How a divided Senate will affect Joe Biden’s programme for government

18 January 2021, 13:04

The US Capitol (Julio Cortez/AP)
Capitol Breach. Picture: PA

Following runoff wins in Georgia, the upper house is balanced at 50-50.

Just before a mob ransacked the US Capitol, two Georgia runoff wins for the Democrats ensured a 50-50 balance in the US Senate.

The unexpected new balance of power giving Democrats only the barest control of Congress has big consequences for President-elect Joe Biden, easy confirmation of his Cabinet most importantly, but the road ahead for his ambitious legislative agenda remains complicated and murky.

Republicans remain poised to block most of Mr Biden’s proposals, just as they thwarted much of President Barack Obama’s efforts on Capitol Hill.

But 50/50 control permits action on special legislation that cannot be filibustered, and momentum for the popular parts of Covid-19 relief could easily propel an early aid bill into law.

– What does Joe Biden get from a 50-50 Senate?

– Nominations

With Democrats chairing committees in the Senate and only needing a majority to win floor votes on nominations, Mr Biden is now assured of sealing confirmation of his Cabinet and judicial picks — including potentially for the Supreme Court.

It also means controversial choices such as Neera Tanden, Mr Biden’s pick for budget director, can look ahead to assuming their posts.

Republicans can slow but not stop nominations.

– Budget ‘reconciliation’

Democrats also have the opportunity to pass special budget-related legislation by a simple majority, an often-arcane process that enabled Barack Obama to finish his 2010 health care bill and gave President Donald Trump’s Republican allies a failed chance to repeal “Obamacare” and passage of a tax overhaul bill.

Mr Biden could use this so-called budget reconciliation process to pass more controversial elements of Covid-19 relief with only Democratic votes, repeal some of Mr Trump’s tax cuts or make federal health care programmes more generous, for example.

– Setting the agenda

Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer, he will be majority leader once the two new Georgia senators and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris are all sworn into office — now has the opportunity to bring legislation to the floor and force votes.

That could permit passage of 2,000 US dollars direct Covid-19 relief payments and other aid, for instance, and could mean debates on issues like police reform, immigration and climate change.

Vice President-elect Kamala Harris (Matt Slocum/AP)
Vice President-elect Kamala Harris (Matt Slocum/AP)

But passage of such legislation would require support from Republicans, which gives the minority party enormous leverage.

– What Joe Biden does not get?

– Elimination of the filibuster

Before the November election, pressure had been mounting from the Democratic left to eliminate the filibuster, leading Republicans to charge that Democrats would pack the Supreme Court or give statehood to Democratic strongholds such as the District of Columbia.

Moderate Democrat Joe Manchin of West Virginia says he willl block any attempt to eliminate the filibuster, so party progressives may be wasting their breath on this topic now.

– Bipartisanship

Unified control of the government by one party almost invariably drives the two sides apart.

Recent events — hard-won passage of a 900 billion US dollar Covid-19 relief bill and a sweeping override of Mr Trump’s veto of the annual defence bill — have been evidence that the vanishing congressional middle can help drive outcomes on Capitol Hill.

But issues like increasing the debt limit instantly become partisan, and the political incentives for many Republicans heading into the 2022 midterms and the 2024 presidential election are to vilify Mr Biden and Democrats controlling Congress.

Expect a short honeymoon for Mr Biden.

– Progressive messaging priorities

A 50-50 Democratic Senate and bare control of the House grant virtually any individual Democrat the ability to gum up the works.

That means impossible-to-pass ideas like Medicare For All and a Green New Deal are not going to be the focus of Mr Schumer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi.

Incoming US Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer (Mary Altaffer/AP)
Incoming US Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer (Mary Altaffer/AP)

That could, over time, frustrate liberals and cause them to issue demands related to bills that actually can pass like infrastructure spending and budget reconciliation proposals.

By Press Association