'Priti Patel's immigration plan won't stop people coming'

24 March 2021, 18:48

By Sam Sholli

Priti Patel's proposed changes to rules for asylum seekers "won't stop people coming" to the UK - it will just lead to "cruelty", said Professor Anna Rowlands.

Professor Anna Rowlands, who works with refugees, made the remark after the Home Secretary told LBC earlier that her planned shake-up of the asylum system will make deportations as "swift and efficient" as possible.

Professor Anna said, "The end effect will be cruelty.

"I suspect that whatever the intentions behind this three point plan that's just been announced...it will have the reverse effect of what she intends."

She continued, "This will not lead to a reduced number of people coming, it will lead to people who quickly find that they will feel they need to go underground and not be on the radar; they'll feel they're not safe in the context so will end up with more risk, more limbo and less safety.

"I think that's not in the interests of us as a nation and it certainly isn't in the interests of those people who desperately need sanctuary."

Professor Anna Rowlands also told LBC that the Home Secretary is "refusing to understand" the intention of asylum seekers, most of whom do not come to the UK for welfare.

"Most do not want to come to the UK, most of them want to stay within the context of their communities," she said, "what they're looking for is basic political protection and an opportunity to work and be self-supporting.

"One of the things get very wrong is a sense that refugees are interested in a dependency culture."

Separately, immigration lawyer Colin Yeo had similar pessimistic words for the Home Secretary's new scheme, questioning its practicalities.

Mr Yeo told LBC's Shelagh Fogarty: "What Priti Patel is proposing is for people, after they actually reach our shores [and] after we are obliged by the refugee convention to process their cases and give them rights, that we just remove them anyway to some other country.

"If you start to think about the practicalities of that...What country is going to take them?

"It's not going to be an EU country because we've just left the EU. We left the returns arrangement that we had with them as a member of the EU.

"And anyway they take a lot more refugees than we do already. So why would they take more from us?"

"It would have to be a country outside the EU...But if it's a very poor country that we persuade by giving them lots of money or something, [then] there's a danger of human rights abuses.

"The refugees would have to be detained there because if you don't detain them there [then] they'll just start making their way back here.

"And you could start to see that could go quite badly wrong quite quickly..."

The Home Office has said: "For the first time, whether people enter the UK legally or illegally will have an impact on how their asylum claim progresses, and on their status in the UK if that claim is successful.

"We will make every effort to remove those who enter the UK illegally having travelled through a safe country in which they could and should have claimed asylum."

READ MORE: Priti Patel: Half of disputed cases over migrants' ages were 'adults presenting as children'

More Shelagh Fogarty News

See more More Shelagh Fogarty News

Ex-prisoner: Raab 'absolutely right' on using prisoners to plug labour shortages

Ex-offender: Raab 'absolutely right' on using prisoners to plug labour shortages

Government 'all over the shop' on mask-wearing, says Shadow Health Secretary

Government 'all over the shop' on mask-wearing, says Shadow Health Secretary

'It's horrific déjà vu': Ex-nurse 'terrified' at lack of Covid restrictions as cases rise

Ex-NHS staff nurse 'terrified' and 'sad' as Covid cases rise

UK faces 8,000 Covid deaths before Christmas if govt don't act, epidemiologist warns

UK faces 8,000 Covid deaths before Christmas if govt don't act, epidemiologist warns

'It's unthinkable': Iain Dale reacts to Sir David Amess' murder

'It's unthinkable': Iain Dale reacts to Sir David Amess' death

Poorer areas could see 'even larger' council tax increases than projections, says IFS Director

Poorer areas could see 'even larger' council tax increases than projected, says IFS Director

Shelagh Fogarty condemns Javid's 'insulting' and 'leaden' social care comment

Shelagh Fogarty condemns Sajid Javid's 'insulting' and 'leaden' social care comment

'There has been a failing here': Met has 'very serious questions to answer', Safeguarding minister says

Met has 'very serious questions to answer' over Everard case, says minister

Exclusive
Caller defends eco-mob blocking woman visiting mother in hospital

Caller defends eco-mob blocking woman visiting mother in hospital

'We're looking at an institutional problem and talking about it like it's one bad apple'

'Utterly rotten' Met must be 'investigated' after Couzens' sentence, activist tells LBC

'When do we say this is enough?': Women's activist questions Cressida Dick's competence

'When do we say this is enough?': Women's activist questions Cressida Dick's competence

Hariett Harman tells LBC why she wants Cressida Dick to resign

Harriet Harman tells LBC why she wants Cressida Dick to resign

'We don't tolerate the Yorkshire ripper, but we tolerate lesser offences': Shelagh Fogarty condemns tolerance of male violence

'We tolerate lesser offending by men before they go on to murder girls and women'

'Hammer out a plan': Ashworth's message for Javid as key workers struggle for fuel

'Hammer out a plan': Ashworth's message for Javid as key workers struggle for fuel

UK 'subservient to US thinking' on Afghanistan withdrawal, says Defence Select Committee Chair

UK 'subservient to US thinking' on Afghanistan withdrawal, says Tobias Ellwood

'All we've done is replaced the Taliban with the Taliban': caller clashes with Shelagh Fogarty

'All we've done is replaced the Taliban with the Taliban': caller clashes with Shelagh Fogarty