boat.”
The boat left the French coast at 7.24am and was intercepted several hours later at just past 10am.
It was the same day that separately two men and two women drowned in the Channel.
Ali’s charge was previously referenced by the National Crime Agency in relation to this and subsequently reported by the press, the court heard.
Ali’s barrister Paul Hogben said the press release caused a “great deal of public hostility” which has had a “punitive effect” on Ali, his reputation and “any risk to his safety in the future”.
In court, Judge James made clear Ali is not being sentenced in relation to those four deaths and said misinformation was “unhelpful”.
He said it is “very important to make it absolutely clear you had no knowledge of, let alone responsibility for, others being injured or killed. I am not being invited to sentence you on that basis”.
Barrister Paul Hogben told the court Ali was of good character and was ordered to steer the boat by armed people traffickers when he embarked.
He was born in a village in the Darfur region of Sudan where he and his parents, three brothers and six sisters were forced to flee their home during the civil war.
“Because of the war in Sudan he has had no contact with family in over a year, he does not know if his parents or siblings are alive or dead,” Mr Hogben said.
“He has not previously attempted to cross the Channel, he was not paid for piloting the boat, and he was ordered to steer the boat by armed people traffickers.”
The court also heard from barrister Niall Doherty, defending Tajik, that the father-of-one left Afghanistan after witnessing the Taliban shoot and kill his father and brother for refusing to put yellow powder in food served to soldiers in their restaurant which they believed would have fatal consequences.
Tajik feared he would also be targeted and fled to seek asylum, first trying in Greece where he was refused, before travelling on to Europe and the UK.
The pair both have submitted claims for asylum since being in the UK, the court heard.
Afghan national Tajik Mohammad and Sudanese national Alnour Ali will both appear at Canterbury Crown Court on Wednesday over two separate dangerous journeys.
Endangering others during a journey by sea to the UK is a new offence that came into force in January as part of new border security legislation.
Under the offence, those who endanger or risk another life at sea could face up to five years in prison, or up to six years if they are in breach of a deportation order.
Mohammad was the first to be convicted under the new law having pleaded guilty at Canterbury Crown Court on April 21.
Read more: Two men jailed for violent disorder at protest following death of Henry Nowak
According to the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), the 32-year-old abandoned the dinghy he was driving across the English Channel and its passengers when a rescue ship arrived on January 17.
The boat was overcrowded and some passengers were not wearing life jackets during the attempted crossing in poor weather conditions, the CPS said.
Elsewhere, Ali admitted the charge of endangering others during a sea crossing on April 9 at the same court last month.
That day two men and two women drowned after being swept away by strong currents while trying to climb on to a dinghy at Equihen-Plage, near Boulogne-sur-Mer in France.
Following his conviction, National Crime Agency branch operations manager Emma Brown said: “Working with colleagues at home and abroad, we are determined to do all we can to identify and bring to justice those responsible for small boat crossings.
“The tragic deaths illustrate again how perilous these crossings are and the callous nature of the criminals organising them.”
According to the Home Office, the offence is designed to stop more people being crammed into unsafe boats and would apply to those involved in physical aggression and intimidation, as well as anyone who resists rescue.
The new charge includes physical or psychological injury and covers journeys by water to the UK from France, Belgium and the Netherlands.
The sentencing hearings for Mohammad and Ali will begin at 10am on Wednesday.