Social worker wins £63,000 discrimination payout over 'offensive' comments about colleague’s ‘gender neutral’ daschund

17 September 2024, 12:51 | Updated: 17 September 2024, 13:55

Social worker wins £63,000 discrimination payout over comments about colleague’s ‘gender neutral’ daschund
Social worker wins £63,000 discrimination payout over comments about colleague’s ‘gender neutral’ daschund. Picture: Alamy

By Danielle de Wolfe

A social worker has won a £63,000 payout over discriminating comments made about colleague’s ‘gender neutral’ daschund.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Elizabeth Pitt, 62, was reprimanded by Cambridgeshire County Council for expressing "gender critical" views at a meeting held by the authority’s LGBT+ employee group.

The council worker is said to have made “non-inclusive and transphobic” remarks about a male co-worker's dog - comments the council said were “particularly inappropriate and ill-judged”.

A judge heard how a disagreement over the man's "gender-fluid' dachshund in January 2023 led Ms Pitt to express "nasty opinions" over a video meeting.

On one occasion, Ms Pitt's colleague put a dress on his dog in order to provoke “debate about gender”, the tribunal heard.

Following a number of complaints about Ms Pitt's behaviour during a meeting, the council drafted a report, which deemed to her remarks to be "offensive" in nature.

Stock Image Of Pet Dachshund Dog Dress As Businessman At Desk In Office With Computer And Coffee
Stock Image Of Pet Dachshund Dog Dress As Businessman At Desk In Office With Computer And Coffee. Picture: Alamy

Ms Pitt and another lesbian co-worker are said to have negatively responded to the “gender-fluid” dog, sharing critical views of the terminology and its application.

Comments made by the pair were also said to include remarks about transgender people’s participation in women’s sport, as well as the use of female-only spaces.

Council managers informed Ms Pitt of multiple complaints made against her in April 2023, explaining that co-workers had expressed issues with “some views” expressed during the video meeting.

Read more: Titan submarine’s lead engineer tells inquiry he ‘felt pressure' to get vessel ready for doomed Titanic dive

Read more: Kevin Pietersen's 'bid to join exclusive Surrey golf club fails' as members 'threaten veto' against ex-England cricket star

Formal complaints submitted by colleagues deemed Ms Pitt's comments “offensive” and that she expressed “nasty opinions" during the call.

Another complaint said she used a “really aggressive tone” when making the remarks.

Ms Pitt denied aggressive behaviour but did accepted she could be “quite direct” on occasion.

Asked whether she believed the LGBT+ group was an “appropriate place” to express such opinions, she replied: “What was the group for, if it was not for that type of discussion?”

County Hall, Cambridge viewed from Castle Mound
County Hall, Cambridge viewed from Castle Mound. Picture: Alamy

Taking Cambridshire County Council to an employment tribunal, the judge heard that she was told the remarks caused a “detrimental impact on the mental health and well-being of the complainants”.

However, after hearing the evidence, employment judge Paul Michell ruled that documents submitted “unambiguously show” that Ms Pitt was treated in the way she was because of her opinions which amounted to freedom of speech.

As a result, the authority accepted that her gender-critical opinions consisted of a “philosophical belief” and ultimately accepted liability.

The verdict saw Ms Pitt awarded her £30,000 in loss of earnings, as well as £22,000 in compensation for injury to feelings, amounting to £55,910 including interest.

“Let’s hope that other employers will start to learn that it’s a bad idea to try to stop lesbians asserting their boundaries and silence staff who know that sex is real and sometimes matters,” she said following the verdict.

Cambridgeshire county council was also ordered to pay Ms Pitt's legal costs, which amounted to £8,000, as well as being made to include a section on “freedom of belief and speech in the workplace” in all staff training.

A council spokesman said: “We strive to create a safe, inclusive and compassionate environment for people to work in and recognise this needs to be balanced with everyone being entitled to express their own views and beliefs.

“We will reflect carefully on this final outcome, as well as undertaking a review of our policies and procedures accordingly.”

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Jack Watkin, 25, claimed on social media in 2016 to own a £1.7 million fleet of expensive cars

Police hunt for self-proclaimed ‘rich kid of Instagram’ after breach of bail for fraud charge

Breaking
BBC presenter Jay Blades arriving at Worcester Crown Court

Jay Blades pleads not guilty to engaging in controlling or coercive behaviour towards estranged wife

Aerial view of Sunbury Lock on the River Thames

Boat carrying six people capsizes on River Thames, five have been rescued with one still missing

c

Woman who murdered parents hid mother’s body in wardrobe and father’s in ‘makeshift tomb’ for four years

Big chill: Snow forecast across parts of the UK as Met Office warns temperatures could dip below freezing over the weekend

Arctic blast: Snow forecast across parts of the UK as Met Office warns temperatures could dip below zero this weekend

Virginia McCullough, 36, (pictured) admitted poisoning her father with prescription medication and stabbing her mother before hiding their bodies for years

Artist, 36, who murdered her parents then lived alongside their bodies for four years to be sentenced

A British man was stabbed to death with a Machete in an attack at his home in Kenya

British man 'stabbed to death with machete' in Kenya home after 'someone tried poisoning dogs'

Mohamed Al Fayed

Met police probe 40 new rape and sexual assault allegations against Mohamed Al Fayed

Tickets for the NYE London fireworks this year will cost as much as £50

London New Year’s Eve fireworks tickets to cost up to £50 as ‘premium’ views and ‘tourist tax’ introduced

The captain of a fishing vessel was rescued by the US Coast Guard after he survived Hurricane Milton

Saved by an ice box: Astonishing moment man is rescued by helicopter after being left stranded in Gulf of Mexico

'I wouldn't do it again': Jenrick suggests regret for painting over murals at children’s asylum centre.

'I wouldn't do it again': Robert Jenrick says he regrets ordering workers to paint over murals at children’s asylum centre

Error ridden Lucy Letby door-swipe data was used in cases of eight other babies

Error ridden Lucy Letby door-swipe data was used in cases of eight other babies

The organisation of survivors of the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki was awarded the prize on Friday

Japanese group of atomic bomb survivors wins Nobel Peace Prize

Exclusive
Hundreds of women are asking for tattoo 'cover ups'. (stock image)

Hundreds of women asking for 'cover-up' tattoos after being sexually abused in studios

Russia's outgoing US ambassador issues chilling warning

Russia's outgoing US ambassador issues 'nuclear catastrophe' warning as he returns to Moscow

Partial remains of missing British explorer Andrew ‘Sandy’ Irvine discovered on Everest after 100 years

Chilling discovery as 'partial remains' of missing British explorer Andrew ‘Sandy’ Irvine found on Everest after 100 years