'Culture of fear and silence' stopped senior Church officials calling for Archbishop to resign, Bishop claims

17 November 2024, 09:23 | Updated: 17 November 2024, 09:24

A “culture of silence and fear" exists within the Church of England, a bishop has said.
A “culture of silence and fear" exists within the Church of England, a bishop has said. Picture: Alamy

By Henry Moore

High-ranking members of the Church of England are choosing not to expose leaders over the John Smyth abuse scandal because of a “culture of silence and fear,” the Bishop of Newcastle has said.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Bishop of Newcastle Dr Helen-Ann Hartley said her colleagues are choosing to prioritise silence and their career prospects following the resignation of the Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby.

Mr Welby resigned last week following the independent Makin Review concluded that the most prolific abuser associated with the Church of England, John Smyth, might have been brought to justice had the archbishop formally alerted authorities in 2013.

"I think it's a great disappointment to me that when I called for that publicly, I was indeed a lone voice,” Ms Hartley told Sky News.

Read more: Justin Welby's son breaks silence on former Archbishop of Canterbury's resignation following damning review into abuse

"So I have no real explanation for that other than there is a culture, I think, of silence and fear amongst the bishops, which is really unhealthy."

Other bishops may have stayed silent "because they see themselves as succeeding to be the new archbishop of Canterbury" and were "fearful of being reprimanded and rebuked", Ms Hartley added.

Welby to resign as Archbishop of Canterbury - What happens next

She said she believed "anybody" who holds public office or a role in the church, who was named in the damning review as having failed in their response to abuse and the report of abuse, should also resign.

Across five decades in three different countries and involving as many as 130 boys and young men in the UK and Africa, John Smyth is said to have subjected his victims to traumatic physical, sexual, psychological and spiritual attacks, permanently marking their lives.

He died aged 77 in Cape Town in 2018 while under investigation by Hampshire Police, and was "never brought to justice for the abuse", the Makin Review said.

In a statement announcing his resignation, Mr Welby said the Makin Review had "exposed the long-maintained conspiracy of silence" regarding Smyth's abuse.

The archbishop added that he was informed of the abuse in 2013, but was told at the time that police had already been notified - which later proved not to be the case.

Journalist says 'police were not interested' in investigating John Smyth abuse allegations

Mr Welby's son Tim has said his father was "right to resign" and his position "became untenable, simply because so many people were calling for his resignation", The Mirror reports.

Tim Welby told The Mirror: "He's definitely very embarrassed and appalled by what's happened.

"I know he's going to spend a lot of his time left in office having conversations with some of the people and trying to make sure that things are set up in the right way - so that kind of lapse cannot happen again.

"He's trying to meet with people who were the victims of Smyth but others as well. He will be doing a lot of that. That's going to be one of his primary focuses."

He said: "The frustrating thing is I don't think it ever occurred to him that it hadn't been reported to the police.

"When, as Archbishop, you are told that something has happened, it has usually gone through so many hands. It seemed utterly inconceivable that someone wouldn't have said to the police: 'This has been going on'.

"He is really, really cross that it didn't occur to him - to triple check that someone had actually done that. If you discover a crime then, of course, it gets reported. I wouldn't say he was naive so much.

"Certainly, if it had happened later on, he would have known what was going on and would have been more explicit."

He added: "It feels more like a political decision to resign where something's gone wrong in the office. The person at the top is always responsible. His position became untenable, simply because so many people were calling for his resignation."

Tim Welby said his father is "a good man and I love him a lot".

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

One lucky punter scooped £65m on the EuroMillions

Lucky UK ticket-holder claims £65m Valentine's Day EuroMillions jackpot

A life-drawing class that has been running for over 30 years has been told its models must cover-up or find a new venue.

Models at life drawing class in posh London neighbourhood told to cover up over child 'safeguarding' concerns

Exclusive
An investigation by LBC can reveal there are more than 1.1m homes sitting empty across England - the equivalent of one in every 23.

More than 1.1m homes sitting empty across England as thousands left at risk of homelessness

William Howell was found dead in the Aria Casino Hotel in August 2023

Heartbroken family of British man 'left alone to die' in Las Vegas suing ambulance company and hotel where he died

Conor Maynard shared a health update after his fall

Singer Conor Maynard gives health update after being rushed to hospital on stretcher

Lisa Smith, 43, has been named by Kent Police as the victim of the shooting on Valentine's Day

Mother-of-two shot dead at pub on Valentines’ Day is named - as tributes paid to ‘wonderful mum’

Bafta winners

Conclave and The Brutalist win big at 2025 BAFTA awards - as absent Gascón nomination met with rousing applause

Jennifer Rauchet, Pete Hegest, US defence secretary, and Wladyslaw Kosiniak-Kamysz, Minister of Defence of Poland, during a welcoming ceremony in Warsaw, Poland, on February 14, 2025.

Ukraine is the 'frontline' of Britain, Starmer says as US begins peace talks with Russia

A fire that engulfed luxury hotel Chiltern Firehouse reportedly started in a pizza oven.

Fire that engulfed celebrity haunt Chiltern Firehouse 'started in pizza oven' of luxury hotel

Julie Buckley, 54, has not been seen since late January when she went missing from the village of Christchurch, Cambridgeshire.

Man charged with murder in 'no-body' case after woman goes missing in Cambridgeshire

Exclusive
Trump is ‘shaking up our region’, says Israel's president.

Donald Trump is 'shaking up our region', says Israel's president as he 'reveals US leader's strategy' in Middle East

Exclusive
Israel must 'square the circle to get hostages out' as Israeli President labels 500 day wait 'tormenting, aching and painful’.

Israel must 'square the circle to get hostages out' says President, labelling 500 day wait 'tormenting, aching and painful’

A teacher who was knocked down by a group of kids playing playground game British Bulldog says she was left with a severe leg injury that left her out of work for months.

Summer camp teacher claiming £300k in damages after group of kids knock her down in famous playground game

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has arrived in Saudi Arabia for peace talks with Russia as the war in Ukraine rages on.

US-Russia peace talks for Ukraine begin as Europe blocked out of Saudi Arabia meeting

Harry received a standing ovation at the closing ceremony.

Meghan's four-word response as Prince Harry receives standing ovation in emotional Invictus Games closing ceremony

Exclusive
Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer (far right) visits the Tapa NATO forward operating base in Estonia.

Starmer should send 'warships, combat brigade, and air squadrons' to Ukraine, says ex-armed forces minister