Government ‘failed its citizens’, Covid Inquiry finds as campaigners say findings are 'no surprise'

18 July 2024, 12:01 | Updated: 18 July 2024, 15:58

The government 'failed its citizens', the Covid Inquiry has found
The government 'failed its citizens', the Covid Inquiry has found. Picture: Getty/Alamy

By Fraser Knight

The chairwoman of the UK Covid public inquiry says there needs to be a “major overhaul” to how the country prepares for whole-system civil emergencies.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Baroness Heather Hallett, in her first report, said the UK’s planning for a pandemic was “significantly flawed” before coronavirus swept across the globe in 2020.

She said the inquiry had “no hesitation” in concluding that the UK government and devolved administrations had “failed their citizens”.

It comes as Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice group, alongside medical professionals, said the findings were "no surprise" during a press conference outside St Thomas' Hospital in London.

Dr Saleyha Ashan, a trained medic who served in Bosnia and worked in a hospital in Bangor, Wales, during the Covid pandemic, said: “You can be believed, you can be a healthcare worker, but you can’t be both.”

"I’m disappointed - no, disappointed is a polite word, I’m disgusted," she said.

"I took inspiration from the blood scandal inquiry and the Post Office inquiry," she said, adding it gave campaigners "hope" of what could be achieved through a review.

The inquiry criticised the limited scope of pandemic scenario planning, the lack of economic preparation by the Treasury and a “damaging absence” of focus on the interventions and infrastructure needed to deal with a pandemic.

It said: “Had the UK been better prepared for and more resilient, some of that financial and human cost may have been avoided.

“Preparedness for and resilience to a whole-system civil emergency must be treated in much the same way as we treat a threat from a hostile state.”

Read more: Boris Johnson slammed by victims' families after telling Covid inquiry Partygate coverage is a 'travesty of the truth'

Read more: Nicola Sturgeon fights back tears at Covid Inquiry as she's grilled about her pandemic leadership

The Covid report
The Covid report. Picture: Covid-19 Inquiry

Sir Keir Starmer said the UK Covid-19 Inquiry's report confirmed that "the UK was under-prepared for Covid-19" and that policy "failed UK citizens".

The Prime Minister said in a statement: "The memories brought about by the inquiry will be very difficult for many people. My heartfelt sympathies go out to all those who lost a loved one during that time.

"The pandemic showed us that the backbone of Britain is made up of those committing their lives to service - key workers like carers, nurses, paramedics, cleaners and teachers. They put themselves in the eye of the storm, and together with people up and down the country, many of them lost their lives or are still living with the impact of the virus.

"Today's report confirms what many have always believed - that the UK was under-prepared for Covid-19, and that process, planning and policy across all four nations failed UK citizens.

"The safety and security of the country should always be the first priority, and this government is committed to learning the lessons from the inquiry and putting better measures in place to protect and prepare us from the impact of any future pandemic".

Ten recommendations have been made, which Baroness Hallett urged the governments in all regions of the UK to adopt, including the creation of a “specialised, independent, UK-wide body for civil emergencies”.

She said: “My report recommends fundamental reform of the way in which the UK government and the devolved administrations prepare for whole-system civil emergencies.

“If the reforms I recommend are implemented, the nation will be more resilient and better able to avoid the terrible losses and costs to society that the Covid-19 pandemic brought.

“I expect all my recommendations to be acted on, with a timetable to be agreed with the respective administrations. I, and my team, will be monitoring this closely.”

Boris Johnson after giving evidence to the Covid Inquiry
Boris Johnson after giving evidence to the Covid Inquiry. Picture: Alamy

The inquiry found that the only pandemic strategy formed by the government was from 2011, in which ministers had planned for 2.5% of the population to die from a flu-like disease.

The height of the outbreak was predicted to be passed in as little as 15 weeks, with between 210,000 and 315,000 additional deaths.

The report said this strategy was “outdated and lacked adaptability” and that it was “virtually abandoned on its first encounter with the pandemic”.

Pandemic preparedness and response structures in the UK
Pandemic preparedness and response structures in the UK. Picture: Covid-19 Inquiry

The inquiry has recommended a wider range of scenarios to be used in future risk assessments and a pandemic response exercise to be carried out at least every three years.

It said: “Most members of the public understand the importance of military defence and security of the country. 

“Having experienced the devastating consequences of the Covid-19 pandemic, they should also now understand the importance of building resilience to and preparedness for whole-system civil emergencies, including pandemics.”

Baroness Hallett has also called for better systems of data collection and a “radical simplification” of the systems that feed into emergency planning, describing the current set-up as “unduly complex and labyrinthe”.

Baroness Heather Hallett
Baroness Heather Hallett. Picture: Alamy

External expertise for the government has also been recommended to guard against ‘groupthink’ - where everyone in an organisation is thinking the same way.

It said Matt Hancock, as health secretary, being repeatedly told that “the UK was one of the best placed countries in the world for responding to a pandemic” was likely down to an element of groupthink in Public Health England.

The first module of the Covid-19 inquiry, which focused on the resilience and preparedness of the UK, worked through 103,000 documents and 213 witness statements.

Reports are set to be published for eight further modules, looking at decision making, procurement, vaccines, and the care sector among other things.

The inquiry chairwoman has restated her aim to finish all public hearings by summer 2026.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

A large sinkhole has forced the closure of the high street in the Surrey village of Godstone

Homes evacuated and major incident declared after 65ft sinkhole appears in Surrey village

Lydia Mugambe

United Nations judge forced woman to work as slave after tricking her to come to UK, court hears

Craig and Lindsay Foreman

Did motorbike couple's 'happiness' survey prompt arrest on spying charges in Iran?

Abdirahman Ibrahim has been convicted of murder after driving into the back of Liam Jones

Killer driver mows down e-bike rider to 'teach him lesson' for doing wheelies

The Vatican says Pope Francis is being treated for 'bilateral pneumonia'

New scans show Pope Francis has pneumonia in both lungs but Vatican says he remains ‘in good spirits’

Meghan

Meghan Markle could face 'legal action' from Spanish town as her new luxury brand logo faces resemblance to coat of arms

The father of murdered schoolgirl Sara Sharif is reportedly being protected by a 'Muslim gang'

Sara Sharif's father protected by 'Muslim gang' in jail after being attacked with jagged tuna lid

Zhenhao Zou is accused of raping three women in London and 7 in China, whilst they were unconscious

PhD student 'discussed rape role-play' with alleged victim, trial hears

Exclusive
Senior Tories including Suella Braverman and Michael Gove have criticised the judge's comments

Senior Tories blast 'out of touch' judge for 'ludicrous attack' on Starmer’s migrant remarks

Shiri Bibas and her two young sons, Ariel and Kfir, died in an airstrike, Hamas said

Bodies of youngest Israeli hostage Kfir Bibas and his brother and mother to be handed over as family ‘in turmoil’

Lisa Smith, 43, was with a female friend when she was killed outside the Three Horseshoes pub in Knockholt, Kent

Man suspected of fatally shooting wife outside pub on Valentine's Day rang friend and said 'she's dead'

Carry On legend Julian Holloway dies aged 80

Carry On legend Julian Holloway dies aged 80 after 'brief illness' as tributes pour in

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov warned 'any appearance by armed forces under some other flag' in Ukraine would be 'completely unacceptable', in a dig at a peace plan floated by Keir Starmer.

Keir Starmer’s Ukraine peacekeeping plan ‘completely unacceptable’, Russia tells US in Saudi Arabia talks

Rita Lambourne, 58, was “fatally wounded” at her home in Bayencourt South, Bexhill

Man charged with axe murder of woman in own home

Lydia Mugambe is accused of taking 'advantage of her status'

UN judge ‘trafficked woman to UK to be her slave'

Anonymous posters have appeared in Hampstead Heath, a park in north London, calling for gay men to stop using the park for sex.

'Take back Hampstead Heath', dog walkers urged as posters appear calling for men to stop using park for sex