Businesswoman fined after her broken-down van enters Clean Air Zone on the back of a pick-up truck

15 November 2023, 09:21

Eve Scragg received a fine after her car was taken away in a breakdown recovery vehicle.
Eve Scragg received a fine after her car was taken away in a breakdown recovery vehicle. Picture: Eve Scragg

By Emma Soteriou

A businesswoman has been fined after her broken-down van entered a Clean Air Zone on the back of a pick-up truck.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Eve Scragg was shocked to receive a fine from Bristol City Council, claiming her yellow van had been driven through the Clean Air Zone in the city centre - despite her knowing she had stayed clear. 

But photo "evidence" later revealed that the vehicle had gone through the zone at the Bath Road Bridge junction on September 25 - on the back of a pick-up truck.

Ms Scragg's van was being taken to a garage on a recovery vehicle after it had broken down.

She was able to appeal to the council and get the penalty charge notice cancelled. But she said her biggest concern was that she could have faced an even bigger fine if it had arrived while she was away.

Read more: Suella Braverman accuses Rishi Sunak of 'betraying the nation' in scathing resignation letter

Read more: Police hunt 11 men seen at pro-Palestine marches in London following Hamas' October 7 attack

"Apparently this is quite common - if your vehicle is being transported on the back of an AA truck like mine is here, the council system can't tell any different, and they evidently don't have any human sense checks in place before they send PCNs out," Ms Scragg, who is the founder of local business Fan The Flames Marketing & Design, told BristolLive.

"The result is anyone having their vehicle transported by a recovery truck is likely to get issued with a fine and threats if they don't pay up. 

"I have now appealed the fine, but have been away so nearly didn't spot the letter in time to do so, there's a limited period in which you're allowed to appeal."

She added: "I'd guess a lot of others have found themselves in a similar situation or landed with fines through no fault of their own too."

A Bristol City Council spokesperson told BristolLive that the penalty charge notice had been sent out in error and had since been cancelled.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Owen Cooper is reportedly the youngest actor to have been nominated for the award

Teen star Owen Cooper leads British Emmy charge as 'Adolescence' scores 13 nominations

Ministers are seeking to avoid a repeat of last summer's violent anti-immigration protests, which lasted six days

Fears of riots after secret Afghan resettlement scheme exposed following MoD data breach

Physician associates (PAs) should be banned from seeing patients who have not been reviewed by a medic to prevent the risk of "catastrophic" misdiagnoses, a Government-ordered report has found.

PAs should stop being used as substitutes for doctors to prevent ‘catastrophic’ misdiagnoses, report finds

Nurse Sandie Peggie's employment tribunal resumes today.

Changing room row tribunal set to resume

Yoga, tai chi, jogging and walking could be the best forms of exercise to help tackle the sleep disorder insomnia, a study suggests.

Suffering from insomnia? Try yoga, tai chi or jogging, new study suggests

Bradley Murdoch, the killer of British backpacker Peter Falconio has died after being moved to palliative care last month.

Bradley Murdoch, Australian killer of British backpacker Peter Falconio, dies aged 67

The TV chef, 59, broke his silence on Tuesday night after the show's producers Banijay UK confirmed his contract will not be renewed.

John Torode breaks silence after being axed from MasterChef over racism claim

Last week, Dylan Earl, aged 20, and Jake Reeves, 23, became the first people to be convicted under new National Security Act powers after they were recruited by the Russian mercenary group Wagner.

Teenagers targeted by Russia and Iran for sabotage missions in Britain as state-backed threats increase five-fold

Exclusive
The Conservative leader made the declaration after it was revealed that the government spent nearly two years using an unprecedented superinjunction to prevent the public from learning about the breach.

Ministers must have power to sack civil servants after 'extraordinary' MoD data breach, Badenoch tells LBC

Exclusive
Penny Mordaunt spoke with Andrew Marr about the MoD data breach.

The person responsible for the MoD data breach should lose their job, Penny Mordaunt tells LBC

Exclusive
Defence Secretary John Healey refuses to say whether anyone has lost their job over the Ministry of Defence data breach.

Nobody has been fired over £7 billion Afghan data breach, LBC understands

Exclusive
A former Afghan interpreter told LBC that the Taliban may have used the major Ministry of Defence (MoD) data breach to target Britain's allies.

Taliban has used major data breach at MoD to target those who helped Britain, says former Afghan interpreter

People search for their belongings amid the debris of destroyed houses in the aftermath of Israeli bombardment in Gaza City, on July 15, 2025.

Israeli strikes kill more than 90 Palestinians overnight, including 19 members of the same family

Dr Nooralhaq Nasimi, who came to the UK in 1999 and founded the Afghanistan and Central Asian Association (ACAA) to help others, said the Government must “accept full responsibility (and) offer meaningful compensation” to those affected.

MoD data breach has 'endangered lives' and 'betrayed' thousands of Afghans, says campaign group

MasterChef presenter John Torode will not return to the BBC cooking show after producers Banijay UK confirmed his contract will not be renewed.

MasterChef star John Torode sacked - after allegation he used 'racist language' upheld in Gregg Wallace report

Keely Hodgkinson runs at the London Athletics Meet in 2024

Keely Hodgkinson out of London Diamond League