Trump cannot prevent release of tax returns, US judge rules

7 October 2019, 17:57

A US judge rejected Trump's challenge to the release of his tax returns
A US judge rejected Trump's challenge to the release of his tax returns. Picture: PA
Nick Hardinges

By Nick Hardinges

A US federal judge has rejected Donald Trump's claim that a sitting president is not "subject to the criminal process" saying it defies the US constitution.

President Trump challenged a subpoena demanding the release of his tax returns arguing he was immune from criminal investigations.

US federal judge Victor Morrero dismissed the president's legal claim, saying he cannot endorse such a "categorical and limitless assertion of presidential immunity from judicial process".

Trump's lawyers argued against New York District Attorney Cyrus Vance, stating "'virtually all legal commenters agree' that a sitting President of the United States is not 'subject to the criminal process' while he is in office."

However, Marrero described Mr Trump's attempts to invoke presidential immunity as "unqualified and boundless".

The second US Circuit Court of Appeals temporarily blocked the handover of the documents "pending expedited review".

Mr Vance requested Trump's accounting firm turn over eight years' worth of tax returns
Mr Vance requested Trump's accounting firm turn over eight years' worth of tax returns. Picture: PA

Mr Vance requested the president's accounting firm turn over eight years' worth of business and personal tax returns.

This demand formed part of an investigation into the payment of hush money towards two women who claimed to have had affairs with the US leader.

The president's legal team argued that requests for his tax records should be halted because a sitting president should be immune from a criminal investigation and suggested the case was politically motivated.

Donald Trump took to Twitter: "The Radical Left Democrats have failed on all fronts, so now they are pushing local New York City and State Democrat prosecutors to go get President Trump.

"A thing like this has never happened to any President before. Not even close!"

However, Judge Marrero stated Mr Trump's claim was "extraordinary" and an "overreach of executive power".

"As the court reads it, presidential immunity would stretch to cover every phase of criminal proceedings, including investigations, grand jury proceedings and subpoenas, indictment, prosecution, arrest, trial, conviction, and incarceration," he wrote.

"That constitutional protection presumably would encompass any conduct, at any time, in any forum, whether federal or state, and whether the president acted alone or in concert with other individuals."

Justice Department lawyers in Washington, who had urged Judge Marrero to delay deciding the issue, declined to comment.

The probe began after prosecutors in Manhattan completed their investigation into hush money payments that Mr Trump's former personal lawyer, Michael Cohen, arranged to be paid to porn actress Stormy Daniels and model Karen McDougal to keep them silent during the 2016 presidential race.

Mr Cohen was reimbursed by the Trump Organisation at a later date but is serving a three-year prison sentence for crimes including campaign finance violations.

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Corey Comperatore was killed during the Trump rally attack.

Pictured: Man killed in shooting at Trump rally as he 'tried to shield family from bullets'

Donald Trump has been shot through the ear at a rally in Pennsylvania - as one bystander was killed and two others were critically injured.

Pictured: Shocking scenes as gunman shoots Donald Trump during rally leaving one bystander dead

At least 71 Palestinians have been killed in an Israeli air strike

‘Dozens killed in air strike on Gaza humanitarian zone’ as Israel says it was targeting Hamas leaders

Tony Blair was among a star-studded guest list at the wedding of the son of India's richest man

Tony Blair, Boris Johnson and wrestling star John Cena among guests at lavish wedding of Asia's richest man

Tori Towey has spoken out after being freed

Air stewardess breaks silence after being freed from arrest for 'attempted suicide' in Dubai following home attack

Simon Harris confirmed that Tori Towey has been released

Air stewardess freed after being 'detained for attempted suicide' in Dubai following 'attack at home'

Carla Bruni-Sarkozy faces witness tampering charges in her husband's illegal campaign finance case

Carla Bruni faces witness tampering charge over ex-French president husband Nicolas Sarkozy's corruption case

Tori Towey is stuck in Dubai

Air stewardess 'trapped in Dubai and charged with attempted suicide' after being 'attacked at home'

Joe Biden confirmed NATO will send “dozens” of air defence systems to Ukraine

Biden declares Ukraine 'can and will' stop Putin as he confirms NATO will send 'dozens' of air defence systems to Kyiv

Sir Keir Starmer will kick back a key decision on when Britain will spend more cash on defence

Keir Starmer to kick back defence spending decision at NATO summit in first foreign visit as Prime Minister

Sir Keir Starmer and Lady Starmer head for Washington for Nato summit

Starmer heads to Washington for historic Nato summit after making first Parliamentary speech as Prime Minister

Tourists in Spain have started reserving the best beach spots by hanging their towels on parasols

'New dimension' in battle for sunbeds in Majorca resorts as tourists drape towels over beach umbrellas for best shoreline spots

Yulia Navalnaya, widow of Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny

Moscow court orders arrest of Alexei Navalny's widow Yulia Navalnaya months after his death

The plane mechanic was killed after getting sucked into a jet engine

Plane mechanic killed after being sucked into Boeing jet engine as he went to retrieve tool

Spanish council clears up murky 'peeing in the sea' rule that threatened to hit tourists with hefty €750 fine

Spanish council clears up murky 'peeing in the sea' rule that threatened to hit tourists with hefty €750 fine

Exclusive
'They tried to kill children': Doctor speaks of horror as death toll rises to 41 following Ukraine hospital attack

'They tried to kill children': Doctor speaks of horror as death toll rises to 41 following Ukraine hospital attack