Mum of four killed by lorry driver after Green Flag 'refused to assist with broken down car'

16 August 2022, 19:05 | Updated: 16 August 2022, 19:09

Shirley-Ann Dumbuya was killed in a car crash on the M60.
Shirley-Ann Dumbuya was killed in a car crash on the M60. Picture: Greater Manchester Police

By Emma Soteriou

A lorry driver who crashed into and killed a mother-of-four who was stuck in her broken down car on a motorway has avoided an immediate prison sentence.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Shirley-Ann Dumbuya, 38, was unable to move her Kia Ceed from a hatch marked area of the M60 after being told by roadside assistance that she could not get help unless she was on the hard shoulder.

Minutes later, John Bowers, 35, hit the car with his skip lorry, killing the mum at the scene in Blackley, north Manchester.

Mrs Dumbuya left her home in Moston on January 21 2021 to sit one of her final student nursing student exams, Manchester Crown Court heard.

Within 10 minutes of her journey, the car broke down on the M60 - in the area separating lane one of the motorway from the slip road at junction 20.

She called her husband, who suggested she put her emergency lights on and get out of the car while he made a call to Green Flag.

However, the breakdown company said they would be unable to help unless the card was either on the hard shoulder or off the motorway altogether.

In its policy booklet, Green Flag says it will not be able to help motorists if their vehicle is 'going to be dangerous or illegal to load or transport'.

Meanwhile, Bowers was said to be travelling at 55mph and had an unobstructed view of the car for about 150 to 175 metres, with an expert report saying that his "error" was that he did not know that Kia Ceed had broken down.

He was not using his phone, he was not intoxicated and he was driving 15 miles under the speed limit.

In a police interview, he said his lorry had been working fine and there had been no distractions or medical conditions which would have impacted his driving.

Read more: Pop Idol star Darius Danesh found dead in apartment aged 41

Read more: Ryan Giggs says he's never been faithful and 'can't resist' attractive women as he takes stand in assault trial

Manchester Crown Court
Manchester Crown Court. Picture: Alamy

Sentencing, Judge Anthony Cross QC called for an enquiry by the Assistant Chief Constable in Greater Manchester to look into what should happen if a similar situation occurs again.

"Green Flag should take it upon themselves to ring 999 to help the person who was obviously panicking, wondering whether to stay or get out of the vehicle, and worrying about the other cars on the motorway," he said.

He added: "It's obvious to me that society has lost someone who was not only going to make a valuable contribution to society but who had already done so, just by being a good person. 

"It would be easy to wreak revenge on the defendant by jailing him but I rather suspect Mrs Dumbuya's family are not interested in vengeance."

Bowers, from Preston, admitted causing death by careless driving was sentenced to six months in jail, suspended for 12 months, banned from driving for three years and had his licence endorsed. 

For more information on what to do if you breakdown on a motorway click here.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters as he signs executive orders in the Oval Office at the White House, Monday, Feb. 10, 2025, in Washington. (Photo/Alex Brandon)

'No exceptions, no exemptions': Trump brings in 25% tariffs on steel and aluminium imports

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters as he signs executive orders in the Oval Office at the White House, Monday, Feb. 10, 2025, in Washington. (Photo/Alex Brandon)

'Let all hell break out': Trump says Gaza ceasefire 'should be axed' if Hamas doesn't free all hostages on Saturday

Kim Leadbeater after the bill passed its first reading in November

Assisted dying cases could go ahead without judge's approval

Kanye West

Kanye West slammed for Super Bowl advert directing viewers to site selling swastika t-shirts

Matar is accused of trying to murder Salman Rushdie

Man accused of trying to murder Salman Rushdie says 'Free Palestine' as he is led into court

Legendary strongman Geoff Capes left nearly £240,000 in his will

Legendary strongman and Olympian Geoff Capes leaves £240k in will following death aged 75

The scene in Coulter Road, Hammersmith, west London, following the death of a woman in a flat

Woman, 36, found dead after man seen trying to force his way into flat in west London

Quinn Parker

'Inhumane' NHS trust admits maternity failings as three babies die within months of each other

The Aesculapian snake can grow up to two metres in length

Europe's biggest snake 'thriving' in UK and living in people's attics, study finds

The Aurora Borealis, Or Northern Lights, Visible From Large Swath Of North America

Northern Lights to be visible across parts of UK tonight

Zhenhao Zou is accused of rape

Woman among 10 allegedly raped by Chinese PhD student in London left “angry and ashamed” after attack, court told

London, UK. 28th January, 2025. Attorney General Richard Hermer arrives in Downing Street to attend the weekly Cabinet meeting. Credit: Wiktor Szymanowicz/Alamy Live News

Labour spat as peer brands attorney general Lord Hermer 'arrogant, progressive fool' and calls for him to quit

Jaysley Beck, 19, was found dead at Larkhill Camp in Wiltshire

Soldier, 19, complained of 'unwelcome behaviour' from 'psychotic and possessive' boss before taking her own life

Watch the rousing Super Bowl ad directed by Michael Bay on behalf of the Secret Service

US Secret Service spends millions on recruitment film from Hollywood director Michael Bay

Father jailed for at least 15 years after murdering daughter, 14, in 'kitchen play fight'

Scarlett Vickers' grandad defends father who stabbed teen to death in 'kitchen play fight'

Israeli captive Eli Sharabi was handed over on Saturday

Hamas delays the release of hostages 'until further notice' over claims Israel violated ceasefire deal