Govt failed to protect care home residents from Covid when sending patients from hospital

27 April 2022, 10:53 | Updated: 27 April 2022, 16:24

Thousands of elderly and disabled care home residents died after being infected with Covid
Thousands of elderly and disabled care home residents died after being infected with Covid. Picture: Alamy

By Emma Soteriou

The Government failed to protect thousands of elderly and disabled care home residents who died after being infected with Covid, the High Court has ruled.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The policy of discharging patients from hospital to care homes when early on in the pandemic did not take into account the risk to vulnerable residents in homes from asymptomatic transmission.

In a ruling on Wednesday, Lord Justice Bean and Mr Justice Garnham concluded that policies contained in documents released in March and early April 2020 were unlawful because they failed to take into account the risk to elderly and vulnerable residents from non-symptomatic transmission of the virus.

They said that, despite there being "growing awareness" of the risk of asymptomatic transmission throughout March 2020, there was no evidence that then health secretary Matt Hancock addressed the issue of the risk to care home residents of such transmission.

The ruling said: "In our judgment, this was not a binary question, a choice between on the one hand doing nothing at all, and on the other hand requiring all newly admitted residents to be quarantined.

"The document could, for example, have said that where an asymptomatic patient, other than one who has tested negative, is admitted to a care home, he or she should, so far as practicable, be kept apart from other residents for up to 14 days.

"Since there is no evidence that this question was considered by the Secretary of State, or that he was asked to consider it, it is not an example of a political judgment on a finely balanced issue.

"Nor is it a point on which any of the expert committees had advised that no guidance was required.

"The drafters of the documents of March 17 and April 2 simply failed to take into account the highly relevant consideration of the risk to elderly and vulnerable residents from asymptomatic transmission."

Read more: Hepatitis outbreak in children 'could be down to years of Covid lockdowns'

Read more: 'Don't take the risk': Warning after kids hospitalised from eating Kinder Easter chocolate

"We sent people with Covid back to care homes"

Two women whose fathers died from Covid welcomed the ruling after taking the case to court.

Dr Cathy Gardner, 60, and Fay Harris, 58, both said Boris Johnson should resign as a result.

"I think absolutely the Prime Minister should resign," said Dr Gardner.

"There are so many reasons why the Prime Minister should resign."

Ms Harris added: "I think Boris Johnson should resign - because of this and for other reasons."

Mr Johnson has also been under fire over the Partygate scandal, where he allegedly attended several gatherings during the pandemic.

He has faced several calls from opposition parties to step down, particularly after he and Chancellor Rishi Sunak were fined over a birthday bash in June 2020.

The PM said during PMQs on Wednesday that he wanted to "renew my apologies and sympathies for all those who lost loved ones during the pandemic".

He added: "The thing we didn't know in particular was that Covid could be transmitted asymptomatically in the way that it was and that was something that I wish we had known more about at the time."

A spokesman for former health secretary Matt Hancock said: "This court case comprehensively clears ministers of any wrongdoing and finds Mr Hancock acted reasonably on all counts.

"The court also found that PHE (Public Health England) failed to tell ministers what they knew about asymptomatic transmission.

"Mr Hancock has frequently stated how he wished this had been brought to his attention earlier.

"Mr Hancock's thoughts are with everyone who lost loved ones, and we must ensure that all the right lessons are learned."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Universal has confirmed it's opening its first European theme park in Bedfordshire

Universal theme park set to open in Bedfordshire in 2031 in multi-billion pound boost for economy

Serial Killer Conviction Prompts Police To Warn Of Dating App Dangers

Paedophiles targeting single mums on dating apps in order to exploit their children

Exclusive
Sir Steve Redgrave has called for an urgent cleanup of the River Thames

Sir Steve Redgrave calls for clean-up of River Thames ahead of Oxford-Cambridge boat race

Glenn Armstrong bombarded the woman with unwanted messages prior to breaking into her Spennymoor home at around 4am on Thursday, January 2.

Stalker who bombarded ex with messages jailed for breaking into her home - after police find him at top of stairs with knife

Barry Dawson, 60, was killed after being shot through his front window, police have said

'Popular' County Durham dad, 60, was 'shot through his front window', police confirm

Esme Baker, 10, and her father, Lee Baker, 48, were killed in the fire

Fire at caravan park that killed father, 48, and daughter, 10, was 'accidental', investigation finds

Gladiators star Zack George, known as Steel, has revealed that his baby son has died.

Gladiators star reveals heartbreaking loss as baby boy dies days after being born prematurely

Boy, 15, and girl, 13, guilty of manslaughter following the death of Leicester pensioner Bhim Kohli

Bhim Kohli's teenage killers 'humiliated' pensioner in 'brutal and cruel' attack, says heartbroken daughter

Close up of a Police logo on a police officers uniform in Leeds,WEst Yorkshire,UK

Norwegian teenager arrested after being caught with guns in Yorkshire hotel room

x

UK should not 'jump in with both feet' to retaliate against Trump trade tariffs, PM urges

Wahib

'Jealous and controlling husband' who tried to cut wife's head off before leaving her to bleed to death jailed for life

Ashbourne Derbyshire England UK.

Two dead after aircraft crash in Derbyshire, as police tell public to avoid the area

The Government must “invest in childhood” or risk losing the next generation to poor mental health, a charity has warned.

Invest in childhood ‘or risk losing a generation to poor mental health’, charity warns

US-ECONOMY-MARKET-STOCKS

Relief for financial markets as stocks rebound from historic losses days on from tariff turmoil

XL Bullies Being Walked On Private Land After Ban

XL Bully mauled two people after being ordered to ‘kill’ by owner as victims left with 'horrific injuries'

Kerri Pegg, former governor of HMP Kirkham,

Prison governor guilty of misconduct after relationship with drug boss 'Jesse Pinkman' who gifted her £12k Mercedes