Error ridden Lucy Letby door-swipe data was used in cases of eight other babies

11 October 2024, 10:56 | Updated: 11 October 2024, 10:58

Error ridden Lucy Letby door-swipe data was used in cases of eight other babies
Error ridden Lucy Letby door-swipe data was used in cases of eight other babies. Picture: Alamy

By Danielle de Wolfe

Door-swipe evidence used to convict killer nurse Lucy Letby - and was later re-assessed by police after errors were discovered - was used in the cases of eight other babies, it has been revealed.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The swipe evidence, which mixed up when nurses were present on Letby's neonatal ward at the Countess of Chester Hospital, was used by prosecutors during the trial.

However, the data was later reviewed by police after concerns were raised as to its accuracy, with the incorrect swipe data used in relation to eight other babies.

The news follows comments made by Lady Justice Thirlwall, chairwoman of the Thirlwall inquiry, who previously dismissed concerns about the safety of the convictions as “noise”.

The inquiry, which opened in Liverpool last month, had previously heard how concerns raised by colleagues over the nurse's behaviour were “initially ignored," with accusers "actively bullied” over claims.

It comes as Letby’s barrister revealed that the nurse's application challenging verdicts is being prepared using expert medical evidence

This undated handout issued by Cheshire Constabulary shows of nurse Lucy Letby. A British neonatal nurse who was convicted of murdering seven babies and the attempted murder of six others has lost her bid to appeal. (Cheshire Constabulary via AP)
This undated handout issued by Cheshire Constabulary shows of nurse Lucy Letby. A British neonatal nurse who was convicted of murdering seven babies and the attempted murder of six others has lost her bid to appeal. (Cheshire Constabulary via AP). Picture: Alamy

Information obtained by The Guardian has now revealed that a review by Cheshire Constabulary discovered that the door-swipe figures were used as evidence relating to eight other children.

However, they deemed the errors to have no significant impact on the convictions, with the Crime Prosecution Service (CPS) deeming the data had “no meaningful impact” on the trial.

The new information comes as the Thirlwall Inquiry heard last week that another door into the neonatal unit existed, where members of paediatric staff could have entered without the data being recorded.

Read more: ‘Outpouring of comments’ about killer nurse Lucy Letty’s convictions ‘distressing for victims’ parents,’ inquiry hears

Read more: Child serial killer Lucy Letby will challenge latest conviction in court next month

The inquiry had previously revealed hospital bosses made a doctor apologise to Lucy Letby over claims he called her a murderer years before she was eventually arrested, an inquiry heard.

The judge had previously warned that questions raised over the killer nurse's conviction were becoming increasingly distressing for the parents whose children had died or been harmed in her care.

Dr Murthy Saledi, a consultant working at the Countess of Chester Hospital at the time of the deaths, told the hearing that neonatal rota data alone was insufficient.

He flagged that a second door into the paediatric unit existed and was regularly used by the killer nurse.

Chair of the inquiry Lady Justice Thirlwall at Liverpool Town Hall, ahead of hearings into the murders and attempted murders of babies by nurse Lucy Letby.
Chair of the inquiry Lady Justice Thirlwall at Liverpool Town Hall, ahead of hearings into the murders and attempted murders of babies by nurse Lucy Letby. Picture: Alamy

Lucy Letby, widely considered to be Britain’s most prolific killer of children, is currently serving 15 whole-life orders after she was convicted at Manchester Crown Court of murdering seven infants and attempting to murder seven others between June 2015 and June 2016.

It comes as Letby prepares to bring an appeal against her conviction for attempted murder which was handed down in July.

It follows comments from the chairwoman of the Lucy Letby inquiry who said those raising doubts about the former nurse's conviction have caused "enormous additional distress" to the parents.

Lady Justice Thirlwall told the hearing the speculation is coming from people who were not at the trial.

Some claim that Letby's verdict is reliant on faulty evidence and have cast doubt on the safety of her conviction.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Polling station at Deptford Park School.

Russian networks tried to disrupt UK election but did not cause ‘notable’ impact, security minister says

IKEA store in Vilnius, Lithuania

Russian spies accused of firebombing Ikea store ‘because colours are the same as the Ukraine flag’

Facial recognition will be used to help passengers skip passport queues at ports.

British travellers arriving back in UK could 'avoid passport queues' with new facial recognition technology

The White House said Trump is ‘determined’ to get a peace deal in Ukraine over the line, as the US president gears up for talks for Vladimir Putin on Tuesday.

‘We’ve never been closer to a peace deal’ in Ukraine, says White House ahead of Trump-Putin talks

A prison officer walks down the C wing at Wandsworth prison.

Number of prisoners reaches six-month high, despite thousands being released early to ease overcrowding

Richard Burrows, 80, was found guilty of 54 offences at Chester Crown Court on Monday, including indecent assault of boys, buggery, attempted buggery and indecency with a child.

Paedophile scout leader who spent 27 years on the run found guilty of dozens child sex abuse crimes

‘Iran will suffer the consequences’ - Trump raises prospect of war with Iran as Us attacks on Houthis continue

‘Iran will suffer the consequences’ - Trump raises prospect of war with Iran as US attacks on Houthis continue

Owen Cooper (l) and Stephen Graham (r) star in Adolescence

Revealed: Secret behind incredible camera shot in Netflix's new 'masterpiece' Adolescence

Drag star The Vivienne died after taking ketamine, their family said today

Drag star The Vivienne died from cardiac arrest caused by taking ketamine, family say

Irish professional mixed martial artist and businessman Conor McGregor visited the White House on Monday.

‘He doesn’t reflect the spirit of St Patrick’s Day’: Row erupts after Conor McGregor appears in The White House

`

Man who shouted 'Die, die, die' while stabbing man in quiet street in broad daylight sentenced to life

Harry Purcell, 17, Matilda 'Tilly' Seccombe, 16, and Frank Wormald, 16 died in the crash

Teen driver who killed three friends, aged 16 and 17, in crash on way home from school faces years in prison

Princess Kate enjoyed a Guinness as she joined soldiers in the cookhouse

Princess of Ales! Kate buys a round for the Irish Guards at St Patrick’s Day parade

Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer holds a press conference in the Downing Street Briefing Room after hosting virtual meeting with international leaders to discuss support for Ukraine.

Trump to speak with Putin tomorrow as Starmer says 30 countries will sign up to peacekeeping plan

Yvette Cooper argued against the decision but it was upheld

Albanian criminal 'avoids deportation because video calls would be ‘harsh’ on stepson'

Keir Starmer

Overhauling 'unsustainable' benefits 'makes moral and economic sense', ministers insist, amid brewing Labour revolt