James Picks Apart Consultant Arguing He Shouldn’t Pay More Tax

8 May 2017, 12:39 | Updated: 8 May 2017, 13:56

When a management consultant argued against tax rises for people on more than £80,000, James turned the argument back on him.

Dan in Shepherd's Bush phoned-in in defense of higher earners.

He said that he, and most of his friends, earn more than £80,000, and that they deserve this because of how hard they work.

"We work extremely hard. 15, 16 hours a day, often working at the weekends. I don't think that's reflected in the wider population."

James pointed out that many of those in the top five per cent of earners will be there because of inheritence and dividends on investments, which don't require much work. James said how hard you work has nothing to do with how much tax you pay.

"I’m not suggesting that everyone who works hard.

"I’m suggesting that when I hear about teachers working 16 hours a day and paramedics working in circumstances you wouldn’t wish on your worst enemy, I reject the conflation… that you work harder by definition than people who earn less than you."

Dan said he recognised that some people on low incomes work very hard, but that everyone he knows on high income works very hard.

He said he agreed that people who earn more should pay more, but he said it needed to be fair.

“I feel we’re getting to a point now where if taxes went up further than they are, it would feel distinctly unfair to me.”

James said that the question wasn’t about fairness as Dan phrased it. It was about accepting that the country doesn’t have enough money, so where do you go for it? The people who have got lots or the people who haven’t?

“The people who have the most should pay the most, but having a binary threshold at £80,000 feels like I’m being penalised.” Dan said.

“Well then earn more and you won’t feel penalised. You’ll be able to suck it up and move on. Work harder, Dan!” James told him, “That’s your own message, mate, and I think you realise how hollow it sounds.”

'Almost anybody' would be better PM than 'shoddy' Boris Johnson, Rory Stewart tells LBC

'Almost anybody' would be better PM than 'shoddy' Boris Johnson, Rory Stewart tells LBC

James O'Brien's brutal dismantling of PM's plea to Tories

James O'Brien's brutal dismantling of PM's plea to Tories

James O'Brien skewers Tory politicians who don't want PM to face leadership contest

James O'Brien skewers Tory politicians who don't want PM to face leadership contest

Home Office 'tried to bury' report exposing racist origins of Windrush scandal, says journalist

Home Office 'tried to bury' report exposing racism that led to Windrush, says journalist

Author explains fascinating history of metric system amidst imperial measurements row

Author explains fascinating history of metric system amid imperial measurements row

Lord O'Neill hails 'really cool' initiative for people to donate energy bill rebate to less fortunate

Lord O'Neill hails initiative for people to donate energy bill rebate to less fortunate

James O'Brien dissects 'baffling' US gun control opposition

James O'Brien dissects 'baffling' US gun control opposition

James O'Brien: Boris Johnson 'thinks he's the real victim' of Partygate

James O'Brien: Boris Johnson 'thinks he's the real victim' of Partygate

'I feel used!' Tearful veteran 'embarrassed' by Britain's Afghan withdrawal

'I feel used!': Tearful veteran 'embarrassed' by Britain's Afghan withdrawal

James O'Brien's 'astonishing' takedown of PM's Partygate misconduct

James O'Brien's 'astonishing' takedown of PM's Partygate misconduct

Boys at Rishi Sunak's school had 'no idea' about outside world says ex-employee

Boys at Rishi Sunak's school had 'no idea' about outside world says ex-employee

James O'Brien: Rishi Sunak's wealth 'unjustifiable' amid cost of living crisis

James O'Brien: Rishi Sunak's wealth 'unjustifiable' amid cost of living crisis

John Sweeney: I do not think that Vladimir Putin has long for this world

John Sweeney: I do not think that Vladimir Putin has long for this world

James O'Brien tears apart government's 'ideological' opposition to a windfall tax

James O'Brien tears apart government's 'ideological' opposition to a windfall tax

Most Red Wall seats worse off under Boris Johnson despite levelling up promise

Most Red Wall seats worse off under Boris Johnson despite levelling up promise

James O'Brien: Boris Johnson 'running scared of backbenchers' over obesity

James O'Brien: Boris Johnson 'running scared of backbenchers' over obesity