'Prisoners are entitled to more liberty': Legal challenge over quarantine hotel policy

12 August 2021, 00:04 | Updated: 12 August 2021, 00:09

There are currently 60 locations on the red list, such as Mexico, Pakistan, Turkey, and much of South America and Africa.
There are currently 60 locations on the red list, such as Mexico, Pakistan, Turkey, and much of South America and Africa. Picture: Alamy

By Sophie Barnett

A law firm representing travellers affected by the UK's quarantine hotel policy has described the requirement as an "unlawful deprivation of liberty" as it seeks a judicial review.

London-based PGMBM believes requiring people who are fully vaccinated and have recently tested negative for coronavirus to spend 11 nights in a hotel violates their human rights and is an "unlawful deprivation of liberty".

The law firm said "prisoners are entitled to more liberty" than those forced to quarantine in hotels.

It comes after the cost of staying in a quarantine hotel rose from £1,750 to £2,285 on Thursday.

Travellers arriving in the UK from a red list country - such as Mexico, Pakistan, Turkey, and much of South America - must enter a quarantine hotel, even if they have had both doses of a Covid-19 vaccine.

Read more: Changes unveiled to foreign travel traffic light system - full list

Read more: 'I caught Covid in quarantine system', British woman tells LBC

There are currently 60 locations on the red list following the government's latest update to its international travel rules.

PGMBM managing partner Tom Goodhead said: "Mandatory hotel quarantine is a fundamental breach of human rights. It has led to the false imprisonment of people who are fully vaccinated and have tested negative.

"Prisoners are entitled to more liberty than those forced to quarantine in hotels.

"We have all read about the horrific experiences of some of the people in these hotels. We want to see this draconian policy scrapped and those affected to be properly compensated."

'I caught Covid in quarantine'

Mr Goodhead said Ireland and Norway - the only other European countries with mandatory quarantine "involving detention" - have amended their schemes so fully vaccinated travellers are exempt.

"The UK must follow suit immediately," he added.

PGMBM would not disclose the identities of its clients in relation to the legal challenge - but said they include people in the UK who want to visit family in a red list country, and others who have already stayed in one of the hotels.

"They are often travelling for emergency or urgent reasons and would not be travelling unless they felt it was absolutely necessary," explained Mr Goodhead.

There have been multiple complaints about the hotels, including over harassment of female guests by male security guards, and the quality of food.

PGMBM has written a letter to the government over the quarantine hotel policy, and said it is seeking a judicial review.

It wrote that the current regulations are "not proportionate" and "not necessary".

Nurse reunited with family arriving from US as quarantine-free travel begins

Seven countries were added to the government's green travel list on Sunday, with France also dropping its confusing "amber watchlist" status.

Read more: Fully-vaccinated arrivals from France no longer have to isolate as travel rules change

The step aligns France with the rest of the amber list, where those who are fully vaccinated with a vaccine authorised and administered in the UK, US or Europe, do not need to quarantine when arriving in England.

Georgia, Mexico, La Reunion and Mayotte were all added to the red list to safeguard domestic vaccine rollout, the government said.

The changes to the international travel rules for those returning to the UK come after the government waived quarantine for fully vaccinated travellers from the US and much of Europe.

Hundreds of families have been able to reunite after many months apart following the changes.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Pictures of the Week Global Photo Gallery

Iran fires air defence batteries at two sites after drones spotted

Air defences

Russia pummels exhausted Ukrainian forces ahead of springtime advance

Google HQ

Japanese doctors demand damages from Google over ‘groundless’ reviews

Leonid Volkov

Two suspects held in Poland after attack on Navalny ally in Lithuania

Former President Donald Trump during jury selection at Manhattan criminal court

From a man who meditates every morning to a corporate lawyer: The 12 jurors who will decide Donald Trump's fate

There are fears the traditional fry-up is dying out because young people think it's too fatty

Gen Z shun the ‘greasy and high-calorie’ classic fry-up with one in ten never eating the famous dish

Taylor Swift performing during the Eras Tour

Taylor Swift reveals surprise 2am double album drop with record packed with secret messages and attacks on her exes

Pakistan Suicide Attack

Japanese workers narrowly escape suicide bombing in Pakistan

Lloyd Evans wrote in a Spectator article how he lost control of his 'lunatic libido' during a lecture by Lea Ypi

Female academic hits back at Spectator writer who said he went for sex at massage parlour after watching her lecture

Locals are

'Catapulting epidemic' in 'peaceful English' village sees animals killed, cars damaged and funeral-goers targeted

French toddler Emile Soleil may have been eaten by a pack of wolves following discovery of 2-year-old's skull

French toddler Emile Soleil may have been eaten by a pack of wolves following discovery of 2-year-old's remains

Israel strikes back at Iran: Explosions heard following revenge attack - days after Tehran's drone assault

Israel strikes back at Iran: Explosions heard following revenge attack - days after Tehran's drone assault

India Election Narendra Modi

India starts voting as Narendra Modi seeks third term as prime minister

Rishi Sunak is to call for an end to the "sick note culture".

End of the 'sick note': Rishi Sunak to stop GPs signing people off work in welfare scheme overhaul

Andrew Malkinson

'Too little, too late': Andrew Malkinson rejects Criminal Cases Review Commission's apology after being wrongly jailed

Argentina NATO

Argentina asks to join Nato as President Milei seeks more prominent role