Labour need to launch £25 billion tax raid to avoid austerity and keep up public services, top think tank says

10 October 2024, 09:57

Rachel Reeves
Rachel Reeves. Picture: Alamy

By Kit Heren

The government may needs to raise £25 billion in taxes to keep up spending on public services, a top economics think tank has said.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Labour's first Budget on October 30 could be "the most consequential since at least 2010", according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS).

Even if Chancellor Rachel Reeves changes her pledge to keep spending rising in line with national income this would do "almost nothing" to ease the challenge on public service funding, the economists said.

Because of her promise to meet day-to-day spending out of revenues, Ms Reeves would still need to turn to tax rises to avoid spending cuts and meet her pledge to borrow only to invest, according to IFS boss Paul Johnson.

The IFS report, done with investment bank Citi, found that if the government does not make cuts to spending outside of public services, she would need a tax rise of £16 billion to remain on course to balance the budget in 2028-29.

Read more: Chancellor Rachel Reeves considers raising alcohol duty in Budget - but drinks industry bosses say the move would be 'catastrophic'

Read more: Chancellor to consider slashing 25 per cent tax-free pension withdrawals

Starmer accused of ‘opening the door’ to tax and borrowing changes in Budget

This would come in addition to the £9 billion tax rise from measures set out in Labour's manifesto - adding up to about £25 billion overall.

Labour have promised not to raise income tax and corporation tax or to increase National Insurance or VAT - meaning that finding any tax rises may be difficult.

The net tax rises from the new Labour government in July 1997 and coalition in October 2010 were both around £13-£14 billion.

Prime Minister Keir Starmer did not rule out hiking employer national insurance contributions and changing borrowing rules when challenged by Rishi Sunak at Prime Minister's Questions on Wednesday.

Keir Starmer
Keir Starmer. Picture: Alamy

The IFS forecast suggests that, even with Labour's planned £9 billion tax rise implemented, trying to balance the current budget while avoiding cuts to public service spending would put the budget "on a knife edge" and highly sensitive to OBR judgments.

To meet this year's pay settlements and avoid making future cuts to public services spending, Mr Reeves would need to top up day-to-day spending by some £30 billion above her predecessor's plans by 2028-29, the IFS estimates.

The Chancellor has warned ahead of her first Budget on October 30 that there will be "tough decisions" but rejected that the country will see a return to austerity.

Polling expert says Labour shouldn't be 'terminally concerned' about their decline in the polls

She and Sir Keir Starmer have said the Labour Government inherited a £22 billion "black hole" in the public finances from its predecessors.

There has been speculation about how Ms Reeves will raise funds after she ruled out raising taxes on working people.

IFS director Paul Johnson said any changes to capital gains tax would need to be a "careful reform" rather than a simple increase. There is also speculation that Labour could make changes to inheritance tax.

The IFS noted that the Chancellor has inherited an "unenviable" public finance situation as taxes are at a historic high and debt is rising, while public services such as prisons, police and local councils are under strain.

Expert says Labour raising fuel duty would be 'electoral suicide'

Mr Johnson said: "The first Budget of this new administration could be the most consequential since at least 2010.

"The new Chancellor is committed to increasing investment spending, and to funding public services. To do so, she will need to increase taxes, or borrowing, or both.

"Taxes are at an all-time high, and she is tightly constrained by her pledges not to raise the main rates of income tax or corporation tax, or to increase National Insurance or VAT at all.

"The temptation then is to borrow more, perhaps changing the definition of debt targeted by the fiscal rules.

"But, given her pledge to balance the current budget, that would not free up additional resource for day-to-day spending and in any case is not risk-free given the dual deficits - that is, both budget deficit and current account deficit - being run by the UK."

Benjamin Nabarro, Chief UK Economist at Citi, said there were "cautious reasons for optimism" in the economic forecast and that there is a notable opportunity for structural reform.

"Unfortunately, large outstanding debt stocks and a current account deficit mean the UK faces budget constraints that many other advanced economies don't. Additional borrowing may therefore have to be used sparingly and reform used creatively."

A Treasury spokesman said: "It's right to say that we have inherited a tough financial position, but we won't let the challenges of the past define our future.

"Despite uncovering a £22 billion black hole in our public finances we are focused on making this the most pro-growth Treasury in history, built on the rock of economic stability, including robust fiscal rules that were set out in the manifesto.

"That is how we will fix our public services and deliver on the promise of change."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Freezing rain will hit the UK.

Rare freezing rain that poses risks for planes and downs trees will hit UK in days, warns Met Office

Kanye West had his account suspended after posting "I AM A NAZI."

Kanye West has X account reactivated after deleting anti-Semitic rant

The voice of Huw Edwards has been removed from an episode of Dr Who

Disgraced BBC presenter Huw Edwards erased from episode of Dr Who

Elizabeth Line train drivers will go on strike

Elizabeth Line train drivers to stage series of strikes amid pay dispute

Relatives and supporters of Israeli hostages held in Gaza since the October 7, 2023 attacks, block Ayalon Highway in Tel Aviv during a protest calling for the release of all hostages

Hamas announces it will release Israeli hostages as planned amid fears ceasefire will collapse

The largest of the Chagos islands, Diego Garcia, the site of a joint military facility of the United Kingdom and the United States

US makes last-ditch intervention in Chagos islands negotiations amid concerns China will benefit from deal

Police at the scene after the car crashed into protesters

Horror in Munich as Mini ploughs into demonstrators in 'attack' leaving 27 injured hours before security conference

Exclusive
'It's not a witch hunt, we want accountability,' Barnaby Webber's mother has said.

'It's not a witch hunt,' says mother of Nottingham attack victim as she calls for 'accountability'

A woman was charged £50 to bring a water bottle on a Ryanair flight

Woman 'charged £50 to take a water bottle on Ryanair' flight

US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth (L) shakes hands with British Defence Secretary John Healey, on the eve of a NATO defence ministers' meeting at the alliance's headquarters in Brussels

'Ukraine must be at the heart of talks with Russia', says UK Defence Secretary after Trump announces plan to meet Putin

Supporters of the Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) demonstrate in Trafalgar Square

Woman who tried to gain asylum eight times allowed to stay in UK - after she joined terror group

Abdoulaye Doucoure of Everton argues with Curtis Jones of Liverpool during the Premier League match at Goodison Park, Liverpool.

Merseyside Mayhem: Four red cards handed out as Everton score late equaliser in last-ever derby at Goodison Park

Crowd Of Commuters Walking To Work Across London Bridge.

UK economy unexpectedly grew by 0.1% in last quarter of 2024, new figures show

Tranyelle Harshman, 32, of Wyoming, left her fourth daughter fighting for her life after going on a rampage at their home on Monday.

Mum-of-four shoots dead three young daughters before turning gun on herself

Speeding car approaching warning to slow down, on UK road

Shock figures reveal 'incredibly dangerous' speeding across UK - as one driver caught doing 122mph on 30mph road

Emergency services work near the scene of an explosion at a bar where a grenade was thrown, in Grenoble, on February 12, 2025.

At least 12 injured after man wielding assault rifle throws grenade into bar