Lucy Letby inquiry to look at links of killer nurse's crimes to Harold Shipman and Beverley Allitt murders

9 September 2024, 00:11

The Lucy Letby inquiry is set to look at whether the killer nurse was enabled to commit her vile crimes by NHS failure to implement changes after the murders by Beverley Allitt and Harold Shipman.
The Lucy Letby inquiry is set to look at whether the killer nurse was enabled to commit her vile crimes by NHS failure to implement changes after the murders by Beverley Allitt and Harold Shipman. Picture: Alamy

By Chay Quinn

The Lucy Letby inquiry is set to look at whether the killer nurse was enabled to commit her vile crimes by NHS failure to implement changes after the murders by Beverley Allitt and Harold Shipman.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The Thirlwall Inquiry, which opens on Monday, will see Barrister Sir Robert Francis KC examine how the NHS changed in response to killings by healthcare workers.

Solicitor Tamlin Bolton, representing the Letby victims' families, told The Mirror: "He has been asked to look back at things like Shipman, Beverley Allitt, the ­Mid-Staffs inquiry and consider the recommendations that followed. 

Read More: 'I'm with the families on this': Health Secretary slams 'insensitive' speculation surrounding child killer Lucy Letby

Read More: 'Lies and misinformation': Families of Lucy Letby murder victims slam campaign to free serial killer nurse

"What the recommendations were, how they were meant to be ­implemented, whether they were implemented, and how they have assisted or changed NHS practice."

So-called 'Doctor Death' Harold Shipman killed an estimated 284 people over 30 years working as an NHS GP.

The 'Angel of Death' Beverley Allitt was convicted of murdering four infants and attempting to kill three more as a children's nurse in 1991.

The revelation comes after the Health Secretary has called for an end to "crass and insensitive" speculation surrounding the innocence of convicted child killer Lucy Letby, telling LBC it's a matter "for the courts to decide".

Lucy Letby, Undated handout issued by Cheshire Constabulary of nurse Lucy Letby
The Lucy Letby inquiry is set to look at whether the killer nurse was enabled to commit her vile crimes by NHS failure to implement changes after the murders by Beverley Allitt and Harold Shipman. Picture: Alamy

Speaking on Sunday with Lewis Goodall, Wes Streeting addressed online commentary surrounding the innocence of the convicted child killer, telling the public to "do it quietly".

"I’m with the families on this," Wes Streeting said when asked about growing questions surrounding the nurse's conviction.

"I can’t imagine the unbelievable grief they’re going through without the constant speculation whether someone who has been convicted for these murders, with whole life sentences, being effectively presumed innocent by a number of people"

"Out of respect to the families, do it quietly. I actually think it is crass and insensitive to wage a public campaign in this way," he added.

Dr.Harold Frederick Shipman, (14th January 1946-13th January 2004) was an English general prctitioner who is beleived to be the most prolific seriel killer
'Doctor Death' Harold Shipman killed an estimated 284 people over 30 years working as an NHS GP. Picture: Alamy

Killer nurse Lucy Letby was found guilty of trying to murder a premature baby at the Countess of Chester Hospital in February 2016 earlier this year.

The 34-year-old was convicted by another jury last August of the murders of seven babies and the attempted murders of six others at the Countess of Chester Hospital's neo-natal unit between June 2015 and June 2016.

Wes Streeting on speculation around Lucy Letby's convictions: 'I'm with the families on this'

It comes as theories of an “unfair trial" gained traction online, with some claiming Lucy Letby's verdict is reliant on faulty evidence and have cast doubt on the safety of her conviction.

"We always presume innocence - Lucy Letby has been found guilty," Wes Streeting pointed out.

"What I would say to campaigners - whether it’s Lucy Letby's legal team or campaigners, is that there is a judicial process to follow.

"We can debate it, you and I; listeners can debate it; we can read the newspapers; we are not the criminal case review board," he told LBC.

Commenting on the case, Streeting, who was Shadow Health Secretary at the time, defended comments made by fellow MP David Davis, who this week questioned data used to support her conviction.

Read more: 'Lies and misinformation': Families of Lucy Letby murder victims slam campaign to free serial killer nurse

Read more: 'The only way out is reform': Starmer says NHS is 'broken' in 'unforgivable' ways in landmark health service review

"l'm not saying David Davis, by the way, is presuming her innocence; he’s raising questions about the data sets people are bringing forward and the questions clinicians are raising about whether there is reasonable doubt," he told LBC.

"Letby had the right to appeal, she took her appeal to the court of appeal - and that appeal was rejected in a judgement that went to 50 pages. It was a thorough consideration of the appeal - and it was rejected."

Watch again: Health Secretary Wes Streeting speaks to Lewis Goodall

It comes as the distraught families of the killer neo-natal nurse's newborn victims said they were suffering all over again - as politicians and campaigners raised questions over the conviction.

Some claim that Lucy Letby's verdict is reliant on faulty evidence and have cast doubt on the safety of her conviction.

"We have a fair and independent judiciary in this country. Let the judicial enquiry run its course," Streeting said.

"It is for the courts to decide on the basis of evidence," he said, adding: "Let the judicial enquiry run its course".

It comes as the Health Secretry told Lewis Goodhall that if Labour doesn't act now, the country will see "the NHS effectively going bust".

Streeting confirmed to LBC during the same interview that he still believes the Government can bring NHS waiting lists "down by millions" in the next five years and stood by his "constitutional commitments".

He also claimed the report revealed the NHS was "so badly prepared and resourced before the pandemic, we ended up cancelling more operations and appointments and procedures than any other major country".

The comments come ahead of a landmark review into the NHS treatment of children - which is due to be published on Thursday.

Penned by leading surgeon Lord Darzi, the wide-ranging report is expected to reveal that more than 100,000 infants aged under two were forced to wait more than six hours in A&E departments across England last year.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Yung Filly

British YouTuber Yung Filly granted bail after Australian court appearance on charges of rape and sexual assault

Entrance to the Mollie Kathleen Mine

One dead and 12 trapped 1,000ft underground in former Colorado gold mine

President Biden has slammed Donald Trump for spreading misinformation about the government's response ot Hurricane Milton

Biden tells Trump to 'get a life' in Hurricane Milton row as death toll continues to rise following storm

Tributes have poured in following the death of ex-Premier League footballer George Baldock aged 31.

Devastated fiancée of ex-Sheffield Utd star George Baldock pays tribute to her 'soulmate' after his death aged 31

A trial date has been set for Sean "Diddy" Combs to face sex trafficking charges.

'P Diddy' makes sombre appearance in court as trial date is set for sex trafficking case

Exclusive
Middle East is a better place than it was a year ago, Israeli ambassador claims

Middle East is a better place than it was a year ago, Israeli ambassador claims

Would you eat yours with a knife and fork?

Are you eating your burger all wrong? Former Royal butler says yes – and reveals how kings and queens eat theirs

President Biden has slammed Donald Trump for spreading misinformation about the government's response ot Hurricane Milton

'Get a life, man': Biden blasts Trump for spreading misinformation about government response to Hurricane Milton

A mother of five has died after a Brazilian Bum Lift procedure

Calls for crackdown on 'rogue Brazilian Butt Lift clinics' after mum-of-five becomes first to die from procedure in UK

Northern lights over Balgavies Loch, near Forfar

Parts of UK have 'decent chance' of seeing Northern Lights tonight

Nottingham Magistrates Court

Man accused of attempted murder ‘believed to be first charged with dognapping’ after pet stolen following incident

x

Calling a man 'bald' is sexual harassment, High Court rules

Cheryl Murray

Coronation Street star Cheryl Murray dies aged 71

The Princess of Wales laughs during a visit to Southport Community Centre

Princess Kate meets families of Southport stabbing victims in first engagement since cancer treatment

Rahmat Qalander has been jailed after raping a woman on a bus

'Dangerous sexual predator' jailed for raping woman on top deck of bus days after sexually assaulting another teen on bus

Lewis Edwards.

Mum admits helping paedo police officer son hide evidence