Two British judges resign from Hong Kong’s top court

7 June 2024, 08:14

Police standing before a prison bus
Hong Kong Security Law Verdict. Picture: PA

Jonathan Sumption and Lawrence Collins both served as non-permanent overseas judges of Hong Kong’s Court of Final Appeal

Two British judges have resigned from Hong Kong’s top court, the city’s judiciary said, deepening worries over the city’s rule of law under Beijing-imposed national security measures.

The judiciary said that Jonathan Sumption and Lawrence Collins, who both serve as non-permanent overseas judges of Hong Kong’s Court of Final Appeal, have tendered their resignations to the city leader. But it did not give further details about their decisions.

Judge Collins told The Associated Press that his resignation was “because of the political situation in Hong Kong”.

But he said he continues “to have the fullest confidence in the court and the total independence of its members”.

Judge Sumption said he would make a statement next week.

Hong Kong’s Chief Justice Andrew Cheung noted their decisions with regret in a statement, reiterating the judiciary’s commitment to upholding the rule of law and judicial independence in the city.

Hong Kong, a former British colony, is a common law jurisdiction, unlike mainland China. After it returned to Chinese rule in 1997, non-permanent overseas judges have consistently served on the city’s top court.

Police officers stand in front of a prison bus
Last week, 14 pro-democracy activists were convicted in Hong Kong’s biggest national security case under a law imposed by Beijing that has all but wiped out public dissent (AP)

The pair’s resignations are an indicator of confidence in the city’s rule of law and judicial independence, especially after the enactment of the 2020 national security law that has all but wiped out public dissent.

Many pro-democracy activists have been arrested under the law, including some of the city’s best-known democracy advocates.

Last week, a Hong Kong court found 14 pro-democracy activists guilty of conspiring to commit subversion in what was the city’s biggest national security case to date.

They were among 47 activists who were accused of attempting to paralyse Hong Kong’s government and topple the city’s leader by securing the legislative majority necessary to indiscriminately veto budgets.

Critics said the convictions showed how the sweeping security law is being used against dissidents in the city. But Beijing and Hong Kong’s governments insisted the law helped bring back stability to the city following huge anti-government protests in 2019.

Hong Kong officials have repeatedly insisted the city’s judicial independence is being protected.

In March, the Hong Kong government enacted a new, home-grown security law, raising more concerns over the city’s erosion of freedoms.

Hong Kong’s leader John Lee expressed regrets over the judges’ resignations in a statement. Mr Lee maintained the human rights and freedoms guaranteed by the law have not changed, nor has the territory’s judicial independence.

The city’s bar association said it strongly believes that their departure would not affect the ability of the apex court in discharging its judicial functions, adding it has “every confidence” in the independence of the city’s judicial system.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Biden Netanyahu

Netanyahu meets with Biden and Harris at crucial moment for the US and Israel

Israeli supporters during the Men's match between Mali and Israel during the Olympic Games Paris 2024 at Parc des Princes

Israel alleges Iran-backed plot to target athletes at Paris Olympics and equips delegation with armed security detail

Canada Wildfires

Wildfire in Canadian Rockies’ largest national park ravages town of Jasper

Vice president Kamala Harris (Tony Gutierrez/AP)

Bring it on – Kamala Harris says she is ready to fight for country’s future

The Starliner spacecraft docked to the Harmony module of the International Space Station (Nasa via AP)

Nasa says no return date yet for astronauts and Boeing capsule at space station

California governor Gavin Newsom (Steven Senne/AP)

Governor issues executive order for removal of California homeless encampments

A mourner pays his respects a memorial at Robb Elementary School (Eric Gay/AP)

Uvalde school police officer pleads not guilty to charges over 2022 shooting

Firefighters evacuating residents during floods in Pintung county, Taiwan

Typhoon Gaemi hits China after leaving 25 dead in Taiwan and Philippines

Iryna Farion

Teenage suspect held over assassination of Ukrainian language advocate

Meta logo

Meta panel says deepfake policies need update amid controversy over nude images

Queen Mary

Queen Mary mowed down by electric scooter during Royal meet and greet with fans in Greenland

Philippine-flagged motor tanker Terra Nova sinks in Manila Bay

Oil tanker sinks in Manila Bay, raising concerns about possible major spill

US Israel Netanyahu

Netanyahu to meet Biden and Harris at crucial moment for US and Israel

Emergency vehicles and police cars parked on a runway

More than 100 flights axed in Germany as activists target airports across Europe

A white building in Nepal

UN cultural agency opts not to put Buddha’s birthplace on endangered list

Bashar Assad shakes hands with Vladimir Putin

Russian President Vladimir Putin meets Syrian leader Bashar Assad at the Kremlin