MPs should be banned from bringing 'distracting' babies into Commons, review says

30 June 2022, 07:53

Stella Creasy has previously taken both her son and daughter into the Chamber.
Stella Creasy has previously taken both her son and daughter into the Chamber. Picture: Alamy

By Sophie Barnett

Babies should be banned from the Commons chamber during debates after MPs complained that it would be a distraction, a parliamentary committee has ruled.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The ruling by the House of Commons procedures committee comes after there was outcry over Labour's Stella Creasy being told she can no longer have her baby son with her.

The MP for Walthamstow was reprimanded after she brought her three-month-old son, Pip, into the Chamber last year.

He was strapped to her as she rose to ask the then Commons Leader Jacob Rees-Mogg to ensure mothers were supported rather than "rebuked" when returning to Parliament after maternity leave.

Mr Rees-Mogg said in response he thought the rules were "perfectly reasonable and entirely in line with the law".

Ms Creasy had regularly taken her son and previously her daughter into the Commons Chamber, as babies have been allowed in the past.

Read more: Row breaks out after Labour MP Stella Creasy told her baby isn't allowed in Commons

Read more: MP barred from bringing baby to Commons hits out at 'system built for men'

Labour MP Stella Creasy speaks to James O'Brien amid baby row

She told LBC's James O'Brien that barring babies from the House of Commons could "cut" people from politics because the system and its policies are "built" for men with no child-caring responsibilities.

She said not allowing women to care for children as well as play an active role in politics could lead to women not running to be MPs, or constituents not voting for them.

"I don't have maternity cover so there really isn't anybody else who can do [my job], and that faces an impossible position where either my son get my attention or my constituents are denied a voice for six months whilst I take maternity leave."

The Procedures Committee ruled that MPs should not bring babies into the chamber or nearby Westminster Hall if they want to "observe, initiate, speak or intervene in proceedings".

Stella Creasy took her three-month-old son Pip into the Chamber last year.
Stella Creasy took her three-month-old son Pip into the Chamber last year. Picture: Alamy

But they said there should be a "degree of de-facto discretion" that "should be exercised sparingly".

Ms Creasy said she hoped the review would allow " parenting and politics possible to mix".

She said she was shocked when Commons authorities emailed her rules prohibiting bringing children to debates after she took Pip into Westminster Hall.

Her son, who was just three-months-old, was "good as gold" during the debate, according to MPs.

Many MPs came out in support of the mother-of-two, with deputy prime minister Dominic Raab saying he had "a lot of sympathy" for her and that he would not be distracted by a baby.

But Tory MP Alicia Kearns argued the chamber is "no place" for a baby.

"I've asked to leave debates to feed my child a few times - I have never been turned down," she said.

The previous year Sir Lindsay said he "wouldn't be upset by" a mother dividing to breastfeed in the chamber.

But the committee's report said it was a "long-standing practice" underpinned by previous rulings that "babies should not be present".

They noted there had been "several occasions" when MPs had brought babies into debates "without disruption", but this had "contributed to some confusion and a gap" between the practice and the rules.

Ms Creasy said that she was "not surprised" by the recommendation.

She said: "This committee didn't speak to a single person outside Parliament despite many of us encouraging them to do so, so I'm not surprised they don't recognise who is put off Parliament by its antiquated rules and approach to women who have children and the need to modernise.

Read more: 'Your child is a boy or girl': Tory MP says parents should 'not give in' to trans kids

'Posh' environment of modern politics 'off-putting' to ordinary women

"They are not alone in working like this - in the last year we've seen no progress on Parliament having any form of adequate maternity or paternity policy in place, and no progress from IPSA (Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority) on providing proper maternity or paternity funding either.

"Change will only come when we start listening to those outside the status quo."

The committee did, however, back on the "overwhelming balance of evidence" the extension of proxy voting for "serious long-term illness".

Karen Bradley, the Conservative MP who chairs the committee, said a debate should be scheduled in the coming weeks to discuss the extension of proxy voting.

"On the balance of evidence received, the committee also recommends that current rules remain and members should not bring babies into the House of Commons chamber or Westminster Hall proceedings," she added.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Who is Aaron Taylor-Johnson?

Who is Aaron Taylor-Johnson the man expected to become James Bond and what films has he been in?

Australia Cyber Safety

Google, Meta and others face questions in Australia over cyber extremism threats

Police were called to Harrow Road, Wollaton, Nottingham, on the evening on 14 March

Man, 27, charged with attempted murder after man and woman stabbed at home in Nottingham

People-Ariana Grande

Ariana Grande and Dalton Gomez divorce after nearly three years

Kate and William were pictured visiting a farm shop in Windsor together

'Remarkable' Princess of Wales deserves privacy as she recovers, minister says as video emerges of farm shop trip

Japan Economy

Japanese central bank raises interest rate for first time in 17 years

Exclusive
The incident happened at the Harbour

Police refuse to investigate NHS worker who filmed and shared video of naked patient

The new football regulator is set to be introduced

Football regulator to 'put fan voices front and centre', but Premier League warns against 'weakening competition'

Aaron Taylor-Johnson is said to have been chosen as the new James Bond actor

Aaron Taylor-Johnson 'chosen as new James Bond', with actor 'to sign deal to take over from Daniel Craig this week'

File photo of a dentist

Hardly any dentists think government's plan to fix NHS dentistry will work, survey finds

The Queen alongside her grandchildren and great-grandchildren

Revealed: Princess of Wales' photo of Queen Elizabeth II, grandchildren and great-grandchildren was also edited

United Nations Nuclear Weapons

US and Japan seek UN resolution banning nuclear weapons in outer space

Keir Starmer has doubled down on his calls for an election as soon as possible

Keir Starmer vows to 'fix broken Britain' as he repeats calls for general election as soon as possible

Harry and Meghan have been demoted on the site

Harry and Meghan's profiles 'downgraded' on Buckingham Palace website alongside Prince Andrew

The government saw off 10 amendments from peers to the Safety of Rwanda Bill

MPs reject Rwanda Bill amendments as Sunak faces fresh battle with Lords over migrant plan

Election 2024 Trump

‘Impossible’ for Trump to post civil fraud bond of £356m, say lawyers