Privacy campaigners call on Government to end war on encryption

8 February 2022, 00:04

A woman using a smartphone
Impersonation scams. Picture: PA

An open letter from campaigners has criticised a recent Government advertising campaign attacking end-to-end encryption.

A group of civil society organisations and privacy campaigners have accused the Government of using “scare tactics” to try to sway public opinion over the use of end-to-end encryption in messaging apps.

Writing an open letter to mark Safer Internet Day, the Open Rights Group and more than 40 other campaign groups criticised a recent Home Office advertising campaign which claimed that encryption puts children at risk from predators and can be used to hide online abuse.

The civil society groups said they are concerned that the Government is seeking to influence public opinion prior to amending the draft Online Safety Bill so that tech firms would be forced to weaken or remove end-to-end encryption from their messaging systems, something the groups argue would in fact put more people at risk.

Jim Killock, from the Open Rights Group, said: “The way the Government has been using scare tactics damages trust with its citizens.

“The Government exploiting emotive narratives for their campaign is manipulative and does not provide a balanced view. The truth is that encryption is vital for online safety.”

The open letter, which has been signed by a number of experts as well as members of the Global Encryption Coalition including Index on Censorship, the Internet Society and human rights group Article 19, said damaging encryption would reduce privacy for the wider public, as well as vital protections for the most vulnerable.

“Undermining encryption would make our private communications unsafe, allowing hostile strangers and governments to intercept conversations,” the letter said.

“Undermining encryption would put at risk the safety of those who need it most.

“Survivors of abuse or domestic violence, including children, need secure and confidential communications to speak to loved ones and access the information and support they need.”

Popular apps such as Facebook-owned WhatsApp and Signal use end-to-end encryption to offer secure, private messaging for users.

Facebook has announced plans to introduce end-to-end encryption – so messages can only be accessed and read by the sender and recipient – across the rest of its app messaging platforms by 2023.

The tech giant has said it is taking the time until then to “get this right” and strike a balance between user privacy and keeping people safe online.

The Home Office and some law enforcement agencies have suggested that encryption can hamper efforts to stop criminals from organising and communicating.

Home Secretary Priti Patel has previously spoken out about her concerns around encryption, saying it could put progress in preventing child sexual abuse “at jeopardy”.

And last year, Metropolitan Police Commissioner Dame Cressida Dick called for greater international co-operation among law enforcement bodies and governments to engage tech companies on the issue.

In response to the open letter, Security Minister Damian Hinds said: “Privacy and children’s safety are not an either/or – we need both.

“End-to-end encryption can be an important and beneficial technology when used responsibly, and the Government supports this.

“We believe it can be implemented in a way that is consistent with protecting children, and that’s what we want to see.”

Rob Jones, director general at the National Crime Agency (NCA), also said it was important to find a balance between privacy and safety.

“Strong encryption protects users privacy and can provide many benefits, but any move to E2EE also needs to include measures which maintain the ability to protect children and identify images of abuse,” he said.

“A jump to E2ee without this capability risks turning the lights out for law enforcement worldwide.”

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

A battery changing station of Nio brand electrical car (Alamy)

Two dead after Nio electric car they were testing ‘falls from building’

Alexa to expand

Amazon’s Alexa could mimic the voices of dead relatives

Ai-Da at work

Robot painting Glastonbury’s famous faces says festival atmosphere is ‘electric’

Instagram's new age verification tools, which have started being testing in the US

Instagram begins testing new age verification tools

A security surveillance camera is seen near the Microsoft office building in Beijing

Microsoft: Russian cyber spying targets 42 Ukraine allies

Social media apps on a smartphone

Meta removes ‘large numbers’ of upskirting images found on Facebook

Rio Ferdinand poses for photographs with children at 10 Downing Street to celebrate the launch of the Diana Award’s annual anti-bullying campaign Don’t Face It Alone (Stefan Rousseau/PA)

Rio Ferdinand calls for new ‘inspiring’ online platform to combat child bullying

A screenshot of the Microsoft Outlook email service

Microsoft’s Outlook email service hit by outage

Elon Musk

Elon Musk’s proposed £35.8bn Twitter deal gets board endorsement

Apple unveils new products

Guide Dogs launches scheme to provide free iPads to children with sight loss

A woman using a laptop

Cloudflare outage knocks hundreds of websites offline

A Wifi-enabled robotic rooster has been placed on the Glastonbury Festival site to remind attendees when headline acts are about to start on the Pyramid Stage

Robotic rooster will remind Glastonbury-goers of headline set start times

Laptop user

Work on AI algorithm could help create safe spaces from online abuse

Jessie Ware

Jessie Ware wants wearable tech for deaf fans in all live music venues

A drone

Council to trial drone deliveries for school lunches

3 Ai-Da Robot with Billie Eilish

Robot artist Ai-Da paints Glastonbury headliners ahead of festival attendance