Incels using TikTok to spread ‘hateful beliefs’, research suggests

12 October 2023, 11:04

TikTok fined
TikTok fined. Picture: PA

A study found that incel ideology is being spread in a manner of ways including through the use of pseudo-scientific appeals.

Social media platform TikTok is being used by incels to spread their “hateful beliefs” against women, according to a new study.

Previous research has suggested that incels – men who are involuntary celibates – were mainly restricted to niche men’s forums.

But researchers from the University of Portsmouth have found “prominent” incel accounts on video-sharing site TikTok.

Incels have been linked to violent attacks including the shooting by Jake Davison of five people in Plymouth in 2021 and an attack in Toronto, Canada, in which self-described incel Alek Minassian drove a van into a crowd killing 11 people in 2018.

Lead author Anda Solea, of the School of Criminology and Criminal Justice Studies at the University of Portsmouth, said: “It is a common belief that incels are an underground community, removed from beloved and popular platforms such as TikTok.

“Our study demonstrates that incel ideology is also present, popularised and thriving on TikTok.”

The study found that incel ideology was being spread in a manner of styles including through the use of pseudo-scientific appeals.

These use fake and misinterpreted graphs, surveys and information often based on evolutionary psychology and biological determinism to “expose the supposed true nature of women”.

Other methods include emotional appeals which employ repurposed viral internet media, including TV clips and memes, depicting unattractive men’s humiliation and suffering at the hands of women to portray men as victims and evoke empathy.

The study suggests that the language used is soft and implicit enough to escape content moderation but harmful enough to “perpetuate hateful beliefs” while linking with broader sexism and structural misogyny.

Study co-author Dr Lisa Sugiura, associate professor in cybercrime and gender at the University of Portsmouth, said: “These clever subtle approaches aim to resonate with broader audiences, including those who might be unfamiliar with the intricacies of incel ideology.

“They present a challenge to policymakers and a real danger to women. As TikTok gains popularity, more needs to be done to understand the growing incel activity on the platform.”

Ms Solea said: “Incels consider themselves unable to attain romantic relationships due to societal hierarchies based on looks, money and status, where women wield power.

“They have been linked to gendered hate speech and violence against women, making them an increasing security concern.

“However, research has often oversimplified incels, overlooking their diversity across different online platforms.

“Mainstream platforms like TikTok have stricter moderation policies but are not immune to incel influence.

“This study aims to understand how incels adapt their ideology to mainstream platforms and how they influence and are influenced by mainstream discourse.”

TikTok has been approached for comment.

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

A person using a laptop

Nations agree to develop shared risk thresholds for AI as Seoul summit closes

Microsoft new equiment

Data regulator looking into Microsoft’s AI Recall feature

An easyJet plane

EasyJet uses AI to better manage flights from new control centre

Handout image from Microsoft of its Copilot virtual assistant displayed on a laptop screen

Microsoft expanding Copilot AI assistant to organise meetings and support teams

Cabinet meeting

AI safety summits could help shape UK legislation, Technology Secretary says

Someone at a laptop

Safety institutes to form ‘international network’ to boost AI research and tests

Soldiers' boots

Army personnel feel ‘let down’ after MoD cyber attack

Person uses laptop

Global AI tech companies agree to set of safety outcomes in ‘world first’

AI safety summit

World leaders need to ‘get serious’ about AI, experts warn as summit opens

76th Cannes Film Festival

Scarlett Johansson: ChatGPT voice sounds ‘eerily similar’ to mine

UK’s economy

UK workers with AI skills get 14% wage premium, research suggests

Social media apps

Tech firms falling short on misinformation ahead of general election – committee

Microsoft chief executive Satya Nadella speaks at a press event where the company announced its new AI-powered PCs

Microsoft makes its AI pitch with Copilot+ PCs

OpenAI logo seen on a mobile phone in front of a computer screen

ChatGPT to ‘pause’ use of voice following Scarlett Johansson comparison

A self-driving Nissan car

Self-driving cars on roads ‘as soon as 2026’ as Bill becomes law

Dr Craig Wright arriving at the Rolls Building in London during the trial earlier this year (Lucy North/PA)

Computer scientist ‘lied extensively’ in Bitcoin founder claim, judge rules