SNP MP cleared of allegations of sexual misconduct as investigation was 'flawed'

23 June 2022, 12:23 | Updated: 23 June 2022, 12:27

Patricia Gibson MP
Patricia Gibson MP. Picture: Alamy

By Gina Davidson

An MP who was accused of sexually harassing one of her party's staff by allegedly propositioning him in a House of Commons bar, has been cleared of the charge on appeal, with the original investigation process criticised for being flawed.

Patricia Gibson, the SNP MP for North Ayrshire and Arran, had been accused of "stroking" a young male employee and asking him to "come home and shag me".

He also alleged that she attempted to pull him into a taxi after an evening of socialising in Stranger's Bar in 2020.

The young man is the same employee who was found to have previously been sexually harassed by another SNP MP, Patrick Grady.

Grady, MP for Glasgow North was suspended from the Commons for two days after a parliamentary standards investigation found him guilty of "unwanted touching of a sexual nature".

A formal complaint against Mrs Gibson was made to Westminster authorities last year but she strongly denied the claims, which included stroking his arm and back through his clothes while she was drunk.

An investigation by the Parliamentary Standards Commissioner, which involved a number of witnesses, upheld the complaint of sexual misconduct, with the Commissioner concluding they were "satisfied that [the respondent] propositioned the complainant on more than one occasion and that this was conduct of a sexual nature."

However the MP appealed and she has now been cleared after the Independent Expert Panel reported that the initial investigation had been "materially flawed" in three key areas and not followed natural justice.

The report states: ""The investigator applied the wrong test in determining what constitutes conduct of a sexual nature in the Sexual Misconduct Policy.

"She failed to consider all the circumstances, including the complainant’s perspective, to decide whether it was reasonable to conclude that the conduct was sexual in nature.”

It said the "investigator placed too much weight on the complainant’s perception that the touching was sexual.

"Had the investigator applied the test correctly, then she would have taken account of perceptions of all of the witnesses and may have come to a different conclusion.“

And the report added that "unfairness" had also arisen "because of the substantial changes that the investigator made to the draft Formal Assessment Report after the Factual Accuracy Check.

The panel’s report, published today, also summarised Gibson’s denial of the allegation: “The respondent denied, and continues to deny, the allegation.

"Her evidence was (in essence) that she was intoxicated, and therefore unable confidently to recall her exact words and actions.

“The respondent asserted, however, that she would not have stroked the complainant in the manner alleged and would never have used the word “shag”, nor would she have propositioned the complainant.”

Commenting on the report, Patricia Gibsonsaid she was grateful to the panel for its "comprehensive assessment" of the case.

"I am reassured that the Independent Expert Panel has exonerated me, and has found that I am not guilty and that the investigation into this case was materially flawed.

"I have always maintained my innocence. It has been a very difficult 16 months during which my reputation has been wrongly and repeatedly traduced in the press and on social media, which has also jeopardised my personal safety with threats, abuse and harassment.

"I have found this period extremely traumatic but I am pleased that my reputation has been restored and now wish to draw a line under this matter and look to the future."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Breaking
Jeffrey Donaldson

DUP's Jeffrey Donaldson 'charged with allegations of historic nature' as he steps down as party leader

Russia bombed Ukrainian infrastructure overnight

Russia launches 'massive attack' on Ukraine's power supplies, with 'energy security under growing threat'

Newry Magistrates' Court

Man, 61, charged with non-recent sexual offences in Northern Ireland

Drivers queuing in Dover on Friday morning

Holidaymakers hit with 2-hour Dover ferry waits amid strong winds, as 2.6m hit the roads for Good Friday getaway

The attack happened on a train in south London

Teenager charged with attempted murder after south London train stabbing, with victim still in critical condition

Mother Natalie Pinnell

Mother left in tears after daughter with complex needs 'erased' from school photo

Amber Rudd and Mary Beard have both been nominated to the Garrick Club

Amber Rudd and Mary Beard among seven women nominated for membership of all-male Garrick Club

Exclusive
Anneliese Dodds said Labour would make sure local people have 'skin in the game' with tackling inequality

'Rebuild has to start from ground up,' Labour's Anneliese Dodds says, and 'local people must have skin in the game'

Mohamed Mansour has been awarded a knighthood

Conservatives accused of 'cronyism' after donor who gave £5 million awarded knighthood in surprise honours list

Exclusive
Justin Welby recalled his experience of coping with his father's drinking as a teenager.

‘It was utterly isolating’: Archbishop of Canterbury recalls harrowing childhood with alcoholic father

More than 2 million drivers are set to hit the road on Good Friday.

Easter Carmageddon: Over two million drivers to hit the road on Good Friday after Storm Nelson travel chaos

Michael Gove has slammed the water firm as a 'disgrace'.

Thames Water bosses branded a ‘disgrace’ as Michael Gove tells firm ‘not to punish consumers’ for its failings

South Africa Bus Crash

Girl, 8, the sole survivor as 45 die in bus crash off South Africa bridge

A spokesman has denied reports the sausage dog could be banned.

The wurst news is over: Germany denies claims of sausage dog ban

Israel Palestinians Britain Aid

UN top court orders Israel to open more land crossings into Gaza

Greece Confidence Vote

Greece’s government survives no-confidence motion called over rail disaster