Ending use of WhatsApp is ‘clear admission’ Government was wrong, claim Tories

17 December 2024, 16:14

Finger poised above WhatsApp app on smartphone
Person holding smartphone with WhatsApp messaging app. Picture: PA

Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes announced the Scottish Government will stop using mobile messaging applications by the spring.

The Scottish Government has given a “clear admission” that its use of WhatsApp and deletion of messages during the pandemic was wrong, the Conservatives have said.

It comes after Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes announced the Government will end its use of WhatsApp and other non-official messaging applications by spring next year.

The Government was criticised when it emerged ministers and top civil servants deleted WhatsApp messages which had been requested by the UK Covid-19 Inquiry.

As a result of a review ordered by former first minister Humza Yousaf, the use of mobile messaging apps will come to an end.

On Tuesday, Ms Forbes told MSPs: “One of the key questions asked in the review was around the use of mobile messaging apps such as WhatsApp.

Kate Forbes speaking
Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes confirmed the move to Parliament on Tuesday (PA)

“The report provides a clear recommendation in this regard. We have taken the decision to end the use of mobile messaging applications across the Scottish Government. This will happen by spring 2025.

“Government business should happen on Government systems which are secure, searchable and allow the appropriate sharing of information, in line with our statutory duties.

“Scottish Government ministers and staff will not be permitted to use WhatsApp, or any other non-corporate communications channel, to conduct Government business.

“To give effect to this, non-corporate mobile messaging applications will, by spring, be removed from devices and our technical environment configured so that they cannot be used.”

She also said the Government will produce “very clear guidelines” on what is permitted to ensure staff follow the new rules.

The Tories complained that opposition MSPs were not given enough time to read the 94-page review written by Emma Martins as it was only published a few minutes before Ms Forbes’s statement.

Scottish Conservative Party conference 2023
Sandesh Gulhane suggested the ministerial code had been breached (Andrew Milligan/PA)

Tory MSP Dr Sandesh Gulhane suggested the ministerial code had been broken as the usual parliamentary protocols had been breached.

He said: “This statement is a clear admission by the Scottish Government that what they have been doing and what they did over the Covid pandemic was wrong.

“Not just the use but the pre-determined deletion of messages.

“(Former national clinical director) Jason Leitch said it was his pre-bedtime ritual to delete all WhatsApp messages and a senior civil servant reminded everyone that WhatsApp messages are FOI-able and to delete them.

“What were they hiding? We will never know.”

Ms Forbes said there will be “robust training” on the use of mobile messaging applications.

Labour’s Daniel Johnson echoed the Conservative complaints about the late publication of the report, saying it had been written in November.

In late 2023, lead counsel to the UK Covid-19 Inquiry Jamie Dawson KC said most of the messages sent within the Scottish Government had been deleted.

It later transpired a number of senior members of the Government, including John Swinney and Nicola Sturgeon, had deleted messages, though both stressed they did not relate to Government business.

Mr Leitch was also criticised for describing deleting WhatsApp messages as a “pre-bed ritual”, while another senior clinician warned colleagues that messages could be published under freedom of information legislation.

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

The icons for the smartphone apps DeepSeek and ChatGPT are seen on a mobile

Nations and tech firms to jostle for AI leadership at Paris summit

Nick Lees

Man who credits King over cancer diagnosis given pioneering robotic microsurgery

Ellen Roome with her 14-year-old son Jools Sweeney

Parents suing TikTok over children’s deaths ‘want answers’

The Apple logo in the window of an Apple store

Home Office orders Apple to let it access users’ encrypted files – report

Ellen Roome with her son Jools Sweeney

Bereaved families file US lawsuit against TikTok over access to children’s data

The OpenAI logo appears on a mobile phone in front of a computer screen with random binary data

OpenAI taking claims of data breach ‘seriously’

There are concerns over how technology is aiding the abuse of women (Alamy/PA)

Deepfake abuse crackdown a ‘really important blow in battle against misogyny’

The Football Manager 25 logo on a light purple background

Football Manager 25 cancelled after delays

Football Manager 25 has been cancelled after being hit by delays

Football Manager 25 cancelled after several delays

Carsten Jung, head of AI at the IPPR, warned that politics 'needs to catch up' with the implications of AI (PA)

AI could replace 70% of tasks in computer-based jobs, study says

General view of IMI headquarters at Lakeside, Birmingham Business Park, Birmingham.

Engineering group IMI latest UK firm to be hit by cyber attack

A person's hands on the keyboard of a laptop

PSNI exploring use of AI to analyse mobile phone evidence

A screenshot of the homepage of AI chatbot DeepSeek, showing a warning message about new users being unable to register for the app

DeepSeek reopens new user sign-ups despite ongoing security concerns

A Google logo on the screen of a mobile phone, in Londons

Google axes diversity hiring targets as it reviews DEI programmes

A person’s hand pressing keys of a laptop keyboard

UK to get new cyber attack severity rating system

People working at computers

Capital raised by tech start-ups under Government scheme doubles