Health Secretary Reveals He's Looking Into Law On Trans Patients On NHS Wards

4 March 2019, 10:16

The Health Secretary has told LBC he is reviewing the law on whether trans women can go on all-female wards in hospitals.

Matt Hancock was live in the LBC studio, answering questions from LBC listeners on topics around the NHS and social care.

Rachel in Bexley asked him: "Does the Health Secretary think that a trans female patient should be on an all-female ward, as was in the newspapers a few weeks ago when a man who was transitioning performed unsavoury sexual acts on some of the elderly female patients."

Nick Ferrari asked Mr Hancock: "Where should this woman have been in the ward?"

The Health Secretary responded: "This is a very very difficult question. The current rules of the NHS are that people are treated as they present.

"If somebody is a woman and has gone through the legal changes to be a woman, then they are treated as a woman. We have a very similar problem in prisons in terms of gender."

Nick queried if they had to have had the full procedure, to which Mr Hancock responded: "No, they have to have legally changed."

Nick then pointed out: "So they could still have a male appendage? And they'd be on a female ward. You can't accept that."

Mr Hancock responded: "You can see why I'm uncomfortable.

"I think this whole area needs looking at. We need to look at what the rules ought to be."

Nick Ferrari pressed Matt Hancock on where trans patients should be treated
Nick Ferrari pressed Matt Hancock on where trans patients should be treated. Picture: LBC

Nick put to him: "Well what should the rules be? That should not happen, surely.

"Someone who has a male appendage should not be on a female ward."

The Health Secretary paused before answering: "You can see where I'm coming from. I think that it's very very difficult.

"The current rules of the NHS, which were set some years ago. There's a lot of law in this space as well, meaning that we cannot just move without serious consideration.

"The problem is that is the current way the NHS organises itself. We are looking at it."

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

It's not fair

Nick Ferrari loses his patience with caller over ‘non-dom’ tax scheme

Caller Som has a warning from the past as the conflict between Israel and Iran escalates.

Caller Som has a warning from history as Israel and Iran conflict escalates

LBC callers react to Israel’s ‘risky’ strike on Iran

LBC callers react to Israel’s ‘risky’ strike on Iran

Caller in Israel warns against Iran becoming a nuclear-armed state

Caller in Israel warns against Iran becoming a nuclear-armed state

Caller points out that Israel denied entry to Labour MPs as UK comes under fire for new sanctions

Caller points out that Israel denied entry to Labour MPs as UK comes under fire for new sanctions

Caller Layla

Caller Layla fears for her daughters following Kemi Badenoch's Burqa comments

Caller Barry

LBC caller backs the government's reversal on the winter fuel allowence

Nick Ferrari is unsure about caller Bill's proposal to turn migrant hotels into prisons

Nick Ferrari is unsure about caller Bill's proposal to turn migrant hotels into prisons

Call the Cabinet: Nick Ferrari is joined by Environment Secretary Steve Reed to take your calls

Call the Cabinet: Nick Ferrari is joined by Environment Secretary Steve Reed to take your calls

LBC reaction: 1200 Channel migrants arrive in a single day

LBC reaction: 1200 Channel migrants arrive in a single day

Exclusive
'Elite mindset' and ‘left-wing opinion’ fuelling migrant crisis says Nick Ferrari as he slams government

'Elite mindset' and ‘left-wing opinion’ fuelling migrant crisis says Nick Ferrari as he slams the government

Reform, racism and ‘a perverse Batman’ | LBC’s best callers of the week

Reform, racism and ‘a perverse Batman’: LBC’s best callers of the week

'Farage is a media-made man'

David and Nick debate whether 'tiny and ridiculous' Reform gets too much airtime

Tube worker John

Tube worker shares his close encounters with fare dodgers

LBC callers react to Netanyahu calling out Starmer for being on the 'wrong side of humanity'

LBC callers react to Netanyahu calling out Starmer for being on the 'wrong side of humanity'

LBC callers react as the UK suspends trade talks with Israel

LBC callers react as the UK suspends trade talks with Israel