AI can create Caucasian faces that look more real than actual humans – study

14 November 2023, 12:04

Faces judged most often as (a) human and (b) AI.
images_large_10.1177_09567976231207095-fig3. Picture: PA

The same was not true for images of people of colour.

Artificial intelligence (AI) can generate Caucasian faces that seem more realistic than actual human faces, according to a new study.

As per the research, published in Psychological Science and led by experts at the Australian National University (ANU), more people thought the AI-generated white faces were human than the faces of real people.

The study found, however, that the same did not apply to faces generated of people of colour.

According to senior author of the paper, Dr Amy Dawel, the reason for the notable difference between generated Caucasian faces and people of colour comes down to the fact that AI algorithms are trained disproportionately on white faces.

Dr Dawel said: “If white AI faces are consistently perceived as more realistic, this technology could have profound implications for people of colour by ultimately reinforcing racial biases online.

“This problem is already apparent in current AI technologies used to create professional-looking headshots.

“When used for people of colour, the AI is altering their skin and eye colour to those of white people.”

Researchers found when it comes to AI “hyper-realism”, most people did not realise they were being fooled.

Study co-author and ANU PhD candidate Elizabeth Miller said researchers found that most of the study participants who were most confident that their answers were correct paradoxically thought that the AI faces were real.

She said: “This means people who are mistaking AI imposters for real people don’t know they are being tricked.”

The researchers were also able to discover why AI faces are fooling people.

Although there were still physical differences between the AI and human faces, study participants still managed to misinterpret them.

Dr Dawel revealed more in-proportion faces were typical signs that AI had generated a face.

However, people mistook it as a sign of humanness.

She added: “We can’t rely on these physical cues for long. AI technology is advancing so quickly that the differences between AI and human faces will probably disappear soon.”

She said this could have profound implications regarding online misinformation and identity theft.

Dr Dawel urged public transparency around AI so society can identify issues with the technology before they become more significant problems.

“Given that humans can no longer detect AI faces, society needs tools that can accurately identify AI imposters,” she said.

“Educating people about the perceived realism of AI faces could help make the public appropriately sceptical about the images they’re seeing online.”

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

Online Fraud Charter

Top tech firms sign new Government Charter to crack down on online fraud

Microsoft offices

Microsoft to invest £2.5bn in UK to boost AI plans

Musk accused companies like Apple and Disney of engaging in the ad boycott and trying to blackmail him.

Elon Musk launches expletive rant at advertisers who boycotted his social media platform X

Technology stock

Apple names its App Store apps of the year


Generative AI ‘helping criminals create more sophisticated cyber attacks’

Someone using a mobile phone

Virgin Media O2 expands national databank scheme for Christmas

Social media apps on a smartphone

Too much social media linked to harmful behaviours in teenagers, study suggests

Bank accounts

New data powers ‘could allow DWP to snoop on pensioners’ bank accounts’

AI image generators

Teach children about using AI at secondary school, IT professionals say

Child with a laptop

Social media sites failing to stop the spread of suicide content, charity says

Technology Stock

Public warnings about AI misinformation needed before election, peers told

Smartphone with Adobe logo on the screen

£16bn Adobe takeover could harm competition in digital design market – watchdog

Person using a laptop

No ‘smoking gun’ linking mental health harm and the internet – study

ChatGPT website

Young people the biggest users of generative AI, Ofcom study shows

Glenn Weinstein

Software firm Cloudsmith announces £8.8m investment

Online abuse AI algorithm

AI image generators ‘being used by children to create indecent images’