JK Rowling hails 'heroine' Allison Bailey after winning case over gender critical beliefs

27 July 2022, 23:56 | Updated: 28 July 2022, 00:00

JK Rowling branded Allison Bailey her "heroine" after her success
JK Rowling branded Allison Bailey her "heroine" after her success. Picture: Alamy

By Emma Soteriou

JK Rowling has hailed barrister Allison Bailey her "heroine" after a tribunal found she was discriminated against by her chambers because of her "gender-critical belief".

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Allison Bailey was awarded £22,000 in compensation on Wednesday.

The lesbian barrister, who believes sex is immutable, claimed that LGBT charity Stonewall induced her employer, Garden Court Chambers (GCC), to investigate her over her support of gender-critical beliefs.

The tribunal found that GCC discriminated against Ms Bailey by publishing a tweet saying it was investigating her and by upholding a claim by Stonewall arguing that two of her tweets "were likely to breach (The Bar Standards Board's) core duties".

But allegations that it discriminated against and victimised her through withholding of instructions and work in 2019, causing the claimant financial loss, a claim of indirect discrimination by GCC, and a claim that Stonewall instructed, caused or induced GCC to discriminate against her, were all dismissed.

Following the decision, Harry Potter author JK Rowling said: "Allison Bailey is a heroine to me and innumerable other feminists for refusing to abandon her beliefs and principles in the fact of intimidation and discrimination.

"Congratulations."

She later added: "And I couldn't be prouder of my friend."

Read more: Trans men to get doctors help 'chestfeeding' their babies under new NHS guidelines\

Read more: Drag queen escorted to safety after ‘anti-woke’ protesters storm children’s story hour

In December 2018, Ms Bailey complained to her colleagues about GCC becoming a Stonewall Diversity Champion, claiming the group advocated "trans extremism" and was complicit in a campaign of intimidation of those who questioned gender self-identity.

In October 2019, she was involved in setting up the LGB Alliance advocacy group to resist "gender extremism".

Her tweets opposing trans rights campaigns led to tweets and complaints being sent to GCC, alleging her opinions were transphobic and damaged GCC's reputation.

The tribunal held that her gender-critical belief that Stonewall wanted to replace sex with gender identity, that the absolutist tone of its advocacy of gender self-identity made it complicit in threats against women, and that it eroded women's rights and lesbian same-sex orientation, were beliefs protected under the Equality Act.

A reserved judgment handed down on Tuesday upheld her claim that GCC discriminated against her because of her belief, when it tweeted that the complaints would be investigated under a complaints procedure, and when it found in December 2019 that two of her tweets were likely to breach barristers' core duties.

GCC was ordered to pay her £22,000 compensation for injury to feelings, plus interest of £4,693.33.

The chambers said it is "reviewing the judgment carefully with our legal team with a view to appeal".

The tribunal did not accept she lost work and income because of her December 2018 complaint, or her claim that a Stonewall complaint about her tweets was "engineered" by a trans rights-supporting colleague.

She had made an indirect discrimination claim alleging that GCC had a practice of holding that gender-critical views were bigoted, and that GCC allowed Stonewall to direct its complaints process, but both claims were rejected.

A separate allegation that Stonewall instructed or induced discrimination by GCC, or attempted to do so, was also rejected.

In response to the outcome, Ms Bailey said on Twitter: "The Employment Tribunal found that Garden Court Chambers discriminated against me because of my gender critical belief when it published a statement that I was under investigation & in upholding Stonewall's complaint against me."

A Stonewall spokesperson said: "We are pleased that the tribunal ruled that Stonewall has not been found to have instructed, caused or induced (GCC) to discriminate against Allison Bailey."

A GCC spokesperson said the judgment "dismissed Ms Bailey's claim against Stonewall and most of her claims against Garden Court Chambers including all her claims for indirect discrimination"

They added: "We note that her primary claim (for loss of earnings on the grounds of victimisation) was dismissed, the tribunal finding that 'We could not conclude that it was shown that the fall in income was in any way influenced (let alone significantly influenced)' by Ms Bailey's complaint to colleagues about Garden Court becoming a Stonewall Diversity Champion or by her beliefs.

"The tribunal found that it 'could not conclude that (GCC) as a whole had a practice of treating gender-critical beliefs as bigoted'. This confirms our stance.

"We have maintained throughout that our members, quite reasonably, hold differing views in the complex debate around trans and sex-based rights."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Breaking
Jeffrey Donaldson

DUP's Jeffrey Donaldson 'charged with allegations of historic nature' as he steps down as party leader

Russia bombed Ukrainian infrastructure overnight

Russia launches 'massive attack' on Ukraine's power supplies, with 'energy security under growing threat'

Newry Magistrates' Court

Man, 61, charged with non-recent sexual offences in Northern Ireland

Drivers queuing in Dover on Friday morning

Holidaymakers hit with 2-hour Dover ferry waits amid strong winds, as 2.6m hit the roads for Good Friday getaway

The attack happened on a train in south London

Teenager charged with attempted murder after south London train stabbing, with victim still in critical condition

Mother Natalie Pinnell

Mother left in tears after daughter with complex needs 'erased' from school photo

Amber Rudd and Mary Beard have both been nominated to the Garrick Club

Amber Rudd and Mary Beard among seven women nominated for membership of all-male Garrick Club

Exclusive
Anneliese Dodds said Labour would make sure local people have 'skin in the game' with tackling inequality

'Rebuild has to start from ground up,' Labour's Anneliese Dodds says, and 'local people must have skin in the game'

Mohamed Mansour has been awarded a knighthood

Conservatives accused of 'cronyism' after donor who gave £5 million awarded knighthood in surprise honours list

Exclusive
Justin Welby recalled his experience of coping with his father's drinking as a teenager.

‘It was utterly isolating’: Archbishop of Canterbury recalls harrowing childhood with alcoholic father

More than 2 million drivers are set to hit the road on Good Friday.

Easter Carmageddon: Over two million drivers to hit the road on Good Friday after Storm Nelson travel chaos

Michael Gove has slammed the water firm as a 'disgrace'.

Thames Water bosses branded a ‘disgrace’ as Michael Gove tells firm ‘not to punish consumers’ for its failings

South Africa Bus Crash

Girl, 8, the sole survivor as 45 die in bus crash off South Africa bridge

A spokesman has denied reports the sausage dog could be banned.

The wurst news is over: Germany denies claims of sausage dog ban

Israel Palestinians Britain Aid

UN top court orders Israel to open more land crossings into Gaza

Greece Confidence Vote

Greece’s government survives no-confidence motion called over rail disaster