Underwater search expert Peter Faulding 'caused challenges' to Nicola Bulley investigation, say police

21 November 2023, 10:00 | Updated: 21 November 2023, 11:32

A report has found Mr Faulding caused 'challenges' during the investigation into Ms Bulley's disappearance.
A report has found Mr Faulding caused 'challenges' during the investigation into Ms Bulley's disappearance. Picture: Alamy

By Jenny Medlicott

The diving expert who assisted search operations in the case of missing Nicola Bulley ‘caused challenges to the investigation’, a police report has found.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The body of Ms Bulley, 45, a mother-of-two, was found in the River Wyre on February 19, about a mile from where she vanished, while walking her dog in St Michael's on Wyre, Lancashire, on January 27.

A review into the police handling of Nicola Bulley’s disappearance examined underwater search expert Peter Faulding's role as part of its report.

The review was commissioned to examine the effectiveness of the police response during the case earlier this year, which saw unprecedented levels of mainstream and social media interest.

Mr Faulding, leader of underwater search experts Specialist Group International (SGI), assisted search operations into the missing mother-of-two.

At the time of Ms Bulley’s disappearance, Mr Faulding suggested to the media that the police’s equipment was too ‘low-tech’ to detect a body.

After his comments, Ms Bulley’s family asked police for SGI to assist the case.

While police investigators were told they were able to secure the same equipment used by SGI, the force went ahead with the family’s request to prevent ‘negative press'.

The force wanted to avoid a negative perception that police were not using every opportunity to locate Ms Bulley, the report said.

Read more: Paralympian Oscar Pistorius could be freed from prison after blunder in refusing murderer’s previous bids for parole

Read more: Police launch urgent hunt for group of teen boys missing after North Wales camping trip as family ‘frantic with worry’

A report has found that Peter Faulding caused 'challenges' to the investigation.
A report has found that Peter Faulding caused 'challenges' to the investigation. Picture: Alamy

Mr Faulding met with a chief inspector who provided “suitable, robust advice about the information he is passing to the media - unhelpful to the investigation, the family and wider community”.

The report also added that police appeared to have presented Mr Faulding with an NDA instructing SGI not to discuss the search with anyone outside the investigation - but SGI claimed that such an NDA had never been discussed or signed.

Mr Faulding alleged that he did not receive any instructions from police not to engage with the press and that his team had felt “ambushed” by the press, so he felt media involvement was "within the terms of engagement".

SGI carried out a sweep of the River Wyre a three-mile stretch of the river between St Michael’s and Cartford Bridge over two and a half days, using sonar equipment Mr Faulding described as “state of the art”.

Nicola Bulley's death was ruled as accidental.
Nicola Bulley's death was ruled as accidental. Picture: Handout

The review, published on Tuesday, also found that Mr Faulding caused unwarranted distress to Ms Bulley’s family after he told them he believed he had identified the site of her deceased body.

"It is the view of Lancashire Constabulary that Mr Faulding had a significant impact on the investigation and public confidence through his activities and his engagement with the media,” the report said.

"The review team considers that some of his actions created a more challenging environment for the investigation team.

"His public statements often contradicted the investigative and operational approach, leading to confusion for the public and reducing the family's trust in the investigation and search operation."

In a statement, Mr Faulding said in response: “I take confidentiality very seriously and would never breach an NDA or disclose any confidential or protectively marked material. The only instructions I was given was to use discretion and keep operational information confidential.

“I was never given any operational information and never disclosed any (ie: location of a significant target). If at any time I was asked to stop updating the media, I would have immediately, but no request was ever made.”

An inquest into Ms Bulley’s death earlier this year ruled that the mother-of-two’s death was accidental.

The case received unprecedented levels of public interest and saw Lancashire police face backlash for publicising the details of Ms Bulley’s medical history.

Ms Bulley's family have said they continue to grieve her loss and do not want to comment on the report.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Rescuers are on the verge of freeing the 41 construction workers

'Soon our brothers will be taken out': Indian rescuers reach 41 men trapped in tunnel in the Himalayas

Breaking News

Michael Gove apologises to bereaved families for government mistakes during Covid

It will snow later today, the Met Office has said

Exact time snow to hit UK as Met Office issues weather warning for later today

Israel Palestinians

Israeli campaign in southern Gaza must be ‘carefully thought through’ – US

The ambassador to Spain, Hugh Elliot, has waded into the row

Ambassador to Spain wades into 'cultural appropriation' row over M&S ‘Spanish’ croquettes that are filled with paella

India Tunnel Collapse

Indian workers trapped in tunnel for two weeks ‘close to being rescued’

Mark Harper defending the handling of the row over the Elgin Marbles

'It's not a snub, we offered them Oliver Dowden': Minister defends Sunak amid Elgin Marbles row

CORRECTION South Africa Mine Deaths

South African mine elevator crash leaves 11 dead and 75 hurt

Pakistan Politics

Imran Khan to face public trial on charges of revealing official secrets

Snow is expected to fall across the country

Snow alert issued as 11 areas to be hit by freezing temperatures - will your area be affected?

Maddy's family released a statement on Monday.

Maddy Cusack’s mother says football ‘broke daughter's spirit’ as Sheffield United to launch probe into her death aged 27

Susan Hall criticised Sadiq Khan after she was pickpocketed

Tory London mayoral candidate Susan Hall rages against Sadiq Khan after 'pickpocketing ordeal on Tube'

Sustainable aviation fuels (SAF) can be made from a variety of sources, including crops, household waste and cooking oils

Virgin Atlantic flight powered by cooking oil to make maiden journey from London to New York

Israel Palestinians Hostages

Hamas set to release more hostages as Gaza truce enters fifth day

National Highways has been contacted by coroners over smart motorways

Coroners write to National Highways over smart motorway fears as agency spends £500k on legal fees

Met chief Sir Mark Rowley

'Armed cops would rather face terrorists than gangsters', Met Police chief says