'Depraved loner' Gavin Plumb given three life sentences for plot to kidnap, rape and murder Holly Willoughby

12 July 2024, 12:53 | Updated: 12 July 2024, 13:28

Gavin Plumb was given three life sentences for plotting to abduct and murder Holly Willoughby
Gavin Plumb was given three life sentences for plotting to abduct and murder Holly Willoughby. Picture: Alamy

By Kit Heren

Gavin Plumb has been sentenced to life in prison for plotting to kidnap, rape and murder Holly Willoughby.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Security guard Plumb, 37, must serve a minimum of 15 years and 85 days, after being found guilty of the offences against TV presenter Ms Willoughby at Chelmsford Crown Court last week.

Appearing in the same packed court on Friday, Plumb stood in the dock to hear his sentence wearing a grey tracksuit.

The judge, Mr Justice Edward Murray, noted Plumb's extensive and long-term plans to attack Ms Willoughby, adding that the plot was "more than a fantasy" to him.

The plot also included a plan to seize Ms Willoughby's children to use as leverage against her, the judge added.

Footage of Plumb's arrest
Footage of Plumb's arrest. Picture: Handout

The failed kidnapper, who discussed his plot in graphic detail with associates, was arrested and charged in October last year.

He was caught after unwittingly telling his plans online to an undercover police officer operating under the pseudonym David Nelson in the US, thinking he was a potential accomplice.

The court heard on Friday that the details of his plot were so "depraved and vile" that the media had agreed not to report them.

Read more: 'Depraved and vile' plot to kidnap, rape and murder Holly Willoughby has had 'life-changing' impact on star

Read more: Holly Willoughby breaks silence after man found guilty of kidnap, rape and murder plot

Moment Gavin Plumb is arrested for plotting to kidnap Holly Willoughby

Mr Murray continued: "Your plan was hopelessly unrealistic for a number of reasons - including your poor physical health - but you clearly thought it was feasible.

"Although you talked about carrying out the plan on your own, I am sure that this was simply bravado.

"You always intended to carry out your plan to kidnap, rape and kill Ms Willoughby, but only if you could find the right man or men - the right 'crew' as you sometimes called it - to help you do it."

The prosecution had pushed for Plumb to be handed a life sentence. "These are offences where it is clear from their nature and their persistence... there is a clear, significant risk to the public of serious harm," Ms Morgan added. "Only a life sentence would be appropriate."

Ms Morgan also applied for Plumb to be banned from attending any public event featuring Ms Willoughby, including being in the audience for any show she takes part in.

Prosecutor Alison Morgan KC said ahed of sentencing: "My Lord knows of the extreme and gratuitous degradation of the victim that was planned by this defendant.

File photo dated 24/06/24 of a court artist drawing by Elizabeth Cook of Gavin Plumb (right) appearing at Chelmsford Crown Court
File photo dated 24/06/24 of a court artist drawing by Elizabeth Cook of Gavin Plumb (right) appearing at Chelmsford Crown Court. Picture: Alamy

"Degradation that was so depraved and vile that they were, by agreement, not reported in detail by representatives of the media."

She added that Plumb's plot "was not some speculative future event".

"If David Nelson had been a real person, this defendant intended for these offences to be committed in a short time frame," Ms Morgan said.

File photo dated 05/09/23 of Holly Willoughby
File photo dated 05/09/23 of Holly Willoughby. Picture: Alamy

And the plot had a "life-changing" impact on Ms Willoughby, the court was told.

Ms Morgan said Ms Willoughby wanted her victim personal statement to be kept private.

She continued: "What I can say, and I make this submission from the prosecution... it is abundantly clear that in making that statement the prosecution submits the impact of this offending has been life-changing for the victim of these offences - both in private and personal terms - private, personal and indeed professional.

Court artist sketch by Elizabeth Cook of Gavin Plumb (left) appearing in court
Court artist sketch by Elizabeth Cook of Gavin Plumb (left) appearing in court. Picture: Alamy

"It is clear, the prosecution submit... that the extent of the shock and fear caused by this offending has been impossible to convey."

Mitigating Mr Plumb's offences ahead of sentencing, his defence lawyer said he was "embarrassed and ashamed" by his online conversations. Sasha Wass KC said that the plan was "unworkable" because of Plumb's obesity.

"It is important when one considers if this was really close to an attempt or not," she added.

Ms Wass told the court: "Mr Plumb both worshipped and was obsessed by Ms Willoughby for a period of years - admittedly in a warped and bizarre manner.

"A manner which he described as dark when he gave evidence, but nonetheless, he worshipped her and he was devastated to have been the cause of such pain to her.

Plumb was discovered by Mr Nelson after the policeman infiltrated an online group called Abduct Lovers.

Plumb said he was definitely serious" about his plot to kidnap Ms Willoughby, leaving the officer with the impression that there was an "imminent threat" to her. He passed the evidence to the FBI.

They in turn contacted police in the UK, and when Essex Police officers raided Plumb's flat in Harlow they found bottles of chloroform and an "abduction kit" complete with cable ties.

Ms Willoughby said after Plumb's conviction last week that women "should not be made to feel unsafe... in our own homes".

During the sentencing hearing, the court also heard about a previous victim of Plumb, one of two teenage girls whom he tried to falsely imprison in a shop in 2008.

Prosecutor Ms Morgan also told Chelmsford Crown Court that the woman "felt a permanent sense of worry" that "she would bump into him when he was released" from prison.

"Hearing of these matters has made her think about what could have happened to her if she hadn't been able to run away from him, thankful as she is it didn't turn out worse," said Ms Morgan.

Plumb had earlier tried to abduct two women from trains in 2006, for which he was only given a suspended sentence.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

US and Russian officials have begun Ukraine peace talks in Saudi Arabia. Cracks have meanwhile appeared in Keir Starmer's peacekeeping plan.

US-Russia talks begin in Saudi Arabia as Starmer faces Europe backlash over Ukraine peacekeeping plans

A drone view of Everton's new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock during an Everton under-18 friendly match test event.

Everton's new stadium makes it's grand debut after £800million and four years

Job Centre Plus, London Road, Twickenham, Greater London, England, Great Britain, United Kingdom UK, Europe

UK wages see unexpected rise as unemployment rate holds steady at 4.4 per cent

Placebo band leader Brian Molko has been charged with defamation for calling the Italian PM a fascist and a Nazi during a gig.

British rock star Brian Molko charged after 'calling Italian PM a piece of s*** fascist and a Nazi' during gig

Exclusive
Short sentences and recall periods are keeping offenders in a longer cycle of going to jail, LBC has heard.

'It sent me back to square one': Short sentences create endless cycle of jail time, inmates tell LBC

Shocking footage shows passenger's 'lucky escape' after Delta jet crashes and 'flips' at Toronto airport leaving 18 injured

Shocking footage shows passenger's 'lucky escape' after Delta jet crashes and 'flips' at Toronto airport with 18 injured

Cracks over Starmer’s 'premature' peacekeeping plan as Europe left ‘irritated’ following crisis summit

Cracks over Starmer’s 'premature' peacekeeping plan as Europe left ‘irritated’ following crisis summit

The woman was attacked by a shark

Family of woman whose hands were bitten off by shark reveal 'nightmare' after husband fought off '7ft' predator

Renée Zellweger

Mad about the Box Office: Latest Bridget Jones installment smashes rom com record

Exclusive
David Gauke wants to reduce the size of the female prison estate to make room for more male inmates. File image shows Pentonville prison

Send fewer women to jail to make room for male inmates, says former Justice Secretary

x

Starmer will ensure UK is 'leading country' as European nations step up in support of Ukraine

Gunner Beck

Women in Army subjected to 'disgusting' comments from male colleagues amid misogynistic culture, inquest hears

The aircraft can be seen upside down, with its wheels in the air, and the area thick with snow

Passenger jet 'flips over' during landing in Toronto leaving 15 injured - with three critical

Paula Miluska had started working from home in November 2022 due to her pregnancy illness

Woman awarded £93k payout after boss fires her for morning sickness by sending jazz hands emoji

c

Britain must take a ‘leading responsibility’ for peace in Ukraine, says PM as he calls for US ‘security guarantee’

Andrew Tate is facing allegations of trafficking of minors, sexual intercourse with a minor and money laundering

Trump team 'pressuring Romania to lift restrictions on Andrew Tate'