'Coercion on a state level': Silent Witness star argues assisted dying bill risks people feeling there is 'no choice'

12 November 2024, 19:59 | Updated: 13 November 2024, 00:32

Andrew Marr spoke to Liz Carr
Andrew Marr spoke to Liz Carr. Picture: LBC/Alamy

By Emma Soteriou

Actress and activist Liz Carr has argued that legalising assisted dying risks making people feel as if they are a burden and have "no choice".

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Speaking on LBC's Tonight with Andrew Marr, Ms Carr said that the bill would lead to coercion on a state level.

She argued that people will begin to feel like a burden and as if they have "no choice" but to agree.

"I think, honestly, while we have such low expectation and a low value of certain groups of people – and I say that as a disabled woman, but equally ill people and older people - we just don’t see their value and their worth...

"There could be somebody who just feels like they’re a burden, somebody who doesn't want to use all of their savings or sell their house for home care."

She continued: "There's a lot of talk about coercion and that's often talked about as an individual coercing someone or pressurising them.

"I think we're talking about almost on a state level, on a system level, feeling you've got no choice."

Read more: 'There are different views and opinions': MP behind assisted dying bill reveals cabinet split ahead of key vote

Read more: Teacher dying of bowel cancer begs MPs to approve assisted dying as proposed law published

Campaigner says the assisted dying bill is 'coercive'

Ms Carr went on to say: "We're afraid and why not? We've all had experiences of seeing people that we love die unpleasant and difficult deaths and we assume that these bills are going to make that go away.

"Actually, we know that over half of the people that currently go to Dignitas wouldn't qualify into this bill or a bill like this."

On November 29, the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill will be debated and voted on - marking the first Commons vote on assisted dying since 2015.

Labour MP Kim Leadbeater has described her proposed legislation as the "most robust" in the world, as she stated she expects hundreds of dying people might initially opt to use a service which could see patients press a button to end their lives.

Defending the bill, she argued that there are "three layers of scrutiny" in the form of a sign-off by two doctors and a High Court judge, and would make coercion an offence with a possible punishment of 14 years in jail.

Sir Keir Starmer has described the issue as "a very important question on which views differ, strongly-held views on either side".

Speaking at Cop29 in Baku, the PM said: "I will not be putting pressure on any MP to vote one way or the other.

"I personally will study the details of the Bill which has now been published today because safeguards have always been extremely important to me and were an essential part of the guidelines that I drew up when I was chief prosecutor."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

c

Murdered schoolgirl Elianne Andam, 15, posted Snapchat moments before being stabbed to death in 'row over teddy bear’

Jorge Ortega

'Just hours from going home to his wife': Tribute to 'devoted' rail worker killed at station as fundraiser launched

A man holding up two nooses in Saydnaya prison

Thousands flock to Assad regime prison in search for missing loved ones

Exclusive
Five former Health Secretaries call for memorial to tens of thousands of stillborn babies buried in unmarked mass graves.

Five former Health Secretaries call for memorial to tens of thousands of stillborn babies buried in unmarked mass graves

The family of Luigi Mangione say they are "shocked and devastated"

Family of Luigi Mangione break silence after 26-year-old charged with murder of health insurance boss

Protests against the arrests of the suspected PKK members

Six people charged in London terror probe linked to banned PKK after 'extensive police investigation'

New promo image shows Stacey, Nessa, Gwen, Bryn and Gavin heading to Essex in the Picasso

Gavin And Stacey star says Christmas special will be 'nothing short of a masterpiece' - as new photos released

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu

Benjamin Netanyahu to take stand in corruption trial

Super Bowl LI - New England Patriots v Atlanta Falcons

Rupert Murdoch loses bid to give eldest son control of media empire in Succession-style legal battle

Israel Netanyahu’s Trial Explainer

Israel’s Netanyahu is set to take the stand in long-running corruption trial

Luigi Mangione has been charged with murdering UnitedHealthcare's CEO Brian Thompson

Ivy League graduate Luigi Mangione, 26, charged with murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson

South Korea Martial Law

South Korean prosecutors seek to arrest ex-defence minister over martial law

Philippines Volcano

Mass evacuation of Philippine villages underway after volcanic eruption

Members of a Joint Task Force with the FBI and the NYPD exit the Altoona Police Department, where suspect in the UnitedHealthcare chief executive shooting, 26-year old Luigi Mangione, is being held

Man suspected of killing UnitedHealthcare boss held without bail

Luigi Mangione has been named as the prime suspect in the killing of Brian Thompson.

Prime suspect in killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO appears in court after being arrested in McDonald's with manifesto

The UK has paused decisions on asylum applications from Syrians following the collapse of Bashar Assad's regime.

UK pauses Syrian asylum claims as ex-MI6 boss warns jihadis pose 'chronic' threat to West's security