Australian teenager cleared of murdering British woman who confronted intruders during home break-in

31 October 2024, 08:48 | Updated: 31 October 2024, 08:54

Emma Lovell and her husband Lee confronted two teenagers at their home in Brisbane
Emma Lovell and her husband Lee confronted two teenagers at their home in Brisbane. Picture: Handout

By Asher McShane

A teenager has been cleared of murdering a British woman who was stabbed to death during a break-in at her home in Australia.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Emma Lovell, 41, was killed in North Lakes, Queensland, on Boxing Day in 2022 while fending off two intruders.

The mother died of a single stab wound to her heart and another man, who cannot be named because he was under 18 at the time of the attack, was jailed for 14 years in May after pleading guilty to her murder.

A second man, who was 17 at the time of the attack and also cannot be named, appeared at Brisbane's Supreme Court last week.

Justice Michael Copley, who heard the case without a jury, found the man not guilty of murder on Thursday, as well as a malicious act with intent and unlawful wounding.

He found the defendant guilty of burglary and assault.

Read more: Spanish government declares three days of mourning after 95 die and dozens missing in flash floods

Read more: First case of potentially deadly mpox virus strain detected in the UK

"I am not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the accused was a party to this murder," the judge said.

Mrs Lovell had emigrated to Australia from Suffolk in 2011 with her husband Lee, who survived the attack, and their two daughters.

In his sentencing remarks in the original trial, Justice Tom Sullivan said Mrs Lovell was described as "an energetic and beloved mother, wife, daughter, and sister".

The court heard the couple had attempted to fend off the intruders after they were woken by their dogs barking at about 11.30pm.

Mr Lovell was injured during a "physical struggle directly outside the front door" which then moved to the front lawn, where his wife was fatally stabbed.

Although the defendant was found guilty of burglary, he was cleared of the circumstance of aggravation of being armed with an offensive weapon.

The prosecution argued that the accused "had knowledge at the time of the commission of all of the offences that his co-offender was in possession of a knife", according to the judgment.

But Justice Copley said he could not be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the defendant knew his co-offender, "H", was armed with a knife.

The judge also found he could not be sure to the criminal standard that the man was "a party to this murder", nor that he was a party to unlawfully wounding Mr Lovell or committing a malicious act with intent.

The defendant was convicted of assault occasioning actual bodily harm in company after the judge was satisfied that he was present on the lawn when "H" assaulted Mr Lovell "for the purpose of physically participating, if necessary, in the assault".

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Keith Edun, 47, used the messaging app “Kik” to spread vile images of children

Predator who encouraged man to rape a baby after sharing vile images of children online is jailed for 21 years

Breaking
President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelensky speaks during the 61st Munich Security Conference on February 15, 2025 in Munich, Germany.

Zelenskyy calls for creation of ‘European army’ as he warns Russia 'will pull Europe apart' if not defeated

The woman who said she was raped by rappers and business moguls Jay-Z and Sean "Diddy" Combs in 2000, when she was 13, has dropped her civil lawsuit against both men.

Woman who accused Jay-Z and Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs of raping her when she was 13 drops lawsuit

Liam Payne died last Wednesday.

One Direction star Liam Payne was 'sectioned' after near-fatal overdose months before death, close friend claims

Hamas hands over 3 Israeli hostages in the Gaza Strip to Red Cross

Hamas parades three Israeli hostages on stage before being freed - as hundreds of Palestinian prisoners released

uk british national lottery euromillions ticket with picks

Winning numbers revealed as single UK EuroMillions ticket holder scoops massive £65million Valentine’s Day jackpot

The Three Horseshoes pub in Knockholt

Manhunt launched after woman seriously injured at village pub in Valentine's Day 'shooting'

Rob and Lindsey Burrow a few weeks before he died

Rob Burrow's wife reveals heartbreaking moment she knew rugby league star 'couldn't go on' with MND struggle

Axel Rudakubana will be 'target number one' in prison

Southport killer Axel Rudakubana's sentence won't be referred to Court of Appeal despite claims it's 'unduly lenient'

The damaged shield

'Risk of radioactive leak' after Russian 'high explosive' drone hits Chernobyl, causing 'significant damage'

The fire broke out at the Chiltern Firehouse

Fire engulfs celebrity haunt Chiltern Firehouse as 100 evacuated from luxury hotel

Trump confirms he will meet Starmer in Washington 'in the next few weeks'

Trump to meet with Starmer in Washington 'in the next few weeks' - as JD Vance slams Europe in fiery speech

Both Meghan and Kate shared Valentine's pictures

Harry and Meghan share sweet Valentine's photo after William and Kate also post romantic picture

Jaden Sheriff.

Man found guilty of killing ex-girlfriend's neighbour over 'blue balls', sentenced to life imprisonment

The woman was attacked by a shark

Horror as woman loses both hands after being mauled by shark as husband desperately fights it off

United States Vice-President JD Vance, second right, meets with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, third left, during a bilateral meeting on the sidelines of the Munich Security Conference in Munich

'Putin is a liar': Zelenskyy's warning to Trump as Ukraine's leader voices concern over 'risky' phone calls with Russia