Italian prosecutors 'not ruling out homicide' as heartbreaking new details revealed over sinking of Bayesian superyacht

24 August 2024, 09:56 | Updated: 24 August 2024, 11:12

Italian prosecutors 'not ruling out homicide' after seven die in sinking of Bayesian superyacht
Italian prosecutors 'not ruling out homicide' after seven die in sinking of Bayesian superyacht. Picture: Alamy/Handout

By Emma Soteriou

Italian prosecutors are "not ruling out homicide" as they launch an investigation into the sinking of the Bayesian superyacht, which left seven dead.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

British tech tycoon Mike Lynch and his 18-year-old daughter, Hannah, were among those recovered after the vessel sank near Porticello at around 5am local time on Monday.

Hannah was found alone in her own cabin 50 metres below the surface, rescue workers revealed during a press conference on Saturday.

Five others were found in a separate compartment: Hannah's father, Mike Lynch, Morgan Stanley International bank chairman Jonathan Bloomer, his wife Judy Bloomer, Clifford Chance lawyer Chris Morvillo and his wife Neda Morvillo.

Meanwhile, the body of Canadian-Antiguan national Recaldo Thomas, who was the chef on the boat, was recovered close to the ship on Monday.

Hannah and Mike Lynch
Hannah and Mike Lynch. Picture: Handout

Read more: 'Questions to be asked about the crew': Engineering expert tells LBC that fatal Bayesian yacht sinking is 'puzzling'

Read more: Manslaughter probe launched over Bayesian superyacht sinking as rescuers resume search for final missing person

Speaking in court on Saturday, Ambrogio Cartosio, public prosecutor of nearby town Termini Imerese, said that his office has opened an initial investigation into manslaughter.

He said that "behaviours that were not perfectly in order" may have been behind the number of deaths off the coast of Sicily at a news conference on Saturday.

But all lines of inquiry are being considered, he said.

Italian firefighter divers work at the site of a shipwreck, in Porticello, Sicily, southern Italy, Thursday, Aug. 22, 2024. Divers searching the wreck of the superyacht Bayesian that sank off Sicily on Monday.
Italian firefighter divers work at the site of a shipwreck, in Porticello, Sicily, southern Italy, Thursday, Aug. 22, 2024. Divers searching the wreck of the superyacht Bayesian that sank off Sicily on Monday. Picture: Alamy

Firefighter Bentivoglio Fiandra said the yacht had already sunk when they received the emergency call.

It was on its right-hand side with those who died having been "trying to hide in the cabins on the left-hand side" of the vessel.

"You may want to know where we recovered the bodies of the victims. I can tell you... that the ship sunk and was laid onto its right hand side at the bottom of the sea," he said. 

"It's quite clear that the people were trying to hide in the cabins on the left-hand side and we found the first five bodies in the first cabin on the left-hand side and the final body in the third cabin on the left-hand side.

"There were six cabins: three on the left-hand side and three on the right-hand side. We found them on the highest part of the ship going towards the surface."

Superyacht Recaldo Thomas
Superyacht Recaldo Thomas. Picture: Facebook

In response to the delay in authorities informing the public of the details of its rescue operation, Mr Cartosio said Italian civil codes prevented him from saying more.

He said he personally believed it created "notable obstacles" when it came to transparency with the public.

He said it quickly became apparent that it would be "impossible" to save those trapped on the yacht as it sank.

He said: "The Public Prosecutor's Office of Termini Imerese has registered a file with the state against unknown persons, hypothesising the crimes of negligent shipwreck and multiple negligent manslaughter."

"Generally a prosecutor is never satisfied to give this information at this stage, precisely because developments could change," Mr Cartosio added. 

"We cannot exclude anything at all but what, there has been a lot of media interest with regards to the people were involved.

"But at the same time I believe it is right to anticipate developments of this inquiry can be very variable."

This picture released by the Italian Firefighters on Friday, Aug. 23, 2024, shows a firefighter cave diver as he prepares to reach the wrecked luxury superyacht Bayesian
This picture released by the Italian Firefighters on Friday, Aug. 23, 2024, shows a firefighter cave diver as he prepares to reach the wrecked luxury superyacht Bayesian. Picture: Alamy

The main questions being raised are around how a yacht deemed "unsinkable" by its manufacturer managed to sink while nearby vessels were mostly unaffected.

Dr Jean-Baptiste Souppez, an engineering lecturer at Aston University, told LBC: "We're looking at vessels that are very safe, that are built to very strong and rigorous engineering standards. For the vessel of that side to find itself going down without any major structure of failure.

"The accounts of the divers are that the vessel is pretty much intact. So that's something that's very puzzling.

"We know that there was a report of very strong but very localised weather, so what we call a water spout, or essentially a mini tornado over the sea, and that could contribute to explaining why this vessel was affected when another vessel a couple of 100 metres away was not.

"But there's also questions being asked about the preparation of the vessel and the crew, with respect to the weather alerts that day."

Some 15 people survived the wreck. The group of survivors were picked up in a life raft by a nearby boat after firing a flare into the night sky.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

The voice of Huw Edwards has been removed from an episode of Dr Who

Disgraced BBC presenter Huw Edwards erased from episode of Dr Who

Breaking
Elizabeth Line train drivers will go on strike

Elizabeth Line train drivers to stage series of strikes amid pay dispute

Relatives and supporters of Israeli hostages held in Gaza since the October 7, 2023 attacks, block Ayalon Highway in Tel Aviv during a protest calling for the release of all hostages

Hamas announces it will release Israeli hostages as planned amid fears ceasefire will collapse

The largest of the Chagos islands, Diego Garcia, the site of a joint military facility of the United Kingdom and the United States

US makes last-ditch intervention in Chagos islands negotiations amid concerns China will benefit from deal

Police at the scene after the car crashed into protesters

Horror in Munich as Mini ploughs into demonstrators leaving 20 injured hours before world security conference

Exclusive
'It's not a witch hunt, we want accountability,' Barnaby Webber's mother has said.

'It's not a witch hunt,' says mother of Nottingham attack victim as she calls for 'accountability'

A woman was charged £50 to bring a water bottle on a Ryanair flight

Woman 'charged £50 to take a water bottle on Ryanair' flight

US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth (L) shakes hands with British Defence Secretary John Healey, on the eve of a NATO defence ministers' meeting at the alliance's headquarters in Brussels

'Ukraine must be at the heart of talks with Russia', says UK Defence Secretary after Trump announces plan to meet Putin

Supporters of the Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) demonstrate in Trafalgar Square

Woman who tried to gain asylum eight times allowed to stay in UK - after she joined terror group

Abdoulaye Doucoure of Everton argues with Curtis Jones of Liverpool during the Premier League match at Goodison Park, Liverpool.

Merseyside Mayhem: Four red cards handed out as Everton score late equaliser in last-ever derby at Goodison Park

Crowd Of Commuters Walking To Work Across London Bridge.

UK economy unexpectedly grew by 0.1% in last quarter of 2024, new figures show

Tranyelle Harshman, 32, of Wyoming, left her fourth daughter fighting for her life after going on a rampage at their home on Monday.

Mum-of-four shoots dead three young daughters before turning gun on herself

Speeding car approaching warning to slow down, on UK road

Shock figures reveal 'incredibly dangerous' speeding across UK - as one driver caught doing 122mph on 30mph road

Emergency services work near the scene of an explosion at a bar where a grenade was thrown, in Grenoble, on February 12, 2025.

At least 12 injured after man wielding assault rifle throws grenade into bar

Dorothy Chiles

Great-grandmother, 87, pictured for first time after deadly train station attack, as woman in her 20s arrested

President Donald Trump speaks on Wednesday night

Trump makes plans to meet Putin and end Ukraine war as he says 'the US wants its money back'