Second Post Office IT system 'likely' caused accounting issues, as 40 sub-postmasters 'falsely accused of stealing'

30 September 2024, 18:03 | Updated: 30 September 2024, 18:06

Second Post Office IT system 'likely' caused accounting issues, as 40 sub-postmasters 'falsely accused of stealing'
Second Post Office IT system 'likely' caused accounting issues, as 40 sub-postmasters 'falsely accused of stealing'. Picture: Alamy

By Christian Oliver

A second Post Office accounting system used by sub-postmasters - which predates the Horizon software - is likely to have also been faulty, an investigation has found.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

A report into the system, which was rolled out to branches nationwide from 1993, found it had "a reasonable likelihood" that the software "created shortfalls".

Some 40 sub-postmasters say they were falsely accused of stealing as a result of "glitches" in Capture.

The system was in place before Horizon, which saw hundreds of sub-postmasters wrongfully convicted between 1999 and 2015 because of erroneous shortfalls.

Post Office minister Gareth Thomas said he was "horrified" following the report into the Capture system and thanked former sub-postmasters for "coming forward to talk about the impact it had on their lives and livelihoods".

People outside the Post Office in Stoke Newington, Hackney
People outside the Post Office in Stoke Newington, Hackney. Picture: Alamy

Read More: Post Office campaigner Alan Bates knighted by Princess Anne for exposing Horizon IT scandal

Read More: Prince Harry makes rare return to London without Meghan to attend WellChild awards but King Charles stays in Scotland

The independent report into Capture by Kroll - a risk advisory and financial solutions company - said there was "a reasonable likelihood that Capture could have created shortfalls for sub-postmasters".

Despite "various control functions being in place" at the Post Office, there was an "acknowledgement both in internal and external communications during the 1990s that Capture had bugs and errors that varied in severity," the report continued.

"The burden placed upon sub-postmasters to implement fixes, which varied in complexity, together with a reliance on communications from Post Office Limited to identify these bugs and fixes, meant there was a high capacity for errors to go unnoticed."

The investigation did not comment on whether any convictions that arose from sub-postmasters using Capture could be considered unsafe.

Kroll interviewed 21 sub-postmasters for the report, including 12 who had been suspended by the Post Office.

"Of these 12, eight were prosecuted, two resigned, and two were terminated from their employment," the report continued.

"A further seven sub-postmasters were never suspended, but advised Kroll that they ended up selling their branch, in part or whole, due to losses they sustained during Capture use."

People waiting for counter services at the Post Office in Cambridge
People waiting for counter services at the Post Office in Cambridge. Picture: Alamy

Around 13.5 per cent of branches used Capture, with many of the sub-postmasters claiming that network managers and area managers pressured them to use the system.

Neil Hudgell from Hudgell Solicitors, who represents 70 of the sub-postmasters who used Capture, said: "It should never have needed such a long, hard battle to reach this stage, and there now must not be a long, hard battle ahead for exoneration and compensation."

A spokesperson for the Post Office told LBC: "We have, and will continue to, fully support the independent forensic accountancy investigation established by the Government into the Capture software.

"We have been very concerned from the outset about the reported problems relating to the use of the Capture software in the 1990s and are sincerely sorry for past failings that have caused suffering to postmasters.

"We remain determined that wrongs must be put right as far as that can be possible."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Celebrity Sightings In Los Angeles - February 18, 2025

ASAP Rocky embraces Rihanna as US rapper found not guilty of firing gun at former friend

Trump suggests Ukraine responsible for Russian invasion as he calls on country to elect new leader

Trump demands Zelenskyy hold elections as he suggests Ukraine responsible for Russian invasion

Rick Buckler

Rick Buckler, drummer of The Jam, dies aged 69 - former bandmate Paul Weller confirms

Kitchen knives on a magnetic bar holder on the wall

Round-edged blades safer alternatives than sharp-pointed kitchen knives, research shows - in bid to tackle knife crime

A large sinkhole has forced the closure of the high street in the Surrey village of Godstone

Homes evacuated and major incident declared after 65ft sinkhole appears in Surrey village

Lydia Mugambe

United Nations judge forced woman to work as slave after tricking her to come to UK, court hears

Craig and Lindsay Foreman

Did motorbike couple's 'happiness' survey prompt arrest on spying charges in Iran?

Abdirahman Ibrahim has been convicted of murder after driving into the back of Liam Jones

Killer driver mows down e-bike rider to 'teach him lesson' for doing wheelies

The Vatican says Pope Francis is being treated for 'bilateral pneumonia'

New scans show Pope Francis has pneumonia in both lungs but Vatican says he remains ‘in good spirits’

Meghan

Meghan Markle could face 'legal action' from Spanish town as her new luxury brand logo faces resemblance to coat of arms

The father of murdered schoolgirl Sara Sharif is reportedly being protected by a 'Muslim gang'

Sara Sharif's father protected by 'Muslim gang' in jail after being attacked with jagged tuna lid

Zhenhao Zou is accused of raping three women in London and 7 in China, whilst they were unconscious

PhD student 'discussed rape role-play' with alleged victim, trial hears

Exclusive
Senior Tories including Suella Braverman and Michael Gove have criticised the judge's comments

Senior Tories blast 'out of touch' judge for 'ludicrous attack' on Starmer’s migrant remarks

Shiri Bibas and her two young sons, Ariel and Kfir, died in an airstrike, Hamas said

Bodies of youngest Israeli hostage Kfir Bibas and his brother and mother to be handed over as family ‘in turmoil’

Lisa Smith, 43, was with a female friend when she was killed outside the Three Horseshoes pub in Knockholt, Kent

Man suspected of fatally shooting wife outside pub on Valentine's Day rang friend and said 'she's dead'

Carry On legend Julian Holloway dies aged 80

Carry On legend Julian Holloway dies aged 80 after 'brief illness' as tributes pour in