Facebook staff ‘kicked out’ of meetings early on, says member of oversight board

2 March 2021, 17:54

Alan Rusbridger
Facebook staff were ‘kicked out’ of oversight board meetings early on. Picture: PA

Former Guardian editor-in-chief Alan Rusbridger, a member of Facebook’s oversight board, told the Lords he feels ‘highly independent’.

A member of Facebook’s oversight board has defended the group’s independence, saying it is not there to “please” the social network and had kicked out executives who tried to attend meetings.

Alan Rusbridger, former editor-in-chief of The Guardian, is one of 20 members recruited by the tech giant to make “binding decisions” about content removal decisions and the upholding of policies, with the power to overrule bosses, including chief executive Mark Zuckerberg.

Speaking to the House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee on Tuesday, Mr Rusbridger said scuppering the firm’s economic model is “not our problem”.

“We’re not there to please Facebook,” he said.

Facebook
Facebook’s oversight board started taking cases at the end of 2020, to investigate decisions made on posts that brush against the firm’s rules (Dominic Lipinski/PA)

“If you wanted to please Facebook, I think you’d have chosen a different group of people, and in my experience of my colleagues so far, they’re quite bolshy, they don’t want to have anything to do with Facebook, they turf Facebook out of our meetings when we realise there are some people sitting there, and so we don’t feel we work for Facebook at all and so I don’t think there’s any obligation either to be nice to Facebook or be horrible to Facebook.

“Occasionally people will say, ‘But if we did that, that would scupper Facebook’s economic model in such and such a country’, to which we answer, ‘Well that’s not our problem’, which is a very liberating thing.”

Mr Rusbridger said he has not met any Facebook executive since the group was started last year, including Mr Zuckerberg himself, but a couple of staff members did attempt to stay on calls between the oversight board early on.

“We got to the point where the training had ended and, you know, much on a Zoom screen like this, you saw there was still one or two Facebook people with their names there and one or two of us said, you know, ‘Hold on a minute, what are they still doing here?’,” he said.

“So once the training had ended, and the induction ended, we kicked them out and we haven’t seen them since.”

Discussing the board’s work so far, Mr Rusbridger said he believes the best way to tackle bad speech is to counter it with good speech, otherwise it will “go underground”.

In one case about a post praising hydroxychloroquine as a treatment for Covid-19, the board decided Facebook was wrong to remove it from the platform.

“Facebook banned that because they said that that’s a sort of crank solution and we don’t believe in misinformation, but if you looked at it, really, it was addressed really to the French regulation agency and saying it was trying to influence them to be more receptive to this,” he told the committee.

“I’m very worried by banning that kind of speech because where does it then go? It’ll go underground, it’ll go into encrypted channels and I’m afraid, I’m an old John Stuart Millite, you know, I think actually the way to tackle bad speech is to produce good speech and you’re not really solving anything by pushing it underground.

“I have some sympathies with Facebook because a blanket ban on Covid misinformation would be an easier thing for moderators and machines to understand.”

Mr Rusbridger also suggested it is likely the oversight board will ask to see Facebook’s algorithms at some point.

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

An eldery man getting into an Uber vehicle

Uber rolls out ‘senior accounts’ in UK to help elderly people travel

A blurred laptop screen

Ofcom boss: Tech firms not given much power over how to protect children online

European Space Agency astronaut Tim Peake (PA)

No limit to ChatGPT searches ‘remarkable’ given environmental impact – Tim Peake

CityFibre Broadband van

Openreach challenger CityFibre secures £2.3bn financing deal

The Grok X AI logo is displayed on a mobile phone with Grok seen in the background

Elon Musk's chatbot that praised Hitler was 'trained to use his personal beliefs'

Top view of the Milky Way galaxy showing the estimated orbits of both our Sun and the 3I/ATLAS comet

Mysterious space object may be oldest comet ever discovered, scientists say

Children with multiple long-term health issues undergo severe emotional stress at the same time as they are trying to cope with the physical challenges of their conditions, a study has found (Dominic

Children’s social media activity ‘highlights stress of living with health issue’

Scientists at Sheffield Hallam university have developed a new technique which they describe as a "powerful double weapon" to prevent cancer patients losing their hair during chemotherapy.

New technique hailed as ‘powerful double weapon’ against chemotherapy hair loss

Elon Musk

Elon Musk says his new AI model ‘better than PhD level in everything’

President of France Emmanuel Macron with Sir Keir Starmer

UK and France agree ‘Entente Technologique’ to help protect infrastructure

SHANGHAI, CHINA - JUNE 18, 2025 - The Nvidia logo displayed on a smartphone in Shanghai, China on June 18, 2025. (Photo by CFOTO/Sipa USA)

Nvidia becomes world’s most valuable listed company at $4trn

Surgical Robot

Robot performs realistic surgery ‘with 100% accuracy’

Peter Kyle outside the BBC smiling

Government makes deal with Google to provide free tech for UK public services

Former Wimbledon line judge Pauline Eyre

Wimbledon technology change ‘has turned officials into glorified butlers’

The Grok X AI logo is displayed on a mobile phone with Grok seen in the background

Elon Musk's Grok chatbot forced to delete a slew of posts after praising Adolf Hitler

Linda Yaccarino, chief executive officer (CEO) of X Corp. attends the ceremony for the signing of S.146, The TAKE IT DOWN Act at the White House in Washington, DC.

X CEO quits just two years after she was hired by Elon Musk