Cambridge University votes to preserve free speech

10 December 2020, 00:03

Cambridge University has voted to uphold free speech
Cambridge University has voted to uphold free speech. Picture: PA Images
Ewan Quayle

By Ewan Quayle

Cambridge University has voted to uphold its commitment to free speech after a row about inviting controversial figures to speak at the institution.

Over 7,000 members of the university's governing body - Regent House - have backed three amendments to Cambridge's statement on freedom of speech after concerns were raised about demanding respect for opposing views.

The proposed rules would have required staff, students and visitors at the university to be "respectful" of the views and "diverse identities" of others.

But opponents of the draft statement warned that calling for respect could undermine academic freedom at the university and stifle views deemed to be disrespectful on a variety of subjects.

Actor Stephen Fry was among the alumni and academics with concerns about the changes, saying that it could lead to those with hurtful views to "demand" respect for a different opinion.

The majority (86.9%) of members on the university's governing body, the Regent House, voted to revise the wording in the freedom of speech guidelines from "respect" to "tolerate".

Cambridge University students have long been able to debate freely on controversial issues
Cambridge University students have long been able to debate freely on controversial issues. Picture: PA Images

The revised statement, which will be implemented following the ballot, also highlights that any speaker who has been invited to speak at the university "must not be stopped from doing so" as long as they remain within the law.

Vice-chancellor Professor Stephen Toope told reporters welcomed the decision to uphold the University's values.

He said: "I welcome the result of the vote by the Regent House today which is an emphatic reaffirmation of free speech in our University.

"The University will now implement the amended statement and this marks the conclusion of the democratic decision-making process on this matter.

"I would like to thank my colleagues who proposed the amendments that have now been agreed by the University’s governing body.

Students called on Cambridge University to remove a window commemorating Ronald Fisher - an advocate of eugenics
Students called on Cambridge University to remove a window commemorating Ronald Fisher - an advocate of eugenics. Picture: PA Images

He added: "Freedom of speech is a right that sits at the heart of the University. This statement is a robust defence of that right.

"The University will always be a place where anyone can express new ideas and controversial or unpopular opinions, and where those views can be robustly challenged.

"The statement also makes it clear that is unacceptable to censor or disinvite speakers whose views are lawful but may be seen as controversial.

"Rigorous debate is fundamental to the pursuit of academic excellence and the University of Cambridge will always be a place where freedom of speech is not only protected but strongly encouraged."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Keir Starmer has offered his 'hearty congratulations' to Donald Trump - but is facing pressure to apologise over past comments made by David Lammy

Starmer offers 'hearty congratulations' to Trump, but faces pressure over Lammy's past criticisms of president

Kamala Harris has conceded defeat to Donald Trump

'I concede the election but not the fight': Harris urges supporters not to despair despite defeat to Trump

Donald Trump speaks at his election night watch party, Wednesday

What does Trump's victory mean for war in the Middle East and in Ukraine?

Amy Dowden and former dance partner JB Gill

Amy Dowden gives health update after announcing she is dropping out of Strictly in 'heartbreaking' statement

Mpox only spreads between people who are in close proximity to each other.

Another case of new more infectious mpox strain detected in UK, bringing total to four

Kamala Harris spoke with Donald Trump to congratulate him on his victory

Kamala Harris calls Trump to concede defeat and urges him to govern for all Americans as president

Exclusive
FILE - Republican presidential nominee former President Donald Trump, right, and Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy shake hands during their meeting at Trump Tower, on Sept. 27, 2024, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson, File)

Trump 'is serious about ending Ukraine war', says former national security adviser as he blames Biden for the conflict

Suzy Lamplugh disappeared in 1986, with John Cannan the prime suspect

Prime suspect in disappearance of Suzy Lamplugh dies in prison 40 years after estate agent went missing

Queen Camilla will return to her royal duties next week.

Palace gives update on Camilla's return to work after Queen falls ill

Catherine Warrilow spoke out over her issue with Ryanair

Shock as Ryanair force passenger to pay over £100 for carry-on case - even though it fit in the checker

File photo of migrants being rescued in the Channel

Over 50 migrants rescued in English Channel, as 'several bodies' also pulled from the sea

JK Rowling funds a women-only rape crisis centre in Edinburgh

£70,000 payout for woman at centre of rape centre's 'trans heresy hunt'

Ukraine says forces clashed with North Korean troops for first time

Ukraine says forces clashed with North Korean troops for first time

John Swinney says he will press the new US government not to reintroduce tariffs on Scotch whisky.

Fears for Scottish whisky jobs with Trump election

Kamala Harris set to give concession speech hours after supporters are told to leave watch party amid Trump victory

Kamala Harris set to give concession speech hours after supporters are told to leave watch party amid Trump victory

Sara Sharif's father denies murdering the 10-year-old.

Sara Sharif's father accuses 'crazy' wife of abusing him before 10-year-old's death