UK's extremism approach should be based on behaviour and activity - rather than ideology, review claims

28 January 2025, 05:53 | Updated: 28 January 2025, 06:16

Yvette Cooper Makes First Visit As New Home Secretary
The UK's approach to extremism should be based on concerning behaviours and activity rather than ideologies, according to a leaked Home Office review. Picture: Getty

By Flaminia Luck

The UK's approach to extremism should be based on concerning behaviours and activity rather than ideologies, according to a leaked Home Office review.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Those include spreading misinformation, influencing racism, and involvement in "an online subculture called the manosphere", according to the Policy Exchange think tank, which obtained a copy of the review.

Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said in August she had directed the Home Office to conduct a "rapid analytical sprint on extremism" to map and monitor trends and inform the Government's approach.

The BBC reported that Ms Cooper disagrees with some of the central findings of the report and will push the Government to continue to focus on Islamist and far-right extremism.

A Home Office spokesperson told the BBC "a wide range of potential next steps" from the report were being considered.

The report recommends reversing a code of practice to limit the number of "non-crime hate incidents" being recorded and floats the idea of creating a new crime of making "harmful communications" online, according to Policy Exchange.

It says claims of "two-tier" policing are an example of a "right-wing extremist narrative".

The think tank said the review lists "behaviours and activity of concern" and "damaging extremist beliefs" including misogyny, violence against women and girls and having a "fixation on gore and violence without adherence to an extremist ideology".

It also lists "spreading misinformation and conspiracy theories", "influencing racism and intolerance" and involvement in an "online subculture called the manosphere".

Paul Stott and Andrew Gilligan, of Policy Exchange, said in an analysis of the report that the suggested approach risks swamping authorities with new cases.

They said: "This new approach risks swamping already stretched counter-extremism interveners and counter-terror police with tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of new cases, making it more likely that dangerous people will be missed.

"Some of the definitions of extremism also threaten free speech, defining aspects of normal and legitimate political debate as extremist."

The review notes that not all individuals associated with the manosphere promote extreme views and that it is "challenging to identify the extent to which misogyny is explicitly and consciously (or unconsciously) operationalised among violent extremists", the think tank said.

A
Axel Rudakubana. Picture: Merseyside Police

Read more: Southport killer Axel Rudakubana 'likely to die in jail' as he's sentenced to 52 years for the murder of three girls

Read more: Inside Southport killer's bedroom: Chilling photos show triple murderer Axel Rudakubana's weapons cache

After Axel Rudakubana, 18, pleaded guilty last week to murdering three girls at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class, Sir Keir Starmer said it was understandable that the public would look at the crime and "wonder what the word terrorism means".

The Prime Minister said the teenager represented a new kind of threat, distinct from politically or ideologically motivated terrorism, with "acts of extreme violence perpetrated by loners, misfits, young men in their bedroom, accessing all manner of material online, desperate for notoriety".

He said that if needed, the Government would change the law to recognise the "new and dangerous threat" and "review our entire counter-extremist system to make sure we have what we need to defeat it".

Rudakubana was referred to the Prevent anti-terror programme three times but those referrals were closed due to his apparent lack of a clear ideology.

The Home Secretary has ordered a review of Prevent's thresholds in response.

A Home Office spokesperson said: "The counter-extremism sprint sought to comprehensively assess the challenge facing our country and lay the foundations for a new approach to tackling extremism - so we can stop people being drawn towards hateful ideologies.

"This includes tackling Islamism and extreme right-wing ideologies, which are the most prominent today.

"The findings from the sprint have not been formally agreed by ministers and we are considering a wide range of potential next steps arising from that work."

Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said: "By extending the definition of extremism so widely, the Government risks losing focus on ideologically motivated terrorists who pose the most risk to life.

"In fact, the Shawcross Review of Prevent made clear that counter-extremism and the counterterrorism strategy should be more focused on terrorist ideology, not less.

"Prevent must be equipped to deal with the terrorist threats in our society, and we should not be dialling back efforts to confront this."

He added: "Other appalling and unacceptable criminal behaviour that is not ideologically motivated - of which there are many kinds - should be dealt with via the police and criminal justice system, and via other agencies such as social services and mental health services, including sectioning those that present a risk.

"Non-crime hate incidents, where there is no imminent risk of criminality, often waste police time and infringe freedom of speech.

"The last government made important changes to ensure that personal data is only recorded and investigations only take place where there is an imminent risk of criminality." That was a "sensible approach", Mr Philp said.

He added: "What the Government seems to be planning is a backwards step in the interests of the political correctness we know Keir Starmer loves.

"Starmer wants the thought police to stop anyone telling uncomfortable truths that he and his left-wing lawyer friends don't like."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has arrived in Saudi Arabia for peace talks with Russia as the war in Ukraine rages on.

US-Russia peace talks for Ukraine begin as Europe blocked out of Saudi Arabia meeting

Harry received a standing ovation at the closing ceremony.

Meghan's four-word response as Prince Harry receives standing ovation in emotional Invictus Games closing ceremony

Exclusive
Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer (far right) visits the Tapa NATO forward operating base in Estonia.

Starmer should send 'warships, combat brigade, and air squadrons' to Ukraine in show of leadership, says ex-armed forces minister

Millions of jobs at risk as UK firms mull biggest layoffs in close to a decade amid plunging business confidence

Millions of jobs at risk as UK firms mull 'biggest layoffs in a decade' amid plunging business confidence

Wes Streeting says campaign to free Lucy Letby is 'not right'

'This isn't a political campaign, it's a legal process': Wes Streeting says campaign to free Lucy Letby is 'not right'

Exclusive
West Streeting, left, has back Sir Keir Starmer after the Prime Minister said he was ready to put British troops on the ground in Ukraine.

Peace in Ukraine 'vital for Britain's freedom', says Streeting as he backs PM's calls for troops on the ground

From Conclave to The Brutalist - the full 2025 BAFTA's winners list revealed

From Conclave to The Brutalist - the full 2025 BAFTA's winners list revealed

President Zelenskyy of Ukraine has arrived in the United Arab Emirates ahead of this week's expected peace talks aimed at ending his country's war with Russia.

Zelenskyy visits UAE as Starmer signals support for British troop deployment in Ukraine peacekeeping

Emergency services were called just after 7pm on Friday amid reports a woman had suffered serious injuries

'I thought it was fireworks': Pub landlady describes moments before fatal Valentine's Day car park shooting

Danielle McLaughlin's killer Baghat was finally found guilty today

Man sentenced to life in prison over rape and murder of Irish backpacker Danielle McLaughlin in Goa

Shakira: Las Mujeres Ya No Lloran World Tour Kick Off - Rio de Janeiro

Singer Shakira admitted to hospital after abdominal issues force her to cancel concert

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Kyiv 'not invited' to US-Russia peace negotiations

Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer

NHS on 'road to recovery', claims PM as he meets pledge to deliver two million extra appointments

Sir Keir Starmer, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom and Volodymyr Zelenskyy, President of Ukraine.

'I'm ready to put British troops into Ukraine', Keir Starmer says ahead of emergency Paris summit

Princess of Wales 'put her foot down'

Kate 'put her foot down' and stopped George, Charlotte and Louis taking part in gory hunting tradition

LONDON, ENGLAND - FEBRUARY 16: Mikey Madison, winner of Leading Actress Award for 'Anora' and Adrien Brody, winner of the Leading Actor Award for 'The Brutalist'

Conclave wins Best Film at BAFTAs as Adrien Brody named Best Actor