MPs launch inquiry into 'lessons learned' from Greensill lobbying scandal

14 April 2021, 18:08

MPs rejected Labour's bid to establish a committee to investigate the lobbying of Government in the Greensill scandal
MPs rejected Labour's bid to establish a committee to investigate the lobbying of Government in the Greensill scandal. Picture: Getty

By Maddie Goodfellow

MPs have rejected Labour's bid to establish a committee to investigate the lobbying of Government by 357 votes to 262.

However, shortly after the vote, the Treasury committee announced that it will launch an inquiry into the "lessons from Greensill Capital".

The cross-party committee will focus on the regulatory lessons from the failure of the firm and the appropriateness of the Treasury's response to lobbying - Mr Cameron contacted Chancellor Rishi Sunak and other ministers in relation to the company.

Committee chairman Mel Stride said: "The Treasury Committee had previously decided to carefully consider these issues as part of its regular and upcoming evidence sessions with HM Treasury and its associated bodies, including the Financial Conduct Authority and Bank of England.

"In addition to this, we have now decided to take a closer look by launching an inquiry to investigate the issues that fall within our remit.

"We will publish further details when we launch the inquiry officially next week."

It comes after Boris Johnson admitted it is not clear whether the "boundaries" between Whitehall and business have been "properly understood" as Labour claimed the Greensill row marks the return of "Tory sleaze".

The Prime Minister said an inquiry led by lawyer Nigel Boardman would examine the situation after it emerged the Government's former procurement chief had worked for Greensill Capital while still employed as a civil servant.

Meanwhile senior Tory William Wragg said former prime minister David Cameron's lobbying for the collapsed lender was "tasteless, slapdash and unbecoming" and indicated his cross-party committee could investigate the row.

The Government saw off an attempt by Labour to establish a separate parliamentary inquiry into the Greensill affair, which could have seen Mr Cameron and ministers including Chancellor Rishi Sunak and Health Secretary Matt Hancock forced to give evidence in public.

READ MORE: Greensill: James O'Brien caller can't find Labour equivalent after claiming 'all MPs are the same'

READ MORE: Starmer accuses Johnson of 'blocking proper inquiry' into Greensill lobbying scandal

As well as Mr Cameron's efforts to secure funding for the lender from a coronavirus bailout scheme, the affair has raised questions about a "revolving door" between Whitehall and the private sector.

Senior civil servant Bill Crothers began working for Greensill as a part-time adviser to the board in September 2015 and did not leave his role as Government chief commercial officer until November that year.

At Prime Minister's Questions, Mr Johnson said he shared the "widespread concern about some of the stuff that we're reading at the moment", and Cabinet Secretary Simon Case also had concerns.

"I do think it is a good idea in principle that top civil servants should be able to engage with business and should have experience of the private sector," Mr Johnson said.

"When I look at the accounts I'm reading to date, it's not clear that those boundaries had been properly understood and I've asked for a proper independent review of the arrangements that we have to be conducted by Nigel Boardman, and he will be reporting in June."

READ MORE: Greensill: 'Sleazy' David Cameron acted just 'to line his pockets', says MP Rachel Reeves

READ MORE: Cameron row: Top civil servant worked for Greensill Capital while at Cabinet Office

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer repeatedly questioned Mr Johnson about the row, saying an "overhaul of the whole broken system" was needed.

"The Greensill scandal is just the tip of the iceberg," he said.

"Dodgy contracts, privileged access, jobs for their mates, this is the return of Tory sleaze."

He said financier Lex Greensill was brought into the government as an adviser by Mr Cameron, before hiring the former prime minister to act as a lobbyist contacting Cabinet ministers including the Chancellor and Health Secretary.

"And now, even more unbelievably, we know the government's head of procurement, no less, became a Greensill adviser while he was still a civil servant," Sir Keir said.

There was a "revolving door, indeed an open door, between this Conservative government and paid lobbying".

In a reference to hit police corruption TV show Line Of Duty, Sir Keir said: "The more I listen to the Prime Minister, the more I think Ted Hastings and AC-12 is needed to get to the bottom of this one."

Mr Johnson insisted "we're getting on with rooting out bent coppers".

The Prime Minister insisted the Tories had been "consistently tough on lobbying".

Mr Wragg, chairman of the influential Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee, said Mr Cameron's activities were "no doubt a tasteless, slapdash and unbecoming episode for any former prime minister".

He said his committee "is and will be giving these matters proper consideration" and it is something "I am more than happy to take up as the AC-12 of Whitehall".

Labour's motion calling for a separate committee to be established was defeated by 357 votes to 262, majority 95.

The Opposition also criticised the appointment of Mr Boardman, whose father was a Tory minister, to lead the inquiry established by Mr Johnson.

He is pausing his role as a non-executive director of the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy and will be unpaid for his work on the inquiry.

But Sir Keir said law firm Slaughter and May, where Mr Boardman is a senior consultant, had "lobbied to loosen lobbying laws".

Shadow Cabinet Office minister Rachel Reeves said "it's a fact that Nigel Boardman is a very good friend of the Conservative Government" and "what is being proposed by the Government is not remotely fit for purpose".

"It's not an inquiry, it's not independent, it's an insult to us all," she said.

Downing Street said Mr Boardman was a "distinguished legal expert" and "an independent reviewer".

The Prime Minister's official spokesman said: "He was asked to lead this review independently, he has been asked to do it thoroughly and promptly, and we trust him to do that."