Parents of trans children 'can consent to puberty blocker use without court approval'

26 March 2021, 16:28

The High Court rules parents consent for puberty blockers can allow for treatment without a court ruling.
The High Court rules parents consent for puberty blockers can allow for treatment without a court ruling. Picture: PA

By Will Taylor

The parents of transgender children can consent to their treatment with puberty blockers on their child’s behalf without approval from a court, a judge has ruled.

The decision follows a separate, landmark High Court case which could have blocked the treatment of a 15-year-old who was born a boy but lives as a girl.

The girl, identified as XY, was on puberty blockers and the court was asked to rule that she and her father can consent to her treatment amid "uncertainty on the lawfulness of parental consent".

She had been treated with her own consent, but the separate, landmark ruling "cast (that view) into doubt".

There was concern her GP might not prescribe the treatment anymore.

Mrs Justice Lieven said the use of the blockers for children "raises unique and highly controversial ethical issues" and acknowledged views on it had become "highly polarised".

The verdict helps clarify the issue of consent with young people and puberty blockers.
The verdict helps clarify the issue of consent with young people and puberty blockers. Picture: PA

The previous case was brought by Keira Bell, who took puberty blockers aged 16 before "detransitioning".

Ms Bell later took legal action against an NHS trust which runs the UK’s only gender identity development service that provides treatment to transgender children, arguing children cannot properly consent to taking puberty blockers.

Judges ruled in Ms Bell’s favour in December and said children under 16 need to understand the consequences of treatment to be able to consent to using them.

The ruling is being challenged.

Read more: Boris Johnson says he will 'stamp out' LGBT conversion therapy

In a statement before the court at the hearing earlier in March, XY said: "The visible and irreversible onset of male puberty was very and most distressing for me.

"It also meant that my life wouldn't be my life any more and normal, where everyone knew and accepted me as female."

On Friday, Mrs Justice Lieven, who was one of the judges that gave the ruling in the Bell case, said she still agrees with that case.

However, she said parental consent was not considered by the court and in XY’s case there was agreement between the teenager, her parents and treating clinicians that her use of puberty blockers should continue.

She concluded: "In my view, the factors identified in (Ms Bell's case), which I fully agree with, do not justify removing the parental right to consent.

"The gravity of the decision to consent to puberty blockers is very great, but it is no more enormous than consenting to a child being allowed to die."

The judge said that in cases where there was disagreement between clinicians, or concern that parents were being "pressured" by their children to consent, then those cases should be brought to court.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

More than 2 million drivers are set to hit the road on Good Friday.

Easter Carmageddon: Over two million drivers to hit the road on Good Friday after Storm Nelson travel chaos

Michael Gove has slammed the water firm as a 'disgrace'.

Thames Water bosses branded a ‘disgrace’ as Michael Gove tells firm ‘not to punish consumers’ for its failings

South Africa Bus Crash

Girl, 8, the sole survivor as 45 die in bus crash off South Africa bridge

A spokesman has denied reports the sausage dog could be banned.

The wurst news is over: Germany denies claims of sausage dog ban

Israel Palestinians Britain Aid

UN top court orders Israel to open more land crossings into Gaza

Greece Confidence Vote

Greece’s government survives no-confidence motion called over rail disaster

A council has had to apologise following the incident.

Fury as parents offered version of school class photo without complex needs pupils

Conjoined twin who shot to fame with sister on The Oprah Winfrey Show marries army veteran in private ceremony

Conjoined twin who shot to fame with sister on The Oprah Winfrey Show marries army veteran in private ceremony

Israel Palestinians UN Security Council

Russia ‘abolishes’ monitoring of sanctions on North Korea with UN veto

Firefighters at the scene of a bus crash in Limpopo

Bus plunges from bridge in South Africa and erupts into flames, killing at least 45 and leaving child, 8, as lone survivor

Music-Green Day UN

Green Day to headline UN-backed global climate concert

Exclusive
Starmer has vowed to resurrect Boris Johnson's 'Levelling Up' policy

Failure to ‘level up’ Britain would be ‘catastrophic’, Wes Streeting admits, as Starmer vows to resurrect Johnson policy

Border Force staff will walk out from April 11

Hundreds of Border Force officers at Heathrow Airport to stage four-day strike

Stephen Bear was ordered to pay Ms Harrison £5,000.

Disgraced reality TV star Stephen Bear ordered to pay £27,000 over revenge porn conviction or face nine months in jail

Sam Bankman-Fried

FTX founder Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years in prison for crypto fraud

Exclusive
Covid no excuse for death of Finley Boden who was murdered by drug-addled parents, child protection chief says

Covid no excuse for death of Finley Boden who was murdered by drug-addled parents, child protection chief says