Robert Jenrick challenged to justify claim UK special forces 'kill rather than capture' terrorists due to EU law

1 October 2024, 08:56 | Updated: 1 October 2024, 11:36

Tory leadership hopeful Robert Jenrick has been widely criticised for his comments
Tory leadership hopeful Robert Jenrick has been widely criticised for his comments. Picture: MoD/Twitter
EJ Ward

By EJ Ward

Tory leadership hopeful James Cleverly said that the UK military does not "murder people" and challenged Robert Jenrick to justify his claims that special forces are killing rather than capturing terrorists.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The shadow home secretary was questioned about Jenrick’s claim, made during the Conservative leadership race, that British Special Forces, including the SAS, are instructed to kill rather than capture terrorists.

Jenrick's reasoning was that, under European law, captured terrorists could be freed.

Speaking to Sky News, Cleverly said: "You're going to have to ask Robert to justify that statement. That's not something which I have heard. That's not something which I'm comfortable kind of repeating."

He continued, "If Robert is able to justify that, I think he should. The British military always abide by international humanitarian law, the law of armed conflict. We have... the most professional military in the world. Our military do not murder people."

Jenrick, a former immigration minister, made the claim in a campaign video posted on X (formerly Twitter), where he stated: "Our special forces are killing rather than capturing terrorists because our lawyers tell us that if they are caught, the European court will set them free."

He has also pledged to remove the UK from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) if he is successful in his bid to become the Conservative Party leader and then win a General Election.

However, Jenrick’s comments have sparked widespread criticism, including from his fellow leadership contender, Tom Tugendhat. The former lieutenant colonel said: "I think what he said is wrong and I’m afraid demonstrates a fundamental misunderstanding of military operations and the law of armed conflict."

Tugendhat expressed concern that such statements could send the wrong message. "I’m extremely concerned that such words should not be seen in any way to encourage people to take any action other than to surrender to British forces when asked to do so. I think he’s wrong and demonstrates a fundamental lack of understanding."

One Army source hit out at Mr Jenrick's claims branding them "dangerous" and "disingenuous," he told LBC that "once again our military are preparing for a possible operation in Lebanon to evacuate British citizens and this politician is besmirching their name for political gain."

Operation Herrick was the codename under which all British operations in the War in Afghanistan were conducted from 2002 to the end of combat operations in 2014.
Operation Herrick was the codename under which all British operations in the War in Afghanistan were conducted from 2002 to the end of combat operations in 2014. Picture: Alamy

Labour has also condemned Jenrick’s comments, with a source calling for an apology. "Robert Jenrick’s ludicrous attempt to politicise our special forces shows you how far the Tories have fallen. He should apologise. Our brave service men and women deserve better than this."

The debate has emerged against the backdrop of a wider inquiry into alleged war crimes committed by British Special Forces in Afghanistan.

The inquiry, spurred by a BBC Panorama investigation, is examining claims that innocent Afghan civilians were executed by members of the SAS between 2010 and 2013.

Testimony submitted to the inquiry suggests as many as 80 people may have been killed during a campaign of night raids.

The allegations have raised serious questions about the conduct of British forces, though the Ministry of Defence has consistently maintained that the military operates within the bounds of international law.

Listen live to LBC, and catch up on any shows you missed, on Global Player.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

President Donald Trump speaks on Wednesday night

Trump says 'the US wants its money back on Ukraine' as he makes plans to meet Putin and end war

Exclusive
Katie Amess has spoken out about the need for an inquiry into her father's murder by an Islamist terrorist

Daughter of Sir David Amess, MP murdered by Islamist terrorist, ‘made to sign NDA’ on report into father’s death

Exclusive
Angela Rayner reveals she took advice from NHS trauma specialists ahead of Grenfell demolition meeting

Angela Rayner reveals she took advice from NHS trauma specialists ahead of Grenfell demolition meeting

Italian F1 Grand Prix - Previews

Nightclub bouncer behind £12m plot to reveal Formula One star Michael Schumacher's health secrets jailed

Josef Fritzl

Incest monster Josef Fritzl could walk free from prison next year - and expects 'cheering crowds' to greet him

Ofsted's Chief Inspector Sir Martyn Oliver supports an extension to term times

'Time to think about school holidays': Ofsted's Chief Inspector supports extending term times

Exclusive
Angela Rayner insisted that British support for Ukraine was 'unwavering'

Rayner insists UK support for Ukraine 'unwavering' despite Trump's plan for 'immediate' peace talks with Putin

Prince William, President of BAFTA, operates a film camera as he visits the London Screen Academy in London, Wednesday, Feb. 12, 2025. (AP Photo/Kirsty Wigglesworth, Pool)

William tries his hand at being a cameraman on visit to London film academy

President Donald J. Trump participates in a bilateral meeting with the President of the Russian Federation Vladimir Putin during the G20 Japan Summit Friday, June 28, 2019, in Osaka, Japan.

Trump and Putin 'to meet in Saudi Arabia' and 'start negotiations immediately' to end war in Ukraine

Street scene in Peckham, London, with red bus

Bus driver, 76, found guilty of killing passenger who was run over while attempting to board vehicle

Norward Road, Lambeth, the proposed LTN.

Council staff given 'wellbeing day' after attending 'stormy' neighbourhood meeting

United States Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, left, shakes hands with Britain's Defense Secretary John Healey prior to a bilateral meeting on the sidelines of a NATO defense ministers meeting at NATO headquarters in Brussels, Wednesday, Feb.

Ukraine's NATO membership plans 'unrealistic' says US - as defence secretary claims US troops won't be peacekeepers

Jaysley Beck, 19, was found dead at Larkhill Camp in Wiltshire

Officer accused of pinning down and trying to kiss soldier, 19, had been 'waiting for moment for them to be alone'

A public inquiry into the Nottingham attacks will begin 'within weeks'

Public inquiry into Nottingham attacks will begin 'within weeks', PM tells victims' families

Paul Allen.

Cagefighter guilty of Britain's largest cash robbery shot in neck in his kitchen in murder plot

Lucy Harrison

British woman, 23, dies after being shot dead at dad's US house as 'utterly heartbroken' family pays tribute