Dad-of-two 'lawfully-killed' in 'delusional' police operation, inquiry finds

5 July 2022, 16:31 | Updated: 5 July 2022, 17:12

Jermaine Baker was "lawfully killed" by a firearms officer during a foiled prison break as part of a "delusional" police operation in north London, an inquiry has concluded
Jermaine Baker was "lawfully killed" by a firearms officer during a foiled prison break as part of a "delusional" police operation in north London, an inquiry has concluded. Picture: Alamy

By Lauren Lewis

An unarmed father-of-two was "lawfully killed" by a firearms officer during a foiled prison break as part of a "delusional" police operation in north London, an inquiry has concluded.

Jermaine Baker was fatally shot at close range as he sat in the front passenger seat of a stolen Audi A6 near Wood Green Crown Court in north London in December 2015 by police, who suspected he and other conspirators were about to free a dangerous prisoner from a custody van.

The 28-year-old, from Tottenham, was unarmed at the time he was shot by a counter-terrorism specialist firearms officer known only as W80, who told the inquiry he thought Mr Baker was reaching for a weapon.

An imitation firearm was later found in the back of the Audi.

Inquiry chairman His Honour Clement Goldstone QC concluded that, while Mr Baker was lawfully killed, there were police failings at almost every stage of the operation, which would "serve as a loud wake-up call" to the next Metropolitan Police commissioner following the resignation of Dame Cressida Dick.

He said: "I conclude that, when W80 shot Mr Baker, he held an honest and genuine belief that Mr Baker was moving in order to reach for the firearm.

"As such, W80 perceived that Mr Baker posed a lethal threat... I draw the conclusion, on the balance of probabilities, that the perceived threat from the actions and movement of Mr Baker was such that W80 honestly believed that it was reasonably necessary for him to shoot at Mr Baker."

Unarmed man shot by police ‘was dead before he got in the car’, mother claims

Read more: Met sergeant 'raped woman on Brighton beach' after meeting her on stag do

Mr Baker's family had called on the inquiry chairman to consider whether him being black could have been a factor in him being killed, but Mr Goldstone said he "found no evidence to support a finding that race played any part in Mr Baker's death".

Mr Baker's mother, Margaret Smith, said the family could not accept the inquiry's findings and that her son had been raising his hands in surrender before he was shot.

She said: "Jermaine was dead before he got in that car. His life was taken for no good reason. As I have always said, he should have gone to prison like the rest of the men in the car.

"I therefore cannot agree with the judge's conclusions that Jermaine did not die as a result of these failures. That is a conclusion that I cannot understand and the judge has not explained why he has drawn that conclusion.

"After seven years of waiting and two months of evidence, we deserved more."

Tia Demetrio, the mother of Mr Baker's daughter Alexia, said the nine-year-old is "petrified" when she hears sirens or sees police officers.

She told PA: "I am going to go back and explain to her - no matter what this report says - that her father was unlawfully killed, and I will stand by that for the rest of my life."

Mr Goldstone also said W80's "overall credibility" as a witness "remained largely intact".

The inquiry chairman highlighted a number of failures, including that public safety should have been - but was not - the primary objective of the operation, that intelligence that the conspirators had only been able to source an imitation firearm was not passed on to W80 and others, and the "delusional" idea the operation would succeed in ridding the streets of north London of lethal firearms.

Mr Baker's mother, Margaret Smith, said the family could not accept the inquiry's findings and that her son had been raising his hands in surrender before he was shot.
Mr Baker's mother, Margaret Smith, said the family could not accept the inquiry's findings and that her son had been raising his hands in surrender before he was shot. . Picture: Alamy

Read more: Baby boy, 1, dies after falling from seventh floor of tower block

The report said officers involved in the operation, Detective Inspector Robert Murray, Detective Chief Inspector Neil Williams and Detective Superintendent Craig Turner, had "a determination - bordering at times on the obsessive" to bring down violent gang the Tottenham Turks.

"Whilst this may have been a laudable objective, it should not have been something that was allowed to go ahead at virtually any cost and to the exclusion of proper and meaningful risk assessments and safety considerations, as well as compliance with protocols," the inquiry found.

"There can be no doubt that sustained public protection was the prime objective of this operation; the safety of the public was not - and it should have been."

The most officers could have hoped for on the day was the arrest of some "small fry" and the seizure of one gun, the inquiry found.

"The available intelligence supported the likelihood of a failure in achieving sustained public protection save for the 'small fry' who were to be arrested at the scene," the report said.

"The idea that this operation could succeed in ridding the streets of north London of lethal firearms was delusional - realistically one live firearm was the best the Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) could hope to recover.

"Unfortunately, those who decided that the operation should run were unable, because of their fixation on their desire to solve the Tottenham Turks problem at a stroke, to appreciate the flaw in their approach."

Inquiry chair His Honour Clement Goldstone QC concluded that there were police failings at almost every stage of the operation, which would "serve as a loud wake-up call" to the next commissioner following the resignation of Dame Cressida Dick.
Inquiry chair His Honour Clement Goldstone QC concluded that there were police failings at almost every stage of the operation, which would "serve as a loud wake-up call" to the next commissioner following the resignation of Dame Cressida Dick. Picture: Alamy

Read more: Civil servant urges colleagues to quit over PM's 'lies' in 'most remarkable' call

The inquiry found a series of technical failures in the planning and execution of the armed operation.

It said officers had failed to consider any possible outcome other than an armed stop, and had not properly assessed the risk posed by Izzet Eren's cousin, Ozcan Eren, who was behind the escape plot.

They also failed to engage with the Prison Service about Eren's escape risk or tell prison van staff of the planned jail break.

Failures to keep notes of meetings showed "an arrogant, dismissive attitude towards formality and a failure to appreciate the importance of accountability and maintaining an audit trail", the inquiry found.

It also concluded that failures by Mr Williams, who was tactical firearms commander on the day, did not amount to gross negligence and did not cause Mr Baker's death.

Lawyers for Mr Baker's family had highlighted failures in handling of intelligence and not using available surveillance tools to reduce the risks of an armed interception.

The Metropolitan Police said the way it plans and carries out armed operations has changed since 2015, and that it will take time to consider the inquiry's findings.

Chairman of the Police Federation Steve Hartshorn said: "The findings of the inquiry that officer W80's decision to discharge his firearm was justified and lawful are a welcome relief for the officer, and are important to all police firearms officers who have to make split-second life or death decisions in the course of their duty."

Prosecutors decided not to bring criminal charges against W80 in 2017, and he is currently embroiled in a legal battle over whether he should face misconduct proceedings.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Exclusive
The incident happened at the Harbour

Police refuse to investigate NHS worker who filmed and shared video of naked patient

The new football regulator is set to be introduced

Football regulator to 'put fan voices front and centre', but Premier League warns against 'weakening competition'

Aaron Taylor-Johnson is said to have been chosen as the new James Bond actor

Aaron Taylor-Johnson 'chosen as new James Bond', with actor 'to sign deal to take over from Daniel Craig this week'

File photo of a dentist

Hardly any dentists think government's plan to fix NHS dentistry will work, survey finds

The Queen alongside her grandchildren and great-grandchildren

Revealed: Princess of Wales' photo of Queen Elizabeth II, grandchildren and great-grandchildren was also edited

Australia Cyber Safety

Google, Meta and others face questions in Australia over cyber extremism threats

United Nations Nuclear Weapons

US and Japan seek UN resolution banning nuclear weapons in outer space

Keir Starmer has doubled down on his calls for an election as soon as possible

Keir Starmer vows to 'fix broken Britain' as he repeats calls for general election as soon as possible

Harry and Meghan have been demoted on the site

Harry and Meghan's profiles 'downgraded' on Buckingham Palace website alongside Prince Andrew

The government saw off 10 amendments from peers to the Safety of Rwanda Bill

MPs reject Rwanda Bill amendments as Sunak faces fresh battle with Lords over migrant plan

Election 2024 Trump

‘Impossible’ for Trump to post civil fraud bond of £356m, say lawyers

Georgia Election Indictment Lawmakers

Trump seeks to appeal against decision not to disqualify DA in Georgia case

Mike Lynch court case

Fallen tech star Mike Lynch painted as fraud mastermind in Hewlett-Packard trial

Russia Crimea

Putin extends rule in Russian election after harshest crackdown since Soviet era

Vacationing Mom Toddler Death

Ohio woman given life after child died when she left her alone to go on holiday

The statue of Captain Tom was put up for auction

Life-size Captain Tom statue sells for over £3,000 after owner is forced to slash price and auction it off from 99p