Wagatha Christie: Rebecca Vardy claims partial victory against Coleen Rooney

7 July 2021, 12:55

Rebekah Vardy has suceeded in the latest legal round of Wagatha Christie
Rebekah Vardy has suceeded in the latest legal round of Wagatha Christie. Picture: PA

By Kate Buck

Rebekah Vardy has succeeded in having parts of Coleen Rooney's defence in their libel battle thrown out by a High Court judge.

Mrs Justice Steyn dismissed a claim by Mrs Rooney that her fellow footballer's wife showed "publicity seeking behaviour" when sitting behind Mrs Rooney in someone else's seat at the 2016 Euros.

Mrs Justice Steyn found that even assuming the allegation was true, it would still not help Mrs Rooney's case.

She said: "The fact that a person seeks media coverage of their own attendance at a football match does not make it more probable that they would disclose private information about another person to the press."

Read more: Rebekah Vardy wins first stage in 'Wagatha Christie' libel case against Coleen Rooney

However, Mrs Justice Steyn ruled against Mrs Vardy on other parts of Mrs Rooney's defence and denied her bid for summary judgment - a legal step which would see that part of the case resolved without a trial - concerning Mrs Rooney's claim that Mrs Vardy leaked a story to The Sun about her returning to TV presenting.

Mrs Vardy, who is married to Leicester City striker Jamie Vardy, is suing Mrs Rooney for libel after Mrs Rooney, 35, accused her of leaking "false stories" about her private life in October 2019 after carrying out a months-long "sting operation".

Mrs Vardy, who is married to Leicester City striker Jamie Vardy, is suing Mrs Rooney for libel after Mrs Rooney, 35, accused her of leaking "false stories" about her private life
Mrs Vardy, who is married to Leicester City striker Jamie Vardy, is suing Mrs Rooney for libel after Mrs Rooney, 35, accused her of leaking "false stories" about her private life. Picture: PA

The wife of former England star Wayne Rooney publicly claimed her fellow footballer's wife shared fake stories she had posted on her personal Instagram account with the newspaper, earning her the nickname "Wagatha Christie".

In the latest round of the case, Mrs Vardy's lawyers asked the High Court to throw out parts of Mrs Rooney's defence, including allegations of Mrs Vardy's close relationship with The Sun and her alleged but denied authorship of "The Secret Wag" column.

At the hearing in June, Hugh Tomlinson QC argued these were "irrelevant or peripheral" to the case and that the central issue was whether Mrs Vardy was leaking posts from Mrs Rooney's Instagram.

In his written submissions, Mr Tomlinson said most of the claims made by Mrs Rooney's lawyers were in dispute and denied.

He continued: "Even if it were established that the claimant has 'an exceptionally close relationship' with The Sun, that it gave her positive coverage, that she has a history of self-promotion or is the 'Secret Wag', does not mean that it is more likely than not that the claimant had regularly informed The Sun about the defendant's private posts."

(Mrs Rooney pictured) Mrs Vardy has denied any knowledge or authorisation of passing on private information.
(Mrs Rooney pictured) Mrs Vardy has denied any knowledge or authorisation of passing on private information. Picture: PA

Mr Tomlinson later highlighted that both women have a public profile and their own relationships with the media.

He said: "What has happened in this case is that the defendant has gone through the claimant's appearances in the newspapers, put two and two together and made seven."

The move to throw out part of the defence was opposed by Mrs Rooney, with her barrister David Sherborne arguing that the "exceptionally close relationship" Mrs Vardy is said to have had with The Sun is a key part of the case.

In written submissions, Mr Sherborne said Mrs Vardy had a "habitual practice" of providing private information to the press to promote or financially exploit her public profile.

The barrister later claimed that Mrs Vardy would receive a split of commission and revenue for stories given to The Sun through the Front Row Partnership, a PR agency where Mrs Vardy was a client.

He also said that the evidence showed Mrs Vardy was in a "very uneasy position" and said the request to throw it out was a tactical move as it would "undermine her case as well as embarrass her".

Mrs Vardy has denied any knowledge or authorisation of passing on private information.

She also applied for summary judgment - a legal step which would see that part of the case resolved without a trial - in relation to Mrs Rooney's claim that Mrs Vardy leaked a story to The Sun about her returning to TV presenting.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Drivers queuing in Dover on Friday morning

Holidaymakers hit with 2-hour Dover ferry waits amid strong winds, as 2.6m hit the roads for Good Friday getaway

The attack happened on a train in south London

Teenager charged with attempted murder after south London train stabbing, with victim still in critical condition

Mother Natalie Pinnell

Mother left in tears after daughter with complex needs 'erased' from school photo

Amber Rudd and Mary Beard have both been nominated to the Garrick Club

Amber Rudd and Mary Beard among seven women nominated for membership of all-male Garrick Club

Exclusive
Anneliese Dodds said Labour would make sure local people have 'skin in the game' with tackling inequality

'Rebuild has to start from ground up,' Labour's Anneliese Dodds says, and 'local people must have skin in the game'

Mohamed Mansour has been awarded a knighthood

Conservatives accused of 'cronyism' after donor who gave £5 million awarded knighthood in surprise honours list

Exclusive
Justin Welby recalled his experience of coping with his father's drinking as a teenager.

‘It was utterly isolating’: Archbishop of Canterbury recalls harrowing childhood with alcoholic father

More than 2 million drivers are set to hit the road on Good Friday.

Easter Carmageddon: Over two million drivers to hit the road on Good Friday after Storm Nelson travel chaos

Michael Gove has slammed the water firm as a 'disgrace'.

Thames Water bosses branded a ‘disgrace’ as Michael Gove tells firm ‘not to punish consumers’ for its failings

South Africa Bus Crash

Girl, 8, the sole survivor as 45 die in bus crash off South Africa bridge

A spokesman has denied reports the sausage dog could be banned.

The wurst news is over: Germany denies claims of sausage dog ban

Israel Palestinians Britain Aid

UN top court orders Israel to open more land crossings into Gaza

Greece Confidence Vote

Greece’s government survives no-confidence motion called over rail disaster

A council has had to apologise following the incident.

Fury as parents offered version of school class photo without complex needs pupils

Conjoined twin who shot to fame with sister on The Oprah Winfrey Show marries army veteran in private ceremony

Conjoined twin who shot to fame with sister on The Oprah Winfrey Show marries army veteran in private ceremony

Israel Palestinians UN Security Council

Russia ‘abolishes’ monitoring of sanctions on North Korea with UN veto