Judge blocks Trump's attempt to roll back health care protections for transgender people

18 August 2020, 00:42

A judge has blocked Donald Trump's administration from enforcing a rollback in transgender healthcare rights
A judge has blocked Donald Trump's administration from enforcing a rollback in transgender healthcare rights. Picture: PA

By Kate Buck

A federal judge has blocked Donald Trump's administration from enforcing a new piece of legislation aimed at rolling back health care protections for transgender people.

The Trump administration tried roll back part of the Health Care Rights Law, a part of the Affordable Care Act which protects people from the trans community from being denied health care.

By claiming "religious freedom", the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) attempted to revise a rule back to “the government’s interpretation of sex discrimination according to the plain meaning of the word ‘sex’ as male or female and as determined by biology”.

The announcement was made on the anniversary of the Pulse Massacre, in which 49 people were shot and killed in a gay club in Florida.

But at the eleventh hour, just before the ruling was going to take effect on Tuesday, US District Court Judge Frederic Block in Brooklyn granted a preliminary injunction barring the administration from enforcing the regulation until the case can be heard in court and decided.

Donald Trump called the decision "horrible and politically charged"
Donald Trump called the decision "horrible and politically charged". Picture: PA

Judge Block indicated he thought the Trump administration's so-called transgender rule is invalid in light of the Supreme Court ruling in June on a case involving similar issues in the context of job discrimination.

"When the Supreme Court announces a major decision, it seems a sensible thing to pause and reflect on the decision's impact," Judge Block wrote in his order, suggesting the agency may want to reconsider. "

Since HHS has been unwilling to take that path voluntarily, the court now imposes it."

The HHS health care rule was seen as a signal to President Donald Trump's social and religious conservative supporters that the administration remained squarely behind them after the shock of the Supreme Court's 6-3 decision, written by Justice Neil Gorsuch, who was nominated by Mr Trump.

"An employer who fires an individual for being homosexual or transgender fires that person for traits or actions it would not have questioned in members of a different sex," Mr Gorsuch wrote.

"Sex plays a necessary and undisguisable role in the decision, exactly what (civil rights law) forbids."

In a tweet, Mr Trump called that "horrible & politically charged" and compared it to a shotgun blast in the faces of conservative Republicans.

The HHS rule sought to overturn Obama-era sex discrimination protections for transgender people in health care. Similar to the underlying issues in the job discrimination case before the Supreme Court, the health care rule rests on the idea that sex is determined by biology.

The Obama-era version relied on a broader understanding shaped by a person's inner sense of being male, female, neither or a combination.

The lawsuit against the Trump administration rule was brought by an advocacy group, the Human Rights Campaign, on behalf of two transgender women. One of the plaintiffs is an army veteran and the other a writer and activist.

Judge Block dismissed as "disingenuous" arguments from HHS that its rule was legally valid, and wrote that the agency acted "arbitrarily and capriciously" in enacting it.

HHS said it was disappointed by the judge's decision.

He was nominated to the federal bench by former president Bill Clinton.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

The Kering Foundation Hosts First-Ever Caring For Women Dinner

Emma Watson ‘stalker’ arrested after demanding to see Harry Potter star at Oxford fashion show

Passengers are facing delays across the country

Is your flight delayed? Airports and airlines issue updates after mass IT outage causes travel chaos around the world

Evan Gershkovich, a Wall Street Journal reporter, was detained last March on spying charges

American journalist jailed for 16 years in Russia after being convicted of espionage

People have been out enjoying the sunshine ahead of the weekend.

Hot hot hot! Temperatures soar to 31C today and 30C tomorrow after an uncomfortable tropical night tonight

Harehill descended into chaos yesterday evening

Starmer condemns ‘shocking and disgraceful’ disorder after riot sweeps through Leeds

Joe Biden and Barack Obama worked in office together between 2008 and 2016

Biden planning ‘major announcement’ about his future as Obama says he must ‘seriously consider stepping down’

Zara McDermott opened up about the "extremely distressing" events that occurred behind the scenes at Strictly Come Dancing.

Zara McDermott hits back after ex-Strictly pro Graziano Di Prima claims he only kicked her once

Lee Laudat-Scott is charged with touching a boy under 13.

Former Labour councillor Lee Laudat-Scott charged with sexual assault of a child

Graham Gomm

Urgent manhunt as prisoner escapes custody at HMP Wormwood Scrubs during trip to hospital

Dominic Reid and Prince Harry

Prince Harry's charity boss quits as head of Invictus Games days after duke sees backlash over veterans' award

CrowdStrike sign and logo at headquarters in Silicon Valley

What is CrowdStrike, the cybersecurity company ‘responsible’ for global IT failure? Microsoft outages explained

Keir Starmer welcomes Volodymyr Zelenskyy to Downing Street

Starmer greets Zelenskyy as Ukrainian President becomes first foreign leader to address UK cabinet since Bill Clinton

Roger Hallam was jailed for five years over M25 protests

‘Their protests are pathetic’: Armed forces minister slams Just Stop Oil as founder give five-year prison sentence

2024 Republican National Convention: Day 4

Hulk Hogan tears off shirt on stage at Republican national convention as he declares 'Trumpmania'

Clean up has begun following the riot in Leeds

Clean-up begins after riot sweeps through Leeds neighbourhood with bus set on fire and police car overturned

Live
The outage is being felt across the world

Global IT outage LIVE: CrowdStrike outage could be ‘biggest cyber incident in history’ as GP surgeries and banks hit