Bayesian boatbuilder 'demands £186m from Mike Lynch's widow and crew' after sinking of superyacht

22 September 2024, 18:17 | Updated: 22 September 2024, 19:09

Bayesian boatbuilder 'demands £186m from Mike Lynch's widow and crew' after sinking of superyacht
Bayesian boatbuilder 'demands £186m from Mike Lynch's widow and crew' after sinking of superyacht. Picture: Alamy

By Christian Oliver

A legal row has erupted following the sinking of Mike Lynch's superyacht with the boat's constructor demanding up to £186 million from the tech tycoon’s widow and boat's crew, according to court papers.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The legal action, lodged in a Sicilian court, argued the sinking of the Bayesian last month has caused reputational damage and loss of earnings to its builder.

The Italian Sea Group (TISG), which specialises in manufacturing superyachts, denied "authorising" their lawyer to file the case following reports that the paperwork had been lodged. The firm said he had been instructed to withdraw it immediately.

Lynch's family have reportedly found the move "disgraceful" following the 59-year-old's death alongside his 18-year-old daughter Hannah and five others.

The seven bodies have only recently been returned home and none of the victims' funerals are thought to have taken place yet.

Mike Lynch leaves the Rolls Building in London following the civil case over his £8.4 billion sale of his software firm Autonomy to Hewlett-Packard in 2011
Mike Lynch leaves the Rolls Building in London following the civil case over his £8.4 billion sale of his software firm Autonomy to Hewlett-Packard in 2011. Picture: Alamy

Read More: Second man arrested after 'shocking' kidnap of 87-year-old who was bundled into car and dumped miles from home

Read More: 'It can never feel the same again': Holly Willoughby 'moves out of family mansion' after failed kidnapper jailed

TISG said in a statement: “The Italian Sea Group… strongly denies the claims published in La Nazione regarding a legal action following the Bayesian tragedy.

"Although TISG has given a generic mandate to the lawyers named in the article, no legal representative of the company has examined, signed or authorised any writ of summons.”

The papers reportedly name James Cutfield, the yacht's New Zealand captain, and two other crew members.

Camper & Nicholsons, the yacht management company responsible for hiring the crew, were also reportedly named, according to Italian newspaper La Nazione.

Others included Revtom, the Isle of Man-based company that owned the Bayesian. The firm is controlled by Lynch’s wife, Angela Bacares, 57, who survived the tragedy.

Bacares was among the 15 passengers who survived after the 56-metre British-flagged luxury yacht went down near Sicily, in the Mediterranean on August 19.

It is thought that the yacht may have been struck by a “downburst” – a localised, powerful wind that descends from a thunderstorm and spreads out rapidly on hitting the ground.

All crew members survived except for the chef, but six passengers were trapped in the yacht’s hull and died.

TISG’s chief executive, Giovanni Costantino, publicly blamed the Bayesian crew in the hours following the disaster, before all the bodies were recovered.

“Everything that was done reveals a very long summation of errors,” he told the Corriere della Sera newspaper. “The people should not have been in the cabins, the boat should not have been at anchor.”

He claimed the yacht was "unsinkable".

A close friend of Lynch's family told The Times: “The Italian Sea Group should be ashamed. Giovanni Costantino is a disgrace, desperately trying to shift blame.

"He rushed to the media before all the bodies had even been recovered, showing his lack of decency. Now, it seems, he wants to sue his own clients.”

Emergency services at the scene of the search for the missing boat, in Porticello
Emergency services at the scene of the search for the missing boat, in Porticello. Picture: Alamy

It comes after Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE) confirmed plans to continue with its claim for up to £3 billion in damages against Lynch after his death.

The US tech giant won a UK High Court civil claim against him in 2022, accusing him and his former finance director, Sushovan Hussain, of fraud over its 11 billion dollar (£8.37 billion) takeover of his software company Autonomy in 2011.

US firm HPE is seeking damages of up to 4 billion US dollars (£3 billion), with the judge set to rule on the final sum soon.

Lynch was cleared in a separate criminal fraud trial over the Autonomy case in the US in June.

His death means Bacares, could now be liable for the damages claim in London.

HPE said: “In 2022, an English High Court judge ruled that HPE had substantially succeeded in its civil fraud claims against Dr Lynch and Mr Hussain.

“A damages hearing was held in February 2024 and the judge’s decision regarding damages due to HPE will arrive in due course.

“It is HPE’s intention to follow the proceedings through to their conclusion.”

The judge in the UK civil case has already ruled the amount payable in damages would be “substantially less” than HPE had sought, which raised questions over HPE’s reasoning for pursuing the claim after the superyacht tragedy.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Niamh Charles and Alex Greenwood of England battle for possession during a training session at St Georges Park.

England squad full of ‘winners’ ahead of Euros defence, says Lucy Bronze

Armed police descended on London Underground station following reports of 'man with firearm'

Armed police descended on London Underground station following reports of 'man with firearm'

An Israeli hospital was bombed on Thursday.

Iran’s leader ‘can no longer be allowed to exist,’ Israeli minister declares as strike launched on nuclear reactor

The technology is hoped to potentially improve treatment and quality of life for patients, by investigating a new way to scan glioblastoma brain tumour.

'Pioneering' new brain tumour scanner trialled in world-first

A local police report says a knifeman trespassed onto the self-proclaimed misogynist's property at around 2pm local time before knifing his 53-year-old worker in the arm

Andrew Tate employee stabbed during knife attack at Romanian compound

John Murray, 75, was pronounced dead at the scene, despite best efforts of emergency services.

'Defenceless' grandfather found 'beaten to death' in home as police launch murder investigation

Callaghan

'He left her completely broken': Man who raped 'bright young woman' who then took her own life jailed for decade

Bank Of England In The City Of London

Bank of England holds interest rates at 4.25% amid Middle East tensions and rising food prices

The road around Brixton Station will be pedestrianised, to make way for events and markets

Sir Sadiq Khan reveals the four London hotspots being pedestrianised this summer

Female Badger (Meles meles) in woodland, portrait. UK

Badger cull will not be extended, government confirms as it seeks 'holistic' strategy to eradicate bTB

Exclusive
The start of the Israel-Iran conflict caused the price of the benchmark Brent crude to rise more than 10 per cent last week, reaching its highest level since January

Former BP boss warns oil prices will stay 'volatile' amid escalating Middle East tensions

Qari Abdul Rauf (L) and Adil Khan (R) remain in the UK

Rochdale grooming gang ringleaders 'cannot be deported after tearing up Pakistan passports'

.

£4m Lotto win puts Harley-Davidson fan on the road to early retirement

(L-R) Alfie Williams, Jodie Comer, Danny Boyle and Aaron Taylor-Johnson attend the "28 Years Later" World Premiere at the Odeon Luxe Leicester Square

Danny Boyle opens up about returning to the world of 28 Days Later as latest zombie film opens to glowing reviews

Mudryk has denied any wrongdoing, and has denied knowingly breaking any rules

Chelsea’s Mykhailo Mudryk could face four-year ban after positive drug test

Ncuti Gatwa (left) and Dame Judi Dench (right) have signed the letter, published by refugee charity Choose Love, which calls on the Prime Minister to "use all available means" to ensure humanitarian aid gets in to Gaza.

Doctor Who star Ncuti Gatwa and Dame Judi Dench join open letter urging suspension of arms sales to Israel