Starmer facing backbench backlash over winter fuel allowance - but will not say if he will remove whip from rebels

7 September 2024, 20:21

Sir Keir Starmer is facing a backbench rebellion on next week's vote to restrict winter fuel allowance - but would not be drawn on how he will deal with MPs who do not support the changes.
Sir Keir Starmer is facing a backbench rebellion on next week's vote to restrict winter fuel allowance - but would not be drawn on how he will deal with MPs who do not support the changes. Picture: Alamy

By Chay Quinn

Sir Keir Starmer is facing a backbench rebellion on next week's vote to restrict winter fuel allowance - but would not be drawn on how he will deal with MPs who do not support the changes.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Speaking on a trip to Dublin, the Prime Minister said that removing the winter fuel payments for pensioners who are not in receipt of other state benefits was "tough decision" aimed at improving living standards.

The new affirmation comes after Rosie Duffield, Labour MP for Canterbury, said she would not vote to scale back the benefit.

Read More: Historic 'moment of reset' for UK-Ireland relations as Starmer becomes first British leader to visit nation in five years

Read More: President Joe Biden to host Keir Starmer in White House meeting

In Dublin, Sir Keir was asked how potential rebels could be punished if they do not vote with the Government, but would not be drawn into answering.

He told broadcasters: "I was elected in and our Government was elected in with a clear mandate for change.

"We will only bring about that change if we stabilise our economy."

Taoiseach Simon Harris (left) greets Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer on his arrival for a meeting at Farmleigh, the official Irish state guest house in Dublin, ahead of the Republic of Ireland v England football match
Speaking on a trip to Dublin, the Prime Minister said that removing the winter fuel payments for pensioners who are not in receipt of other state benefits was "tough decision" aimed at improving living standards. Picture: Alamy

Ms Duffield said earlier on Saturday that she could "absolutely not" support the move, joining other backbenchers who have voiced their concerns.

She was asked by Times Radio if she would join the Government in voting through the measure, and told the radio station: "No, absolutely not I'm afraid."

However, the MP said she would not vote against it, adding: "Because this Government has made it very clear that Labour MPs who vote against this new Government will be punished and have the whip removed.

"But I will be showing that I don't agree with them by abstaining and I know a few colleagues are doing the same."

Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced the plan to limit the winter fuel allowance in July, as she said there was a need to fill a £22 billion "black hole" in the public finances left by the previous government, a claim the Tories have challenged.

Only those who claim pension credit and other means-tested benefits will receive it after the change.

The new affirmation comes after Rosie Duffield, Labour MP for Canterbury, said she would not vote to scale back the benefit.
The new affirmation comes after Rosie Duffield, Labour MP for Canterbury, said she would not vote to scale back the benefit. Picture: Alamy

It is expected to reduce the number of pensioners in receipt of the up to £300 payment by 10 million, from 11.4 million to 1.5 million - most of whom claim pension credit - saving around £1.4 billion this year.

Thousands of pensioners have rushed to make pension credit claims in the five weeks since Ms Reeves's announcement, with applications up 115% on the five previous weeks.

In response, Sir Keir said: "We have got to take tough decisions. Targeting the winter fuel payments is a tough decision. We have put in safeguards for many pensioners, with pension credit, with housing benefit.

"Also by stabilising the economy we create the conditions in which we can ensure the triple lock is in place and that means for all state pensioners the amount of increase in the pension will outstrip any loss of the payment."

File photo dated 22/12/16 of an elderly woman holding pound coins in her hands, in Poole, Dorset. More than 850,000 pensioners will lose out as a result of the change in eligibility for the winter fuel payment
Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced the plan to limit the winter fuel allowance in July, as she said there was a need to fill a £22 billion "black hole" in the public finances left by the previous government, a claim the Tories have challenged. Picture: Alamy

The Prime Minister said he was "determined" to make the change, adding it would improve living standards, leave "people feeling better off", and lead to better public services.

Other Labour MPs have urged the Government not to go forward with the move by signing a Commons motion from Poole MP Neil Duncan-Jordan.

Some 11 Labour MPs are among the 27 who have signed the Early Day Motion which describes the plan as "a bureaucratic and unpopular means test" for pensioners.

Among their number are also several MPs suspended from the Labour Party for six months after voting for an SNP motion calling for the two-child benefit cap to be scrapped.

The Prime Minister would not be drawn into saying how Labour rebels would be punished if they vote against the Government on limiting the winter fuel payment.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Rick Buckler

Rick Buckler, drummer of The Jam, dies aged 69 - former bandmate Paul Weller confirms

Kitchen knives on a magnetic bar holder on the wall

Round-edged blades safer alternatives than sharp-pointed kitchen knives, research shows - in bid to tackle knife crime

A large sinkhole has forced the closure of the high street in the Surrey village of Godstone

Homes evacuated and major incident declared after 65ft sinkhole appears in Surrey village

Lydia Mugambe

United Nations judge forced woman to work as slave after tricking her to come to UK, court hears

Craig and Lindsay Foreman

Did motorbike couple's 'happiness' survey prompt arrest on spying charges in Iran?

Abdirahman Ibrahim has been convicted of murder after driving into the back of Liam Jones

Killer driver mows down e-bike rider to 'teach him lesson' for doing wheelies

The Vatican says Pope Francis is being treated for 'bilateral pneumonia'

New scans show Pope Francis has pneumonia in both lungs but Vatican says he remains ‘in good spirits’

Meghan

Meghan Markle could face 'legal action' from Spanish town as her new luxury brand logo faces resemblance to coat of arms

The father of murdered schoolgirl Sara Sharif is reportedly being protected by a 'Muslim gang'

Sara Sharif's father protected by 'Muslim gang' in jail after being attacked with jagged tuna lid

Zhenhao Zou is accused of raping three women in London and 7 in China, whilst they were unconscious

PhD student 'discussed rape role-play' with alleged victim, trial hears

Exclusive
Senior Tories including Suella Braverman and Michael Gove have criticised the judge's comments

Senior Tories blast 'out of touch' judge for 'ludicrous attack' on Starmer’s migrant remarks

Shiri Bibas and her two young sons, Ariel and Kfir, died in an airstrike, Hamas said

Bodies of youngest Israeli hostage Kfir Bibas and his brother and mother to be handed over as family ‘in turmoil’

Lisa Smith, 43, was with a female friend when she was killed outside the Three Horseshoes pub in Knockholt, Kent

Man suspected of fatally shooting wife outside pub on Valentine's Day rang friend and said 'she's dead'

Carry On legend Julian Holloway dies aged 80

Carry On legend Julian Holloway dies aged 80 after 'brief illness' as tributes pour in

Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov warned 'any appearance by armed forces under some other flag' in Ukraine would be 'completely unacceptable', in a dig at a peace plan floated by Keir Starmer.

Keir Starmer’s Ukraine peacekeeping plan ‘completely unacceptable’, Russia tells US in Saudi Arabia talks

Rita Lambourne, 58, was “fatally wounded” at her home in Bayencourt South, Bexhill

Man charged with axe murder of woman in own home