James O'Brien clashes with caller over anti-lockdown scientists

2 November 2020, 15:05

By Fiona Jones

This is the moment James O'Brien clashes with a caller over how much media attention should be given to anti-lockdown scientists.

Caller James from Liverpool took exception to James O'Brien's comparison of anti-lockdown scientists with anti-climate change scientists.

"Epidemiology, public health, virology, immunity is not one consensus...climate change is much more recorded for years and years and years," he said.

James O'Brien responded that until very recently outlets could not have climate change scientists on without having an opposition there to deny its existence.

The caller said that comparing anti-lockdown Sunetra Gupta, theoretical epidemiologist at the Department of Zoology, with climate change deniers implies she is "not in consensus" - to which James pointed out she is not in consensus with SAGE or independent SAGE.

"Independent SAGE was set up precisely because of concerns that Government SAGE might be in the pocket of the Government and they are all part of the consensus in regard to lockdowns and circuit breakers," James said.

After the caller insisted WHO does not believe in lockdowns, James clarified that WHO have said nothing will succeed "unless it is supported by test, trace and isolate."

James said that he is not saying anti-lockdown scientists are wrong, he is merely pointing out they do not conform with the consensus.

"What you have in the context of consensus is a view that is supported by a massive majority of what we would call, for the sake of argument, qualified scientists," James said, "we will always be able to find a few who don't agree with the consensus...you couldn't name one and now you're laughing at the idea of there only being a few."

He pointed out that if 90% of scientists believe in a lockdown and 10% do not, then the media should reflect that.

'This is levelling down': Universal credit caller hits out at benefit cut

'This is levelling down': Universal Credit recipient hits out at benefit cut

James O'Brien: 'How are Covid naysayers opposed to both masks and jabs?'

James O'Brien: 'How are Covid naysayers opposed to both masks and jabs?'

James O'Brien caller despairs as conspiracist wife won't let kids have Covid jab

James O'Brien caller despairs as conspiracist wife won't let kids have Covid jab

'I'd rather Insulate Britain shut down supermarkets than disrupt commuters': James O'Brien caller

James O'Brien caller would rather 'Insulate Britain shut down supermarkets'

James O'Brien clashes with caller defending Gavin Williamson's mix-up of Black sportsmen

James O'Brien clashes with caller defending Gavin Williamson's Black sportsmen mix-up

James O'Brien reflected on the issue

James O'Brien's warning on ignoring the fine print on Boris Johnson's care deal

Sadiq Khan hits out at Tory MPs ditching masks, fearing effect on commuters

Sadiq Khan hits out at Tory MPs ditching masks, fearing effect on commuters

James reacted to the reported plans

James O'Brien's take on why the PM is concerned about social care funding

'Daddy keep away from me': Caller tells of daughter 'driven' by Covid conspiracies

'Daddy keep away from me': Caller tells of daughter 'driven' by Covid conspiracies

'It's one rule for Nazi sympathisers and another for sympathisers of other terrorists'

'It's one rule for Nazi sympathisers and another for sympathisers of other terrorists'

James O'Brien pondered the issue if masks on public transport

'What's the problem with not wearing a mask on the Tube? What do you lose?'

'Just get jabbed!': LBC's Theo Usherwood opens up about impact Covid has had on him

'I'd give every material possession I own to not have had Covid'

James O'Brien: Boris Johnson is the Shaggy of British politics

James O'Brien: Boris Johnson is the Shaggy of British politics

The doctor told James the shocking tale

Doctor tells harrowing tale of unvaccinated, pregnant patient ending up in ICU

Afghanistan: Ex-Soldier says lost lives 'were for nothing'

Ex-Soldier says British lives lost in Afghanistan 'were for nothing'

Lord Bethell breaking phone 'could be criminal offense', says Good Law Project

Barrister explains his investigation into Lord Bethell’s new phone