Meta fact-checker cuts will allow spread of racist misinformation, MPs say

25 February 2025, 19:04

Social media stock
Social media stock. Picture: PA

The social media giant’s decision to replace third-party fact checkers with a user-generated community notes system has been heavily criticised.

Meta’s removal of third-party fact checkers from its platforms will allow “racist misinformation” to spread, MPs have warned.

The social media giant denied that it was ending fact-checking on its app, but was instead “moving to a system which is more scalable” following “feedback” from its users.

In January, Meta boss Mark Zuckerberg announced the change, saying at the time that fact-checkers were too “politically biased” and were having an impact on “free expression” – a move seen by many as an attempt to get closer to the pro-free speech stance of the incoming Donald Trump administration.

During an appearance before MPs on the Science, Innovation and Technology Select Committee, Chris Yiu, Meta’s director of public policy for northern Europe said the decision to replace third-party fact checkers with a community notes system in the US, and to reduce content moderation on some topics was based on feedback that debate on sensitive issues was being “suppressed”.

The committee noted that Meta had previously submitted evidence to it that third-party fact-checking was a key part of the firm’s approach to combating misinformation.

Mr Yiu was asked by MPs on the committee how this fitted with leaked guidelines for the changed content moderation approach and community notes system which showed the site would now allow a range of transphobic, racist and antisemitic statements, including statements such as: “trans people don’t exist”, “immigrants are filthy” and “Jews are greedier than Christians” – which were labelled “racist misinformation” by the committee.

In response, Mr Yiu said: “I accept that some of those are difficult for the communities that are affected to hear.

“We have received feedback over the months and years that in some cases, some areas of debate were being suppressed too much on our platform, and that some conversations, whilst challenging, should have a space to be discussed.

“We retain clear rules and community standards prohibiting content which is designed to incite violence.”

Responding to Mr Yiu, Emily Darlington MP asked whether Meta believed there was a “genuine debate” around the example statements on trans people, Jewish people and immigrants.

“We’ve had feedback that topics which have become part of mainstream discourse – conversations around some of the issues that happen among members of the public, that happen in newspapers, were being suppressed on our platforms in a way which was too aggressive,” Mr Yiu said.

“Where people make statements that violate our policies, they will be actioned equally. We’ve had the feedback that there are topics where the view was that there there should be more room for debate and conversation.”

Committee chair Chi Onwurah MP warned Meta that by allowing such statements to be appear on the platform, they were in fact “amplifying” such content.

“It’s not the same as a conversation in somebody’s home,” she said.

“This is something that people are going to see in their feeds.”

Chris Morris, chief executive of independent fact-checking charity Full Fact, said Meta was “dismantling” processes that lead users to “good information” online.

“Meta’s claim that it is not ending fact checking in the US isn’t credible and lacks context,” he said.

“Replacing experts trained to establish factual accuracy with a community notes model designed to reach consensus risks skewing information circulating on Meta platforms towards what some users think rather than what the evidence says.

“Community notes have a role to play in improving our online conversation, but is not the same as independent fact checking.”

Elsewhere during the session, where representatives from TikTok and Elon Musk’s X were also giving evidence, Ms Darlington clashed with X executive Wilfredo Fernandez over the firm’s content policies.

She read out a violent threat made to her in the replies to her own post on X, as well as a string of racist, antisemitic, homophobic and violent posts from the same account that were also posted to the platform.

“Is this acceptable under the guise of free speech on X these days?,” she asked Mr Fernandez.

The X executive said the comments were “abhorrent” and that he would ensure “our teams take a look”, but when pressed on whether the account in question would be removed he added that he “can’t make any assurances”.

“I can assure you that our teams will review under our terms of service, and I’m sorry that you had to experience that,” he said.

Mr Fernandez also refused to be drawn on whether the sharing of videos of Mr Musk’s recent gesture at a Donald Trump rally – widely interpreted as a Nazi salute – was appropriate and made X a safer platform.

“I think there’s a lot of discussion around that, and that’s why the platform allows for people to debate it and discuss it,” he said.

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

Headspace app

AI companion for mindfulness can help ‘bridge gaps’ in mental health care

Dublin

Use of Irish writers’ work for AI training has ‘profound implications’ – union

This artist's concept, released on September 11, 2023, shows what exoplanet K2-18 b could look like based on science data.

Is anybody out there? Scientists discover ‘strongest evidence’ so far of alien life

General views of the Scottish harbour of Mallaig.

Half of vessels in Scotland ‘invisible’ to marine tracking systems – study

Radiofrequency Directed Energy Weapon (RF DEW)

Invisible radio wave weapon downs ‘drone swarms’ in trial success

A person opening the Spotify app on their phone

‘All clear’: Spotify back up and running after service outage

The squid can grow up to 7m (23ft) in length and weigh up to 500kg (1,100lb), according to experts.

Colossal squid spotted in ocean for the first time as scientists stunned by elusive creature's discovery

Spotify has confirmed it has major issues

Is Spotify down? Music app suffers major outage as firm investigates issues

OpenAI logo

OpenAI is building a social network – reports

Anthropic Claude AI chatbot

Anthropic’s Claude AI can now search your Gmail inbox for you

Medical records report and stethoscope. Medical concept. Medical records report and stethoscope. Medical concept.

Half a million UK GP records to be accessed by Chinese researchers

The new WhatsApp chat feature

WhatsApp to message users about protecting themselves from scams

Leader of the House of Commons Lucy Powell leaves Downing Street in October 2024

Minister’s hacked X account promotes ‘House of Commons cryptocurrency’ scam

Trump

‘Severe strain’ on tech supply chains will cause more price rises in electronics

Close up of a pair of hands using and playing with a PS5 handset

Sony raises PlayStation 5 prices in UK and Europe

Facebook chief executive Mark Zuckerberg in Dublin

Meta faces landmark trial which could break up its tech empire