Plans for cheaper alternative of scrapped HS2 northern leg unveiled in which journeys would be only 15 minutes longer

13 September 2024, 13:55 | Updated: 13 September 2024, 13:58

A proposal to build a cheaper but slower alternative to a scrapped section of HS2 has been unveiled
A proposal to build a cheaper but slower alternative to a scrapped section of HS2 has been unveiled. Picture: Alamy

By Will Conroy

A proposal to build a new 50-mile railway line as a cheaper but slower alternative to a scrapped section of HS2 has been unveiled.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Journeys between London and Manchester would only be 15 minutes longer than under the original HS2 plans, a report has found.

The journey time would be 30 minutes quicker than they are today with the consortium behind the new line saying it could deliver "roughly 85% of the benefits of HS2 Phase 2" at 60-75% of the cost.

This comes nearly a year after spiralling costs led to former prime minister Rishi Sunak cancelling plans to extend HS2 between the West Midlands and Manchester.

Journeys between London and Manchester would only be 15 minutes longer than under the original HS2 plans
Journeys between London and Manchester would only be 15 minutes longer than under the original HS2 plans. Picture: Alamy

The report was commissioned by the mayors of Greater Manchester and the West Midlands, Andy Burnham and Richard Parker.

It found creating a new rail link between the two areas is critical to enhance capacity for passengers and freight moving between the regions.

Now, a coalition of private sector organisations led by former HS2 Ltd chairman Sir David Higgins described the proposed alternative new line as a "golden opportunity".

The line would go between Lichfield, Staffordshire and High Legh, Cheshire, connecting with the proposed east-west Northern Powerhouse Rail and would create a new link between Manchester and Birmingham.

Read more: Mind the gap: HS2 trains too high for existing station platforms and 'will cost taxpayer £200m to fix'

Read more: HS2 tunnelling leader and brother jailed for 3 years after rioting and attacking police at Rotherham migrant hotel

The report did not provide an estimated cost of the new project, but said financing should be "maximised from the private sector", with central and local governments "partnering to fund the balance".

Costs would be lower than with HS2 because of the need to design tracks for lower speeds and using simplified connections with the existing rail network, according to the report.

Ballasted track will be used whereby rails are supported by a layer of crushed rock and gravel while HS2, which will now only run between London and the West Midlands, will be built using slab track, which is more expensive.

The report said its plan would also "save the taxpayer £2 billion on costs" from the HS2 Phase 2 cancellation through reusing much of the land, powers and design work already secured through public funds.

The report was commissioned by the mayors of Greater Manchester and the West Midlands, Andy Burnham and Richard Parker
The report was commissioned by the mayors of Greater Manchester and the West Midlands, Andy Burnham and Richard Parker. Picture: Alamy

Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham said: "The report is clear: if we fail to put in place a plan soon to fix rail capacity and connectivity between the North and the Midlands, the already-congested West Coast Main Line and M6 will become major barriers to economic growth in the UK.

"But there is good news for the Government. The report concludes that we do not have to revive HS2 to unlock those benefits.

"There is a viable option to build a new rail line between Lichfield and High Legh, connecting HS2 to Northern Powerhouse Rail, with almost all of the benefits of HS2 delivered quickly and, crucially, at a significantly lower cost."

West Midlands mayor Richard Parker said: "Additional rail capacity to and from the North is vital for the West Midlands.

"It's about more than quicker journeys, it's about connecting people, communities, and businesses to jobs and opportunities.

"I'll work with the Government to ensure this happens."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Police officers hold back protesters trying to block the road.

Two arrested as protesters clash with police outside proposed site for new Chinese ‘mega-embassy’ in London

Duke and Duchess of Sussex.

'She's terrible': Trump takes swipe at Meghan, but will not deport Prince Harry

Freed Palestinian prisoners are greeted by a crowd as they arrive in the Gaza Strip after being released from an Israeli prison following a ceasefire agreement between Hamas and Israel in Khan Younis, southern Gaza Strip.

Emotional scenes in West Bank and Gaza as Palestinians reunited with their families after release from Israeli prisons

Elsie Dot Stancombe, Alice Dasilva Aguiar and Bebe King.

'She was grateful for life': parents of Southport stabbing victims pay tribute to their children

Israeli hostage reunited with his family.

Emotional moment Israeli hostages reunite with families after being paraded on stage by Hamas

Police officers hold back protesters trying to block the road at the rally.

Protesters clash with police as thousands rally outside proposed site for new Chinese ‘mega-embassy’ in London

The father of the Huszti sisters has said he believes his daughters were "kidnapped" and "cruelly killed"

Heartbroken father of sisters found dead in River Dee believes they were 'lured to their death'

Hollyoaks star and country singer thought to be son of British couple shot dead in French villa ‘by UK gangsters’

Hollyoaks star breaks silence over death of mum found dead in French villa with her husband

Harvey Willgoose's parents Caroline Willgoose (left) and Mark (right) holder a banner as they march to Bramall Lane in memory of their son

Hundreds gather for memorial march after 15-year-old Harvey Willgoose stabbed to death at school in Sheffield

Police tell locals to stay away from Jeremy Clarkson’s pub due to large gathering of pony and traps

Police tell locals to stay away from Jeremy Clarkson’s pub due to large gathering of pony and traps

Pauline Quirke

Birds of a Feather star Pauline Quirke 'struggling to identify family members' amid dementia battle

Detail of the logo on a Sony PlayStation 5 home video game console

PlayStation Network hit with worldwide outage as tens of thousands of gamers locked out

The Government has ordered Apple to allow it to access encrypted files uploaded to the cloud by any Apple user worldwide, it has been reported.

UK Government orders Apple to give it access to users’ encrypted data in 'unprecedented attack on privacy'

The wreckage of the small commuter plane that crashed in western Alaska has been found

Missing Alaska Bering Air plane found with all 10 people on board confirmed dead

Hollyoaks star and country singer thought to be son of British couple shot dead in French villa ‘by UK gangsters’

Hollyoaks star and country singer thought to be son of British couple shot dead in French villa ‘by UK gangsters’

Israeli hostages Or Levy, Eli Sharabi and Ohad Ben Ami have been released

'We won't gloss over the shocking scenes', warns Netanyahu as three freed by Hamas paraded on stage