Supreme Court allows release of presidential documents in Capitol investigation

20 January 2022, 05:34

Donald Trump
Trump. Picture: PA

Donald Trump had asked that the diaries, logs and handwritten notes be withheld.

The US Supreme Court has allowed the release of presidential documents sought by the congressional committee investigating the Capitol insurrection.

The justices on Wednesday rejected a bid by former president Donald Trump to withhold the documents from the committee until the issue is finally resolved by the courts. Mr Trump’s lawyers had hoped to prolong the court fight and keep the documents on hold.

Following the court’s action, there is no legal impediment to turning over the documents, which are held by the National Archives and Records Administration. They include presidential diaries, visitor logs, speech drafts and handwritten notes dealing with January 6 from the files of former chief of staff Mark Meadows.

The January 6 riot
Supporters of the former president on January 6, 2021 (AP Photo/John Minchillo, File)

The committee has already begun to receive records Mr Trump wanted kept secret, said Bennie Thompson and Liz Cheney, the committee chairman and vice chairwoman respectively.

“The Supreme Court’s action tonight is a victory for the rule of law and American democracy,” Ms Thompson and Ms Cheney said in a statement pledging to “uncover all the facts about the violence of January 6th and its causes”.

White House spokesperson Mike Gwin called the ruling “an important step forward” for the investigation “and in ensuring accountability for an unprecedented assault on our democracy and the rule of law”.

The House committee agreed to defer its attempt to get some documents at the request of Joe Biden’s administration. The current administration was concerned that releasing all of Mr Trump’s administration documents sought by the committee could compromise national security and executive privilege.

Capitol Breach Police Intelligence
The riot is still being investigated more than a year on (AP Photo/Julio Cortez, File)

Alone among the justices, Clarence Thomas said he would have granted Mr Trump’s request to keep the documents on hold.

Mr Trump’s attorneys had asked the high court to reverse rulings by the federal appeals court in Washington and block the release of the records even after Mr Biden waived executive privilege over them.

In an unsigned opinion, the court acknowledged there are “serious and substantial concerns” over whether a former president can win a court order to prevent disclosure of certain records from his time in office in a situation like this one.

But the court noted that the appeals court determined that Mr Trump’s assertion of privilege over the documents would fail under any circumstances, “even if he were the incumbent”.

It said the issue of a former president’s ability to claim executive privilege would have to wait for another day.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Turkey’s Erdogan still against Finnish and Swedish Nato bids

A mountain range near Pokhara, Nepal

Plane with 22 on board missing in Nepal’s mountains

Pope Francis delivers a prayer from a window overlooking St Peter's Square

Pope names 21 new cardinals

Protesters clash with security forces in Khartoum

UN envoy decries Sudan violence after two killed in protests

Russia Ukraine War

Russian troops storm city amid eastern Ukraine bombardments

Meghan Markle is thought to have reached out to her estranged father

Meghan Markle 'has reached out to father' days after he suffered stroke and lost speech

Young Jewish people wave Israeli flags near the Western Wall in Jerusalem

Visit to holy site by far-right Israeli politician sparks Jerusalem unrest

Shoppers in a reopened mall in Beijing

Beijing and Shanghai ease Covid restrictions as outbreaks fade

Presidential candidate Gustavo Petro

Colombians to vote for president amid widespread discontent

Rescuers look out of the windows of a helicopter

25 missing after cargo boat sinks in Indonesia

Nigeria Church Stampede

31 dead in church fair stampede in Nigeria

Russia Ukraine War

Russia takes small cities as it aims to widen battle in east Ukraine

Iran accused of piracy for seizing two Greek oil tankers

Fears oil price will rise again after Iran accused of piracy for seizing Greek oil tankers

Building Collapse-Florida

Judge in US gives initial OK to a billion-dollar deal in Florida condo collapse

Cardinal Angelo Sodano

Powerful Vatican prelate Cardinal Angelo Sodano dies aged 94

Donald Trump

Senior Republicans’ claims at NRA rally called into question