Nuns jailed for ‘cruel treatment’ of orphans after hitting them with rosary beads and making one eat own vomit

18 January 2024, 17:50 | Updated: 18 January 2024, 17:55

Three women have been jailed for their treatment of vulnerable children at Smyllum Park orphanage in the 60s and 70s.
Three women have been jailed for their treatment of vulnerable children at Smyllum Park orphanage in the 60s and 70s. Picture: Alamy

By Jenny Medlicott

Two nuns and a care worker have been jailed for subjecting children to ‘cruel and unnatural treatment’ while working at an orphanage.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Sister Sarah McDermott, 79, Sister Eileen Igoe and carer Margaret Hughes, 76, all worked for Smyllum Park, an orphanage and children's home run by a catholic charity in Lanark.

The court heard children were demeaned and subjected to verbal and physical abuse between the years 1969 and 1981.

All three women have been jailed for three years each after being found guilty of a number of ‘cruel and unnatural’ treatments while they were in positions of trust.

The three women all denied any wrongdoing as they went to trial at Airdrie Sheriff Court.

Children living in the home were usually placed there by social workers because of problems at home, or because they had nobody to look after them.

The jury heard each of the accused participated in excessive discipline and violence against young children.

Children were demeaned and subjected to verbal and physical abuse.

One woman told the court of how she was beaten by McDermott after she had reported witnessing her brother being sexually assaulted in a toilet in the orphanage.

Read more: Police watchdog to investigate whether officers 'missed opportunities' over death of two-year-old Bronson Battersby

Read more: Man arrested on suspicion of assisting Daniel Khalife’s alleged escape from HMP Wandsworth

She said volunteer worker Brian Dailey, who was later jailed for 15 years for abusing children, molested the three-year-old in the toilet cubicle.

After telling McDermott what she had witnessed, McDermott slapped the girl and accused her of bringing her "filthy home habits into a good Catholic place".

Smyllum Park shut down in 1981.
Smyllum Park shut down in 1981. Picture: Alamy

McDermott also hit another girl with rosary beads and repeatedly struck her on the head and body.

Igoe was convicted of abuse, which included making a child eat their own vomit and force-feeding others.

While Hughes seized one boy by the hair and struck him with her arm. She also forced a girl into a freezing bath before holding her head underwater.

Survivors of the abuse, now in their 50s and 60s, gave evidence at court, with many saying the impact of their treatment had left them with lifelong trauma.

Sheriff Scott Pattinson said the victims had been left with ongoing trust issues and problems forming relationships due to the psychological impact of their treatment.

He told McDermott, Hughes and Igoe: “You failed in your duty of care to the children in Smyllum and fell far short of your moral calling and commitment.”

He also said there was no alternative to prison for the three women as they were each sentenced to three years behind bars. Their sentences were shorter than usual due to the women’s ages and health issues.

The judge said he hoped the sentence would act as a deterrence to others.

“I am satisfied that the focus of my sentences should be punishment and deterrence, to punish you for the crimes committed and to deter all who have care of young children from similar conduct now and in the future,” he said.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Israeli hostage reunited with his family.

Emotional moment Israeli hostages reunite with families after being paraded on stage by Hamas

Police officers hold back protesters trying to block the road at the rally.

Protesters clash with police as thousands rally outside proposed site for new Chinese ‘mega-embassy’ in London

The father of the Huszti sisters has said he believes his daughters were "kidnapped" and "cruelly killed"

Heartbroken father of sisters found dead in River Dee believes they were 'lured to their death'

Hollyoaks star and country singer thought to be son of British couple shot dead in French villa ‘by UK gangsters’

Hollyoaks star breaks silence over death of mum found dead in French villa with her husband

Harvey Willgoose's parents Caroline Willgoose (left) and Mark (right) holder a banner as they march to Bramall Lane in memory of their son

Hundreds gather for memorial march after 15-year-old Harvey Willgoose stabbed to death at school in Sheffield

Police tell locals to stay away from Jeremy Clarkson’s pub due to large gathering of pony and traps

Police tell locals to stay away from Jeremy Clarkson’s pub due to large gathering of pony and traps

Pauline Quirke

Birds of a Feather star Pauline Quirke 'struggling to identify family members' amid dementia battle

Detail of the logo on a Sony PlayStation 5 home video game console

PlayStation Network hit with worldwide outage as tens of thousands of gamers locked out

The Government has ordered Apple to allow it to access encrypted files uploaded to the cloud by any Apple user worldwide, it has been reported.

UK Government orders Apple to give it access to users’ encrypted data in 'unprecedented attack on privacy'

The wreckage of the small commuter plane that crashed in western Alaska has been found

Missing Alaska Bering Air plane found with all 10 people on board confirmed dead

Hollyoaks star and country singer thought to be son of British couple shot dead in French villa ‘by UK gangsters’

Hollyoaks star and country singer thought to be son of British couple shot dead in French villa ‘by UK gangsters’

Israeli hostages Or Levy, Eli Sharabi and Ohad Ben Ami have been released

'We won't gloss over the shocking scenes', warns Netanyahu as three freed by Hamas paraded on stage

Harry and Meghan at the 2023 Invictus Games

Meghan to join Prince Harry at Invictus Games in Canada

Exclusive
General Secretary of the Fire Brigades Union Steve Wright is yet to receive a follow up on the minister’s comments.

Government must introduce health checks for firefighters after Grenfell, union says

c

New EPC rules for landlords could lead to higher rents and fewer homes

PM holds 'crisis summit' after Bank of England warning over 'Stagflation'

'Either be disruptors or disrupted': Starmer tells ministers at start of 'crisis summit' after 'Stagflation' warning