Police Use Of Facial Recognition Technology Is "A Bit Ad Hoc" Court Hears

23 May 2019, 17:17

Police have deployed the controversial technology across the UK
Police have deployed the controversial technology across the UK. Picture: PA

Police are making up their own rules when it comes to facial recognition technology, a court has heard.

The landmark legal challenge issued by Ed Bridges from Cardiff who claims South Wales police violated his privacy and data protection rights.

Mr Bridges claimed the police used the technology on him when he went to buy a sandwich on during his lunch break and when he attended a peaceful anti-arms demonstration.

Mr Bridges said the incident caused him "distress."

Jeremy Johnson QC, for South Wales Police , said the force’s use was justified as it deterred people from carrying out crime, and information of a person’s face is not stored unless police already have the image of a known individual in their "watchlist."

A barrister for the Information Commissioner said that a legal framework should be drawn up for use of the technology, saying there was a lack of clarity on how the force compiled its watchlist of individuals, and in what circumstances it should be deployed.

Police in London have trailed the technology.
Police in London have trailed the technology. Picture: PA

The Minority Report-style technology scans all the faces in a crowd and then compares them against a database of images, which can include suspects, missing people or persons of interest to the police. 

The controversial cameras have been used by police to scan faces in large crowds in public places such as streets, shopping centres, football crowds and music events such as the Notting Hill carnival.

Mr Facenna said: "There is serious doubt whether the legal framework is sufficient.

"It's all a bit ad hoc. There's nothing sufficiently precise and specific."

Mr Facenna also questioned whether people should be able to refuse to be scanned in public after a man was fined for disorderly conduct after covering his face while passing a police van during a Metropolitan Police trial in London.

Dan Squires QC, representing Mr Bridges, told the final day of the hearing at the Administrative Court in Cardiff that AFR had given the police "extraordinary power", and said there were questions over whether there was sufficient legal protection against the "arbitrary and disproportionate use" of the scanning technology by police.

He said: "The police say that information is not retained for those not on their watch list.

"But it is not a legal requirement.

"The risk is if AFR can be used routinely across cities through CCTV cameras.

"The way South Wales Police have operated to date has been responsible and limited. But none of that comes from the law. That comes from self-restraint.

"Our submission is there should be a code of conduct."

The Right Honourable Lord Justice Haddon-Cave adjourned judgment for a later date, thanking parties for their submissions on "novel and potentially far-ranging issues".

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Prince William will be at the game on Sunday

‘Just one last push’: Prince William’s message to the England team ahead of Euro 2024 final against Spain

The family of the three women who were killed in a crossbow attack have said they are "devastated"

‘We are devastated’, John Hunt and surviving daughter say, after his wife and two daughters killed in crossbow attack

At least 71 Palestinians have been killed in an Israeli air strike

Dozens killed in air strike on Gaza humanitarian zone, claims Hamas as Israel investigates

The Princess of Wales is set to attend the Wimbledon Men's final

Princess of Wales to attend Wimbledon men's singles final in second public appearance since cancer diagnosis

Comedian John Bishop has divided fans after announcing he will be changing the time of his gig on Sunday

Wireless Festival and Comedian John Bishop spark controversy after changing set times for England's Euro 2024 final

Joe Biden has insisted he is staying in the race

Democrat donors ‘withhold $90m unless Biden stands down’ as Obama and Pelosi ‘oppose President’s re-election bid’

Two suitcases with human remains inside were found in Bristol

Armed police arrest man, 34, at train station following discovery of human remains in Bristol and west London

Princess Anne has returned to public duties for the first time since her accident

Princess Anne 'can't remember a single thing' about horse-related accident as she returns to public duties

Tony Blair was among a star-studded guest list at the wedding of the son of India's richest man

Tony Blair, Boris Johnson and wrestling star John Cena among guests at lavish wedding of Asia's richest man

Jay Slater went missing nearly a month ago

Jay Slater ‘looked unwell’ hours before he went missing, says Tenerife nightclub waitress who ‘gave him water’

Actor Alec Baldwin reacts during his trial for involuntary manslaughter

Alec Baldwin weeps in court as judge dismisses manslaughter case against actor after fatal shooting on film set

Police have named 24-year-old Colombian national Yostin Andres Mosquera as suspect

Suspect named in manhunt as more human remains found in flat after two bodies discovered in suitcases in Bristol

Patrice Evra has been given a suspended 12-month sentence after being found guilty of abandoning his family for over two years

Man United legend Evra given suspended 12-month prison sentence after being found guilty of abandoning family

The Prince of Wales will attend Sunday's Euro 2024 final in Berlin

Prince William to attend Euro final 2024 in Berlin as England take on Spain

Gareth Southgate has said it would be “emotionally impossible” to make a “logical decision” on his future

'Emotionally imposssible' to make decision on future ahead of Euro 2024 final, says England boss Southgate

A crime scene has been set up in Shepherd's Bush, west London

Manhunt for suspect widens to London after human remains of two men found in suitcases in Bristol